Being Pro-Housing Isnβt Comfortable
But great politicians are comfortable being uncomfortable.
Twitter was really bad for my brain. It was fun for a time, but it became overall really toxic and anxiety-inducong for me. And "micro-blogging" in general is not good for me.
I do enjoy substack though, so I'm making that an intentional part of my 2026!
open.substack.com/pub/politics...
28.12.2025 04:45 β
π 6
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
From left to right, Sarah Goodyear, Laura Foot, Rashi Kesarwani, Adhiti Bandlamudi, Scott Weiner and Doug Gordon standing in front of big bright screen on stage.
Especially great to talk with @yimbylaura.bsky.social, Berkeley Councilmember Rashi Kesarwani, KQED's Adhiti Bandlamudi, and CA State Senator @scottwiener.bsky.social about politics and media in the fight to make cities more affordable, sustainable, safe, and just.
26.10.2025 05:59 β
π 57
π 2
π¬ 2
π 3
Started writing this on the bus, riding with 3 seniors, two other families with young children, two college students and two high schoolers on their way to/from field hockey.
Arrived at the toy store so we can witness firsthand how much kids hate transit oriented neighborhoods.
01.06.2025 20:44 β
π 2
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Things that help families:
- building homes in high resource areas, esp with transit
- funding public transportation
Things that do NOT help families:
- blocking homes causing rent to rise
- blocking homes causing families to move away
- blocking homes causing teacher shortages
- BLOCKING HOMES
01.06.2025 19:48 β
π 41
π 5
π¬ 2
π 0
NIMBYs have this fantasy that somehow parents and disabled people need cars, and they are "saving" us from the bus.
In fact, any day of the week, you can ride the bus and meet hundreds of people in wheelchairs or with strollers who depend on transit to make their lives work.
01.06.2025 19:45 β
π 11
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
As a disabled parent, I am simply begging NIMBYs to stop trying to "help" me by making it more expensive to live in transit oriented neighborhoods by blocking housing.
01.06.2025 19:26 β
π 132
π 21
π¬ 2
π 0
Lobby Day Wrapped image
π LOBBY DAY WRAPPED π
β
22 advocates
ποΈ 38 legislator meetings
π¬ 47 offices contacted
ποΈ 28 Chicagoland lawmakers
πΌ 12 legislative leaders:
πΉ 10 House Leaders
πΉ 2 Senate Leaders
π 1 Cook County President
ποΈ 1 Governor
π Legislative wins:
β 3 new co-sponsors for HB 1813
β 3 new co-sponsors for HB 1814
16.05.2025 01:16 β
π 74
π 10
π¬ 3
π 1
Community-Benefits-Playbook-Draft.pdf
I have heard they've changed the name from "Community Benefits Playbook" because it was too on the nose.
drive.google.com/file/d/1-gEQ...
06.05.2025 22:50 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Here's where they tee up that we're going to have to go back to a normal system where we have predictable taxes that are then spent on government aka "community benefits."
We'll have to have a democratic process where we decide where our taxes should go, rather then capricious side-deal-making!
06.05.2025 22:50 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
You should definately read the entire thing, but here's the good news about how reducing arbitrary - I mean discretionary - processes means that the project-by-project negotiation racket is being curtailed in San Francisco:
06.05.2025 22:50 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
I wrote a blog post a few weeks ago about how the "community benefits" negotiation game with housing developers sure does rhyme with the Trump Tariff Negotiation Process, and an amazing person who wanted to remain anonymous sent me this GEM of a draft document from SF's Planning Department...
06.05.2025 22:50 β
π 2
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
π₯
01.05.2025 21:10 β
π 22
π 3
π¬ 0
π 0
Why is That YIMBY Party 1970s themed?
Because the median home price in California back then was $41,000 and a bag of magic beans.
onecau.se/_9crf91
01.05.2025 23:09 β
π 2
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
Politicians Rarely Lie
Yes, Iβm serious.
"If a politician wonβt say their position in public, they wonβt vote for it in public either."
inpractice.yimbyaction.org/p/politician...
02.05.2025 03:16 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Big props to Senate Pro Tem Mike McGuire for selecting her as chair of the housing committee, breaking the streak of housing champions in that seat. Masterful gambit, sir.
22.04.2025 21:39 β
π 56
π 7
π¬ 1
π 1
Most cities treat zoning as the beginning of a negotiation. Zoning is so restrictive, so obviously impossible to use as written, that planners and city councils have a process where developers beg for changes. After months of negotiations, βbenevolentβ planning commissions and city councils will offer zoning concessions to those who have successfully fought for their favor.
Smart, well-connected developers become experts at navigating these formal systems with informal practices. They know which community groups need to be met with. They know which city council members will need to be shown how the project benefits their district. They learn to bundle sweet Community Benefit Packages with beautiful presentations about their community-serving amenities. These elaborate negotiation games create delays, increase costs, decrease units and height, and, in the end, can lead to abandoned projects. And it creates a much smaller industry of savvy developers and consultants whose competitive advantage is their deep knowledge of whoβs back needs scratching.
Sure, we might let you build a new apartment building, but have you considered donating to the local parks fund? How about some money for the buses? What about building a little extra space for a politically-favored nonprofit to have an office β and what about not charging them very much rent?
