This article was amended on 5 March 2026. An earlier version said low-skilled workers would “receive immediate access to welfare and social housing” if Labour did not make them wait longer to apply for settlement. In fact, settlement status only gives people the eligibility to apply for welfare and social housing, it does not give them instant or automatic access to such benefits. This has been clarified.
From breaking news to huge investigative proje
Guardian has now [after my complaint] corrected Mahmood's deliberate & incendiary false claim settlement gives immigrants "immediate access to welfare and social housing".
Good for Gdn but embarrassing/shameful that Home Secretary deliberately misled the public for political gain like this.
05.03.2026 16:45 —
👍 104
🔁 49
💬 6
📌 2
Shabana Mahmood accused of mimicking Trump as she announces asylum plans
Home secretary’s proposals to overhaul immigration system include end to permanent refugee status
The Home Secretary has made claims which are not true regarding migrants to push policies which will devastate lives, while increasing exploitation and people forced into becoming undocumented. These are not policies of "fairness", but instead of discrimination.
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026...
05.03.2026 16:49 —
👍 15
🔁 9
💬 0
📌 1
But:
Protect paedophile Epstein's mates - rapists and torturers - in the Epstein files?
ICE kills people?
Support genocidal regimes e.g.: Putin in Ukraine; Netanyahu issued arrest warrant for war crimes in Gaza by Intl Criminal Court?
Promote a Board of Peace which consists of human rights' abusers?
05.03.2026 16:52 —
👍 0
🔁 0
💬 0
📌 0
Brave strategy to face down popularism with unpopularism.
05.03.2026 16:09 —
👍 23
🔁 2
💬 1
📌 0
The inhuman deciding who is human.
05.03.2026 15:08 —
👍 34
🔁 13
💬 6
📌 0
Secretary Noem acknowledges ICE and CBP can't shoot Americans for peacefully protesting, videotaping ICE officers or lawfully carrying a firearm, and yet her agents are routinely violating the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. There is a total leadership breakdown requiring immediate change.
05.03.2026 14:23 —
👍 1479
🔁 467
💬 63
📌 26
Jeffries: "Article 1 of the Constitution provides Congress with the sole authority to declare war. Framers made that decision b/c they were concerned about kings plunging their people into unnecessary wars to pillage resources of others for the benefit of a tyrant and his family. Sound familiar?"
04.03.2026 21:06 —
👍 7051
🔁 2095
💬 248
📌 85
I’ve written about this excellent piece before in my own take on Labour’s “midlife crisis“ but this really was the warning sign from almost six months ago that the data was saying something very different from Number 10’s rhetoric.
05.03.2026 08:44 —
👍 44
🔁 15
💬 5
📌 1
If there is evidence of irregularities at some polling stations at the Gorton and Denton byelection, then that evidence should be properly and promptly investigated in accordance with due process by the proper authorities. And that is what is being done. Any denunciations of the election result should thereby await the result of this process.
The losing party spokesperson candidly admitted the day after the election that any irregularities were not enough to have affected the result, which was emphatic. But this did not prevent the losing party’s leader from loudly promoting grave allegations of sectarian voting, corruption and dishonesty. Yet if the irregularities are not upheld on investigation as invalidating the result, it is unlikely that those findings will be shouted about.
And such a response is irresponsible. Parts of the United Kingdom have a history of sectarian violence. Parts of the United Kingdom have histories of racial tension. Responsible politicians should not exploit such allegations for partisan advantage. Making such allegations is to play with fire, literally.
Responsible politicians should be careful to avoid subverting the very fundamentals on which a functioning democracy rests. Such “poisoning of the wells” is familiar to those following the politics of the United States, and it lay behind the lethal violence that took place in Washington DC on 6th January 2021.
New
The poisoning of the wells
Why discrediting election results without waiting for due process is unhealthy for a democracy
This week's Weekly Constitutional by me at @prospectmagazine.co.uk
05.03.2026 11:55 —
👍 268
🔁 101
💬 9
📌 5
Address is guardian.readers@theguardian.com
05.03.2026 12:38 —
👍 29
🔁 16
💬 1
📌 0
Trump’s Orwellian Board of Peace Consists Entirely of Human Rights Abusers
An Intercept analysis finds that every single Board of Peace member state has been rebuked for human rights violations.
Trump’s Orwellian Board of Peace Consists Entirely of Human Rights Abusers: every single Board of Peace member state has been rebuked for human rights violations writes @theintercept.com.
Empowering autocrats: the new US foreign policy ⚡️
theintercept.com/2026/03/02/t...
05.03.2026 13:36 —
👍 5
🔁 2
💬 0
📌 2
Hi! Immigration lawyer here! Mahmood's view of the Refugee Convention as providing temporary protection just isn’t correct & AFAIK isn’t one anyone has ever adopted.
On the contrary, the Convention is clearly predicated on a long-term need for protection.
1/🧵
05.03.2026 13:28 —
👍 116
🔁 71
💬 3
📌 3
Should have had a Policy Exchange backdrop?
Goodhart hosted PE's Blue Labour event promoting Danish 'tough' policy!
[Even Trevor Phillips when chair of the Commission for Racial Equality, described his arguments as being those of "liberal Powellites", after the Conservative politician Enoch Powell.]
05.03.2026 13:37 —
👍 0
🔁 0
💬 1
📌 0
@news.sky.com promote Blue Labour's Shabana working with Policy Exhange on "tough" immigration policies as brave to do 45mins with Trevor Phillips - a Snr Fellow of Policy Exchange! Normalised ppl at Tommy Robinson rally with this far-right line-up! But protests against genocide are 'hate marches'?
05.03.2026 13:08 —
👍 0
🔁 0
💬 1
📌 1
People who are not tax resident in the UK should not be allowed to donate to UK political parties.
Companies should not be allowed to donate to UK political parties.
No one should be allowed to use crypto to donate to UK political parties.
05.03.2026 11:39 —
👍 397
🔁 165
💬 23
📌 3
There is a better way forward, and that would be to genuinely tackle inequality, nourish strong communities, and stop stoking racist hatred. The politics of fear is cheap and easy but in the end we will all pay a heavy price for it.
05.03.2026 12:00 —
👍 1
🔁 1
💬 0
📌 0
One thing the Home Secretary is right about is that far right politics are indeed “taking hold”. But that is because successive governments have actively legitimised and proudly pursued far right, racist, policies, insisting they are part of our core values.
05.03.2026 12:00 —
👍 1
🔁 1
💬 1
📌 0
Meanwhile the 2024 Labour govt was first govt of either party in history whose electorate was majority pro-immigration in broad terms. Reforms like this just don't make political sense. Obviously policy doesn't have to be popular, but Mahmood claims there is an electoral case for this. There isn't!
05.03.2026 09:34 —
👍 13
🔁 6
💬 2
📌 0
Your regular reminder than a large majority of voters - and overwhelming majority of Labour voters - favour giving settled migrants access to the welfare state after five years or less. The Home Secretary is not reforming rules in line with public opinion. She is doing the opposite.
05.03.2026 08:22 —
👍 571
🔁 228
💬 20
📌 9
Shabana Mahmoud - Reform's not so secret weapon!
05.03.2026 08:08 —
👍 19
🔁 6
💬 0
📌 1
"would otherwise receive immediate access to welfare and social housing" is BS.
Correct: "after 5 years working in a care home, would be eligible to apply for welfare and social housing on the same basis as the rest of us."
www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...
Deliberately misleading/disingenous.
05.03.2026 08:11 —
👍 389
🔁 161
💬 31
📌 19