Mike Lewis

False orthodoxy and fired professors Catholic social media has been abuzz in recent days over the news that three professors at Sacred Heart Seminary in Detroit were dismissed from the faculty by Archbishop Edward Weisenburg. Eduardo Ech...

The removal of three outspoken critics of Pope Francis from Sacred Heart Seminary exposes a deeper crisis in the U.S. Church—where dissent from the Magisterium is masked as fidelity and ideology masquerades as orthodoxy.

wherepeteris.com/false-orthod...

"Ultimately, The Sacred Heart: A Love for All Times by Dawn Eden Goldstein is more than a book about a devotion; it’s a heartfelt invitation to draw closer to Jesus Christ, whose Sacred Heart remains open to each of us."
— @mfjlewis.bsky.social in @wherepeteris.com. wherepeteris.com/rediscoverin....

Trad: “DO SOMETHING Bishops! Less dialogue, more keys! Man up!"

Bishop: “ok your schismatic behavior will no longer be tolerated and you can virtue signal with your frills in the abandoned cafeteria from now on”

Trad: “NOOO Tyrants of NuChurch REPRESSING me, I am JUST LIKE the MARTYRS of OLD!!!"

I see that the Bishop of Winona-Rochester has announced and named his quarrel with "the extreme Catholic left." I presume he means the "woke" Catholics.

It is embarrassing to explain this but there is no Catholic left. Left and woke aren't ontological categories and a bishop owes his care to...

My Sister’s Heart One of the most formative events of my life happened a year before I was born. When she was about six weeks old, my sister Katie—my parents’ firstborn, the answer to prayer after years of infertility—...

Today is the fourth anniversary of the death of my dear sister Kate. I wrote this two days after she died.

wherepeteris.com/my-sisters-h...

I think each of them revealed their true colors. I was initially a fan of all three, but each of them eventually showed that deep down their ego came first.

“What’s wrong with the Church in your country?” Last year, I spent two weeks in Rome. During my visit, I met with many interesting people from all around the world, from Church officials to Vatican journalists to clergy and seminarians working and ...

As I wrote several years ago.

wherepeteris.com/whats-wrong-...

Spain and Mexico have a few movements but mostly, yes.

Trump’s Salvadoran Gulag To be deported, one does not need to be a drug dealer or a terrorist; apparently, having tattoos and being Venezuelan is enough.

“To be deported by Trump, one does not need to be a drug dealer or a terrorist; apparently, having tattoos and being Venezuelan is enough,” @adamserwer.bsky.social writes:

Schism is "the refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff." They are well past that point. So the question is whether the Church will actually do anything. It's extremely rare for the Church to act.

Personally, I think (just my opinion) they have both automatically excommunicated themselves.

I don't think these characters are salvageable. Obviously the Church will go on. But there's obviously big money funding a schism.

Strickland, Altman, and the Making of a Parallel Church Recent videos uploaded to YouTube have revealed that on March 20, 2025, Bishop Joseph Strickland, emeritus of the Diocese of Tyler, Texas, celebrated a public Mass at Mary, Mother of the Light Maronit...

Everything is bonkers here in the Catholic Church in the United States.

wherepeteris.com/strickland-a...

I figured it out.

I think it needed to be retranslated because it was really inaccurate - not just the people's parts but the prayers of the priest.

I think the failed 1998 translation sounded better because it was in actual English. But they inserted ideological changes too, and that sunk it.

In the Latin Mass, they also elevate the host and chalice AFTER the consecration, not during, so it's like you miss the whole thing as it's happening.

It's interesting but there are a few elements that I prefer in the current Mass. For example, being able to see, hear, and pray along with the priest during the Eucharistic prayer. In the TLM, he whispers it in Latin with his back to you.

The ideology extends far beyond the liturgy. My guess is that most of the people in the anti-Francis movement don't actually go to the Latin Mass. They just like the idea of it.

Strickland did toss in some chant and there was incense, if I recall correctly. But my guess is that the music and so forth is what the congregation is used to.

It's a Novus Ordo guitar Mass held in a Maronite Church.

Strickland, Altman, and the Making of a Parallel Church Recent videos uploaded to YouTube have revealed that on March 20, 2025, Bishop Joseph Strickland, emeritus of the Diocese of Tyler, Texas, celebrated a public Mass at Mary, Mother of the Light Maronit...

Everything is bonkers here in the Catholic Church in the United States.

wherepeteris.com/strickland-a...

16: Joseph Stuart - Renewing Church History In today’s episode, I had a great conversation with Dr.

My brother, Dr. Joseph Stuart, was on Paul Fahey's podcast, a discussion about Pope Francis' letter on the renewal of the study of Church history

www.catholicthirdspace.com/p/16-joseph-...

Thank you!

Thank you, Robert. The feeling is mutual.

When the Scales Fell from Our Conservative Catholic Eyes There’s something that many right-wing Catholics—especially those who fiercely oppose Pope Francis—don’t seem to understand about people like me: we were once part of their world. We admired the same ...

What once was unthinkable—publicly accusing the pope of heresy or implying he is a danger to the faith—is now routine in certain circles.

For those of us who were once in these circles, this is a tragedy.

wherepeteris.com/when-the-sca...

No Country for Kings Bishop Barron & the Catholic Performance of Masculinity

Bishop Barron attended Trump’s State of the Union and called it a “liturgy of democracy” in a dangerous attempt to erase the distinction between church and state.

My thoughts:

open.substack.com/pub/maxwellk...

For a more Sentimental Church “They were men of genius, but they had no perception of what is just and lawful in music; raging like Bacchanals and possessed with inordinate delights-mingling lamentations with hymns, and paeans wit...

I was reminded this morning of this article I wrote about the role of emotion and sentiment in faith and liturgy.

wherepeteris.com/for-a-more-s...

Father Chad Ripperger versus the Little Gray Men Due to “unforeseen circumstances,” an event scheduled for later this month in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee featuring the controversial celebrity exorcist Fr. Chad Ripperger was forced to change venues...

This nonsense needs to be exposed. Ripperger, Sungenis and friends are peddling fairy tales and science fiction, trying to pass it off as Catholicism. They are corrupting the innocent.

wherepeteris.com/father-chad-...

False Views of the Papacy: Hyperpapalism, Sedevacantism, and Synodality (Guest: Fr. Jason Charron) In this age of confusion, we see many competing ideas on how Catholics should understand the papacy. The most extreme forms—hyperpapalism and sedevacantism— both include an overexaggerated sense of th...

See for example.

crisismagazine.com/podcast/fals...

Because he is otherwise a radical traditionalist. He is a Ukrainian Catholic priest so he supports Ukraine, but he loathes Pope Francis and thinks he's a heretic.

Good grief.

I am beginning to fear that many of the anonymous groypers, trolls, trads, and integrists who post on the "X" website suffer from a paucity of manners, discernment, and critical thinking skills.