Bacchuslaureat

It’s really obvious that you are incapable of deviating from some script you’ve prefabricated in your head, no matter how little it applies to the situation at hand. It is genuinely second hand embarrassing to watch.

Are you posting in the wrong thread by mistake because literally nothing you just said made any sense or connected to anything

Are you okay? Why don’t you drink some water, have a salty snack and sit down somewhere cool and shady for a while.

Like, are you an idiot? Are you maybe unaware that patriarchal society doesn’t accept trans identities or something, has that really basic fact eluded you?

I’m not sure if it’s even possible to make the point clear enough that you won’t just walk face forward into it yet again anyway, but binary trans women not only historically get categorized as third gender, they’re the single largest group of people that do. You idiot.

lmao

You are literally doing it rn lmao

I’ll ask you the question you ignored before again:

Where can you find an example of a culture that has a third gender and then also a role for binary trans women as a separate, recognized thing? Tell me where that exists

I like that you’re just continuing to assume that third gender is a synonym for nonbinary with no self awareness despite that wrong assumption being explicitly called out multiple times

A simple example is you repeatedly using “third gender” as just a synonym for “non binary”, which it isn’t even according to the Wikipedia article you cited, and refusing to acknowledge either that that isn’t what the term means or how May was using it, or even that that’s what you’re clearly doing.

I literally tried to get you to clarify your narrative multiple times and you refused to provide coherent clarifications so I don’t know why you think I’m supposed to offer a coherent narrative of what you’re arguing. My entire point was that you were making up nonsense.

The topic was you trying to force a weird constructed narrative onto May that doesn't map to things she actually said, which is why you have to constantly redefine reality on every level, from things that were never said to social constructs that don't exist to definitions no one uses

And once again, “third gender” doesn’t mean “nonbinary”

lmao I gave you an absurdly generous demarcation of premodern

And are you claiming that the US and UK have a recognized third gender? What’s your evidence for that?

Yeah I’m being really generous with my cutoff criteria that you still can’t meet

Or wait is it that by anglophone societies you meant societies that anglophones have actively brutalized? Is that it?

Okay so the answer is that there isn’t one? Cool

As I literally said in that post anything before thirty years ago

But for anglophone societies I would accept any examples whatsoever since lmao that is not a thing that exists. Not unless idk you’re counting India or something.

Oh is there an anglophone culture with a literal, explicit third gender

What is it

Here’s a fun additional exercise for the reader:

Find a single premodern- like, more than thirty years old even- society that “recognizes third gender” but also recognizes binary trans women

I’ll be waiting over here

I mean okay use Wikipedia

Do you understand what being “gendered as other by society” means

Perhaps you can coherently explain what you think third gendering is, but I doubt it

Hint: It's not being nonbinary. It's not another word for nonbinary.

Perhaps you can coherently explain what you think is going on and back that model up with literally any evidence from things that were actually said

But I doubt it

I’ve asked you several questions to try to explain your nonsensical, irrational accusations and you’ve ignored them all to try to shoehorn May into some HSTSwhatever narrative you’ve made up in your head. You’re gibbering nonsense, just pure making stuff up.

She never said that sexual orientation and gender identity are linked. Why are you disagreeing with things no one said?

That’s not the definition of a third gender. Descriptively and historically, a third gender is imposed on people often regardless of how they identify.

AI Actress Tilly Norwood Has Hollywood Fuming. Is She a Threat or a Stunt? Tilly Norwood was created by Eline Van der Velden, a onetime YouTube performer and sketch comedian who is working on a show about AI.

Trying to market your AI-generated character as an "actress" and get studios to pick it up is unironically stupider, worse, and more embarrassing on every level than the Sonichu thing, because at least that represented some spark of personal imagination and interest

variety.com/2025/film/ne...

@goddessblade.bsky.social

Focusing on the fact that Rowling quoted Hitler's words instead of the actual insipid content of her argument is really dumb and just makes her look better, please stop doing it

It requires years of work by a lot of people and actual funding. Real studies of the real world, again even flimsy ones, are incredibly difficult to arrange and beyond the capabilities of just a random person. You can't reason this stuff from first principles.

What do you all think debunking things scientifically entails, do you think it's just staying up late at night doing a think while little numbers float over your head until you shout "eureka"?

Real science, honestly even the junk pseudo science the right peddles, isn't just "hard"

Do you understand that critiquing the premises of a theory requires more than saying that it’s stupid

I think you’re the one who’s deeply unclear about… a lot, actually

Okay so five seconds ago you said you weren't just dismissing it as junk, and when I ask what you're doing to debunk the claims (rather than arguing against the conclusions, which you attacked May for), your answer is... to just dismiss it as junk.

What are you doing here, do you imagine