@bethmariem.bsky.social
Senior Health Reporter at Ars Technica. PhD in microbiology. Microbes, infectious diseases, public health, questionable puns. (she/her) beth.mole@arstechnica.com | bethmm_ars.02 (Signal)
I canβt tell you how glad I am to be released from the disgrace of Temu ACIP.
I made a commitment to watch and comment on these proceedings. Not sure Iβll do it again.
In summary, ACIP is no longer a legitimate scientific body.
Every U.S. state needs to decouple their vaccine policy from ACIP.
Dr. Hoeg: I would pay to see the debate between Dr. Meissner and you. Note: She is an anti-vaccine activist, and she just showed it. Not a regulator. She does not have the qualifications, not the ability, and she is just biased.
05.12.2025 19:03 β π 10 π 6 π¬ 2 π 0lol the ACIP committee let Aaron Siri speak for some 90 minutes and cut off CDC experts and scientists off after two minutes (sometime yelling at them to shut them up). Incredible stuff.
05.12.2025 18:41 β π 539 π 231 π¬ 12 π 14Attorney Siri applauds his client RFK Jr.βs change to the CDC website which now claims that vaccines may cause autism.
He is showing his cards. IMO the change was made to make it easier to file lawsuits, and I suspect it was done in collusion with Siri.
βI will just say we have heard βdo no harmβ is a moral imperative. We are doing harm by changing this [recommendation],β Cody Meissner, pediatrician and voting member of ACIP said as he voted against the change.
arstechnica.com/health/2025/...
Sen. Bill Cassidy, who cast the deciding vote to confirm RFK Jr. as health and human services secretary, disapproves of what Kennedy's handpicked panel has done to limit access to hep B vaccines.
05.12.2025 16:58 β π 26 π 15 π¬ 3 π 2Dr. Malone thinks he's the resident expert on immunology. No evidence we need does 2 and 3 to get longterm immunity.
CDC member: fair hypothesis. No data to show it's in fact the case for hepatitis B.
Note: In the past, the #ACIP did not just make up schedules based on whether they make sense. They chose specific dates (at birth, at 2 months, etc) becuase clinical trials showed these times were the safest and most effective. The dates recommended were based on science, not conjecture
05.12.2025 13:59 β π 17 π 10 π¬ 0 π 0Dr. Levi still misrepresents the data and said he appreciates her "beliefs" - reminder: she's an expert in this. He is not.
04.12.2025 21:18 β π 13 π 2 π¬ 1 π 0Can't beat the π©Ί headlines from @arstechnica.com
Factual, and to the point
Meissner makes a motion to postpone all votes on the HBV vaccine birth dose until tomorrow because no one understands the actual text of the vote.
Seconded by Hibbeln.
"There is no significant evidence of horizontal transmission" because I can't read the article and can't evaluate the data is not, actually, a good argument, inexpert #ACIP.
04.12.2025 14:10 β π 34 π 5 π¬ 1 π 2U.S. Senator Bill Cassidy, M.D. β’ A @SenBillCassidy X.com Aaron Siri is a trial attorney who makes his living suing vaccine manufacturers. He is presenting as if an expert on childhood vaccines. The ACIP is totally discredited. They are not protecting children. cdc.gov/acip/downloads...
Chairman of Senateβs health committee with his sharpest words yet as CDCβs vaccine advisers meeting gets underway.
The question is what does Cassidy do now, beyond issue rebukes.
Absolutely unconscionable: Dr Prasad won't share details, data, evidence, or proof of causality. We just have Dr Tracy Beth HΓΈeg's vibes - that's the assessment.
AND:
"FDA vaccine staff disagreed with the assessment that the reported deaths were caused by vaccines"
endpoints.news/fda-says-it-...
At a time where most outlets are delicately avoiding naming things like racism, war crimes, and unconstitutional actions, huge props to Ars' @bethmariem.bsky.social for calling it like it actually is.
04.12.2025 00:46 β π 48 π 10 π¬ 0 π 0Martin Kulldorff gained prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic, when he criticized public health responses to the crisis and co-authored an open letter advocating for letting the deadly virus spread unchecked through the population.