But instead of having clear set rules about what we require of developers, these lengthy processes ends up giving leverage to whoever can jam things up the most. And we know that this process ends up benefitting whiter and wealthier citizens. The uncertain and inconsistent decision-making process allows for the βextraction of benefits,β which is why so many city planners and residents love it. After all, who doesnβt like putting the squeeze on your perceived enemies?
But the cost of this extraction process is high. Bespoke negotiations drives up the cost of housing and slow down production. As a 2016 report by the American Planning Association put it, βdiscretionary approvals are time-consuming and costly, and discretionary review processes often culminate in uncertain, inconsistent, and unpredictable decisions.β One study found that by-right projects were permitted 28% faster than discretionary projects. Another argued that βa key driver of higher housing costs in the state is the development costs associated with lengthy entitlement processes. Californiaβs entitlement process is unusually complicated and cumbersome: the permitting process for new development in coastal communities in California takes a third longer than in the average American city.β
How do we get real estate developers to stop attempting to work the system? Make it predictable, uniform, and boring!
If we want developers out of politics, we need to take the politics out of development.
We ought to zone for the housing we need. The rules should be clear and built to achieve the goal of an accessible, affordable community. Once that zoning is in place, cities have to allow housing to get built without separate, bespoke negotiations. That's no way to run a city.
Great article by @yimbylaura.bsky.social on how discretionary approval slows down and increases the cost of housing as developers buy out wealthy, well-connected residents at great expense.
Permitting should be predictable, uniform, and boring!
inpractice.yimbyaction.org/p/what-trump...
13.04.2025 14:16 β
π 4
π 4
π¬ 0
π 1
Finding A Pro-Housing Governor: Candidate Speaker Series w/ Toni Atkins
Join YIMBY Action for a casual conversation about the housing priorities of Toni Atkins as she runs for Governor in 2026
Join us for our inaugural event in this exclusive series on April 16th in San Francisco, featuring Toni Atkins in conversation with YIMBY Action Executive Director @yimbylaura.bsky.social
www.eventbrite.com/e/finding-a-...
04.04.2025 15:36 β
π 1
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
The Political Fight of the Century
For the first time in decades, America has a chance to define its next political order. Trump offers fear, retribution, and scarcity. Liberals can stand for abundance.
Next week I'm in Atlanta interviewing Abundance co-author @dkthomp.bsky.social at the Georgia Center for the Book in Atlanta. (Grab your ticket!)
He makes very similar points in this article and I can't wait to dig in with him about the future of the democracy.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archiv...
27.03.2025 20:03 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Abundance Isnβt Going To Happen Unless Politicians Are Scared of the Status Quo
Itβs A Race Between Building Up and Burning Down
Like everyone, I'm reading Abundance and having my takes:
"Little by little, we stitched together a gigantic wet blanket that continues to hold back housing production. Itβs easy to blame liberals, but like all of our worst problems, it was bipartisan."
inpractice.yimbyaction.org/p/abundance-...
27.03.2025 20:03 β
π 1
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Best new rage-bait we found from Sebastopol:
βIβm just not about to be a part of it,β said one member of the council, after a unanimous vote to ignore their RHNA obligations, an answer that is both completely wrongheaded and honestly a little iconic.
inpractice.yimbyaction.org/p/the-way-ca...
11.03.2025 16:26 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
The Way California Requires Local Governments To Plan For New Housing Is Complete Nonsense. This Underwater House In Sausalito Shows Why.
Passing good laws is one thing. Implementing them is another.
I'm getting on the substack bandwagon!
One of the best/worst examples of how a law *designed* to be a nightmare to implement is the CA Housing Element system.
Hopefully this convinces states considering adopting a "fair share" law that there be dragons!
inpractice.yimbyaction.org/p/the-way-ca...
11.03.2025 16:26 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
@sfacc.bsky.social what's the latest with the bleeding husky dog loose in the Castro? Did you manage to catch him?
09.03.2025 21:08 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
RSVP to Architecture Tour of Historic North Beach | Partiful
Ah, beautiful, historic North Beach. You've heard of famous spots like Coit Tower, Tony's Pizza, Vesuvio Cafe, and City Lights Bookstore.
But you've probably never heard of the real hidden, historic...
To say that the only way to build a lot of housing would be to demolish existing multi-family housing demonstrates such a lack of spacial parking awareness. Like, are they parking-lot-blind?
Luckily @wafoli.bsky.social has the perfect tour for the parking-blind.
partiful.com/e/66eMyfOBhl...
01.03.2025 21:24 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Putting aside the outright lies about how there are already tenant protections in the pro-housing bills, because the people who want more housing care about the class of renters...
01.03.2025 21:24 β
π 0
π 0
π¬ 1
π 0
My landlord (illegally) replaced our windows with new ones that are so so so much safer. They even have built-in child safety locks!
"Preservationists" is a generous term for people who want to control everyone around them at any expense.
27.02.2025 21:58 β
π 2
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Happy Hanukkah!
26.12.2024 01:20 β
π 3
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
We're having a very Merry Muni Christmas, taking the bus to the grandparents!
Reminder: public transportation is way better for families than free parking!
25.12.2024 17:29 β
π 1
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
It is at this special time of year when we remember to tell the stranger to get out and stay out.
24.12.2024 20:58 β
π 2
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0