Baumard and AndrΓ© (B&A) responded to the (many) comments that their original piece (www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti...).
Their response is linked in Alberto's post. I just got a pdf copy and will read it now; this will be a thread with my first thoughts...
09.03.2026 23:07 β
π 5
π 2
π¬ 1
π 0
For more from Baumard and AndrΓ©, keep your eyes on Hunter-Gatherer Research.
09.03.2026 23:48 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Certainly this will standardise our language and revolutionise our science - but have lego considered what this might do to our systems of government?
09.03.2026 01:48 β
π 3
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
Certainly this will standardise our language and revolutionise our science - but have lego considered what this might do to our systems of government?
09.03.2026 01:48 β
π 3
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
The basic tools of military action are things that would be horrorific crimes in civilian life. A war crime is an act so egregious that it stands out against that background. Somehow we never have that conversation honestly before we go to war.
08.03.2026 13:57 β
π 167
π 33
π¬ 0
π 0
08.03.2026 01:39 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Ack, but what if I only believed I had the Power to Defeat. Defeated by my own defeater!
06.03.2026 19:14 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
My close friends and family *are not ready* to have their mental states defeated by my Newly Acquired Power To Defeat.
06.03.2026 19:11 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
Muttering "I am become death destroyer of worlds" as I copy "Rebutting, Undercutting, and No Reason Defeaters" onto an Anki flash card.
06.03.2026 19:08 β
π 4
π 2
π¬ 1
π 0
I LOVE when science is applied to "toddler questions" like "Why is the sky blue?" or "Why is ice slippery?"
Because the answers can be so SUPRISING.
Let's dig into recent revelations about how ice skates work & why tires skid across black ice.
First, we'll dismiss 3 VERY GOOD hypotheses as wrong.
20.02.2026 13:35 β
π 176
π 67
π¬ 3
π 5
π§ͺπ€©Have a look at our new preprint using an agent-based model to explore the issue of how, whether and when can one infer social dynamics from archaeological assemblagesπ€©π§ͺ
05.03.2026 11:17 β
π 12
π 3
π¬ 0
π 0
I think that image might appear in anthropology slides more often than even the Darwin phylogeny drawing
05.03.2026 21:28 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
A digital CAPTCHA verification window titled "Select all squares with PIPES" against a plain white background. The window contains a 3Γ3 grid of numbered squares, mixing literal hardware, smoking pipes, and programming syntax.
These captchas just keep getting harder #rstats
05.03.2026 15:58 β
π 618
π 140
π¬ 8
π 2
It sucks but I suppose we just have to suck it up π¬
05.03.2026 20:26 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Certain parts of this course have obviously left a more enduring impression than have others.
05.03.2026 20:20 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
Questioning some key career decisions made by my younger self as I tap out this sentence.
05.03.2026 20:14 β
π 8
π 0
π¬ 3
π 0
Looking forward to Jamie Tehrani's guest lecture in my cultural analytics course, open to everybody. If you are in Trento and want to know more about cultural evolution, that is a great opportunity! eventi.unitn.it/en/origins-s...
05.03.2026 08:32 β
π 13
π 5
π¬ 1
π 0
Please join us next Thursday, 12th March at 13:00, for our next talk of the semester, given by Dr VΓ‘clav HrnΔΓΕ!
If you would like to attend, please register here: events.teams.microsoft.com/event/e289a4...
More details below π
We hope to see you there!
05.03.2026 14:29 β
π 3
π 1
π¬ 0
π 1
Really nice write-up in @psypost.bsky.social about the recent study with @kris-smith.bsky.social.
Of course, there is *also* regular generosity, but like Woodburn and (most) others I believe that active demands and negotiations do the heavy lifting.
04.03.2026 21:49 β
π 8
π 2
π¬ 0
π 1
I'm not so sure that "equity is achieved through bargaining" necessarily conflicts with what many on that side of the political spectrum are saying - but our work does challenge the tendency to idealize.
04.03.2026 23:05 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
Interlibrary loan is a great resource for getting you hands on old, out-of-print books. Our library gets us (scanned) copies of quite obscure papers in edited volumes in a very timely way.
04.03.2026 22:04 β
π 2
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
I can't see a good midterm solution to this which doesn't involve shadowlibraries like libgen and anna's archive; but in 40ish years when the copyright expires on some of these 80s texts, there will be a bounty of hunter-gatherer information previously locked away.
04.03.2026 23:03 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
I'm lucky enough to be able to throw some of my startup at old books, but thanks for drawing my attention to this - which I shall no doubt use in time.
The bigger metascientific problem is that any friction makes work less represented general citation networks and the general academic consciousness
04.03.2026 23:00 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
Really nice write-up in @psypost.bsky.social about the recent study with @kris-smith.bsky.social.
Of course, there is *also* regular generosity, but like Woodburn and (most) others I believe that active demands and negotiations do the heavy lifting.
04.03.2026 21:49 β
π 8
π 2
π¬ 0
π 1
One of the best in our small discipline. Gently encouraging @vivek123.bsky.social to use LUP's post-print policy to share the recent interview we ran with Bob in HGR in advance of this talk.
www.liverpooluniversitypress.co.uk/doi/10.3828/...
04.03.2026 21:19 β
π 3
π 2
π¬ 0
π 0
I don't think anything has hurt Kalahari ethnography (and Hunter-Gatherer Research broadly) quite so much as its reliance on printed volumes. There's so much extremely important work which is locked in special interest, out-of-print volumes from the 80s that are $100+ on amazon.
04.03.2026 21:16 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
Alex has been cooking as well. What are we doing?
04.03.2026 20:43 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0