02.12.2025 21:30 β π 46 π 16 π¬ 6 π 3MEETING OF THE ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON IMMUNIZATION PRACTICES (ACIP) AGENDA - DRAFT Centers for Disease Control and Preventior Atlanta, Georgia 30329 Thursday, December 4, 2025 8:00 AM Welcome and Roll Call Agency Updates Hepatitis B Vaccine Presentation Discussion Break Hepatitis B Vaccine (continued) Presentation Discussion Lunch Hepatitis B Vaccine (continued) VFC presentation CMS presentation Discussion Public Comments Break Votes 5:00 PM Adjourn
MEETING OF THE ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON IMMUNIZATION PRACTICES (ACIP) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Atlanta, Georgia 30329 Tuesday, April 15, 2025 8:00 Welcome & Introductions Dr. Keipp Talbot (ACIP Chair) Dr. Melinda Wharton (ACIP Executive Secretary, CDC) 8:15 Mpox Vaccine Introduction Dr. Faisal Minhaj (CDC/NCEZID) Presentation on immunogenicity and safety of JYNNEOS in 12-17 year olds Dr. Buddy Creech (Vanderbilt University) EtR for JYNNEOS in outbreaks and due to the 2022 global outbreak Dr. Faisal Minhaj (CDC/NCEZID) 9:55 Lyme Disease Vaccine Dr. Grace Marx (CDC/NCEZID) 10:00 Influenza Vaccines Introduction Dr. Jamie Lochr (ACIP, WG Chair) Influenza vaccine effectiveness update Dr. Aaron Frutos (CDC/NCIRD) Dr. Sophie Zhu (California DPH and CDC/PHIC), Dr. Joshua Quint (California DPH) FluMist self/caregiver administration Dr. Allyn Bandell (AstraZeneca) 11:15 Break 11:30 COVID-19 Vaccines Introduction Dr. Robert Schechter (ACIP, WG Chair) Moderna mRNA-1283 COVID-19 vaccine Dr. Bishoy Rizkalla (Moderna) Epidemiology and risk factors for COVID-19 hospitalizations Dr. Fiona Havers (CDC/NCIRD) Vaccine effectiveness update Dr. Ruth Link-Gelles (CDC/NCIRD) Workgroup considerations for use of 2025-2026 COVID-19 vaccines Dr. Lakshmi Panagiotakopoulos (CDC/NCIRD) 1:30 Pneumococcal Vaccines Workgroup Next Steps and Proposed Work Plan Dr. Miwako Kobayashi (CDC/NCIRD) 1:45 Break 2:00 Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccines Introduction Dr. Oliver Brooks (ACIP, WG Chair) Update on literature related to reduced number of doses for HPV vaccination Dr. Carla DeSisto (CDC/NCIRD) KEN SHE trial Dr. Ruanne Barnabas (Harvard University) HPV vaccination coverage Ms. Cassandra Pingali (CDC/NCIRD) Modeling of reduced number of doses for HPV vaccination Dr. Jane Kim (Harvard University) Modified EtR: wording of the age for routine HPV vaccination Dr. Ruth Stefanos (CDC/NCIRD) Workgroup next steps and considerations Dr. Lauri Markowitz (CDC/NCIRD) | 4:00 Cytomegalovirus (CMβ¦
The destruction of the legitimacy of ACIP is so complete that the vague agenda on the left is all they have up for tomorrowβs meeting.
It looks like no CDC scientists will present. No materials are posted.
Usually ACIP posts a detailed agenda which includes materials (see example on right).
π¨The Trump administration just WITHDREW a proposed rule to make sure cosmetics products are tested for cancer-causing asbestos.
Does exposing more Americans to asbestos Make America Healthy Again??
I wrote the law that required this testingβthis move is dangerous and wrong.
Weaponization of the premier public health agency in the country for personal clout and gain. The CDC website should not be trusted given the fact that it is controlled by people who will profit from spurious and false attempts to link vaccines to autism.
www.cdc.gov/vaccine-safe...
How awful. This is outright health disinformation, lying to the American people. Not only is there massive evidence showing no link between vaccines & autism, thereβs not even a plausible mechanism based on what weβve learned about the genetics of autism, some environmental exposures in pregnancy
20.11.2025 03:18 β π 2817 π 1134 π¬ 60 π 22RFK Jr had committed to Bill Cassidy, as a condition to win his vote, that he would keep website language.
Cassidy in February: βIf confirmedβ¦ CDC will not remove statements on their website pointing out that vaccines do not cause autism.β
Note the language in second photo.
Welp.
20.11.2025 02:58 β π 7 π 2 π¬ 1 π 0JOIN US TODAY: We'll be outside Conde Nast HQ tonight just after 6PM to demand the full reinstatement of our @condeunion.bsky.social and @newyorkerunion.bsky.social members. Joining us at our rally as a speaker: @newyorkstateag.bsky.social. BE THERE WITH US!
12.11.2025 15:58 β π 22 π 9 π¬ 0 π 0The one obituary of James Watson you should read is this one by microbiologist Beth Mole, @bethmariem.bsky.social
08.11.2025 01:49 β π 4 π 3 π¬ 1 π 0BREAKING from PP
We found immigration agents have held more than 170 *citizens*
The govt doesn't track citizens held. So we did. We tallied:
Nearly 20 kids, two w/ cancer
More than 20 citizens held for day or more, incommunicado
www.propublica.org/article/immi...
by @nicolefoy.bsky.social
apnews.com/article/pent... turn in access badges, exit Pentagon rather than agree to new reporting rules
15.10.2025 21:05 β π 4 π 2 π¬ 0 π 0Six of the nine Nobel Prize winners this year work in the U.S.
Three of the six were born outside the U.S., which is the pattern most years. No country has benefited more from welcoming immigrants from around the world.
www.nobelprize.org