Nick Dunn

They do so by applying eligibility criteria as stated in...the law.

@minibubbly.bsky.social "Provinces can provide support but cannot legislate who can or cannot get it". If this is the case, then how could Quebec get away with legalizing 'advanced requests'?

A province that chooses to prohibit MAID in these cases is not 'taking away' any rights.

MAID is not available to persons with a mental disorder as their sole underlying condition or for mature minors; Quebec is the only province which has advanced requests. There is no constitutional right to MAID for these reasons, nor is there any existing federal legislation that allows for them.

There seems to be some confusion (or, worse, bad faith arguing and fear mongering). A government cannot 'roll back' something that doesn't exist.

Nothing is being repealed.

One can't 'roll back' something that doesn't exist in the first place. MAID for mental illness is currently not available in Canada, and there is no legal or constitutional right to MAID solely on the basis of a mental disorder.

You can't roll back something that doesn't exist in the first place.

There is no constitutional 'right' to MAID with regards to mental illness, mature minors, or advanced requests.

There is no 'right' to MAID for anyone under 18 in Canada. It's right there in the Criminal Code.

Loaded headlines such as "SACPA learns about the psychiatric MAID debate?"

"May" be as opposed to "will" be. It's a factual claim. Nothing dishonest about that. I certainly wouldn't claim to know what the government plans to do, precisely because it has been delayed three times already.

SACPA learns about psychiatric MAID debate By Joe Manio Lethbridge Herald At noon Thursday, another large and highly engaged crowd gathered for the weekly Southern Alberta Council on Public Affairs

Last week, I had the chance to talk to the Lethbridge community about MAID and mental illness, which may be available in Canada as early as March 2027:

lethbridgeherald.com/news/lethbri...

Debate Continues Over Expanding MAID To Mental Illness - Bridge City News - February 23, 2026 Should Medical Assistance in Dying, or MAID, be Available to People with Mental Illness? The highly debated issue was the focus of a community discussion in

Should Medical Assistance in Dying, or MAID, be Available to People with Mental Illness? The highly debated issue was the focus of a community discussion in Lethbridge hosted by the Southern Alberta Council on Public Affairs or SACPA.

bridgecitynews.ca/debate-conti...

Alt text: Graphic for a Call for Chapters for Hannah Arendt’s Lectures on Kant’s Political Philosophy, edited by Nicholas Dunn. The design features a navy blue and beige background with a graphic element from the De Gruyter Brill logo. On the left is the cover for the online resource “Works of Philosophy and Their Reception” with an abstract image of stacked books. At the bottom, the text states: “Submit your proposal until 1 April 2026”

Call for Chapters 📢

👉For an edited volume on Hannah Arendt's Lectures on Kant's Political Philosophy, to be published online first in Works of Philosophy and Their Reception.

ℹ️More details: philevents.org/event/show/1...

📕Read from the volume: www.degruyterbrill.com/database/wpr...

#PhilSky #CfP