I feel a lot better about determining merit based on “actual accomplishments” versus based on “potential” and “stature of the sponsoring PI and the institution” and “letters of recommendation”. Opportunities are a red herring here, because the same issues still apply to 2nd year students.
26.09.2025 22:36 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Stated alternatively: Tufts and UD undergrads will compete very well on *accomplished research* with undergrads at most higher-ranked institutions. Tufts and UD grad students will fare less well when compared to equivalent grad students, because reputation/LoR will factor in more heavily.
26.09.2025 21:09 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
I just don’t think that by early in their second year of grad school they will have distinguished themselves (in grad work) sufficiently for reviewers - it will come down to letters of rec (and careful editing of their proposals, which is also down to advisers). Judge on what they ACCOMPLISHED.
26.09.2025 21:04 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
I honestly think that, long-term, it is a good policy. As-is, it rewards 2nd-year students in big labs. Rewarding the students who were most productive as undergrads (focusing on research first, GPA second) is probably a better indication of “most promising”.
26.09.2025 20:32 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
One of my best undergrads ever is in this situation. Had a 1st-author paper published last summer, deferred applying on grad advisor’s rec, will have a *second* 1st-author pub in a few weeks, 2nd year student in a great lab…and now ineligible. Gutted for him.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/...
26.09.2025 20:24 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Organic Chemistry, Peptide Synthesis, Drug Discovery and Bioinformatic, Machine learning
Old process chemist - I make drugs by the metric fuckton
Ready to make the free pharmaceuticals that save lives in the glorious corporation free future
Follow all scientists
Ask me about drugs or chemistry
Glasshalfemptologist.
https://drugmonkey.wordpress.com/
Provost
Hofstra University
Chemist, husband, father, singer. Sustainability, catalysis, stereochemistry, predictive modeling. Senior Principal Scientist @astrazeneca.bsky.social Gothenburg. he/him
dad, professor, chemistry, biology
Chemical biologist at Tufts University working on small molecules, peptides, and biotechnology.
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2878-6781
https://chem.tufts.edu/kritzer-lab
I'm a scientist! Asst Prof at Univ of Delaware | RNA biochemistry, RNA modifications, (metallo)enzymology, structural biology, and chemistry | Postdoc at UCSF | PhD at UCBerkeley | he/him
mugridgelab.org
Distinguished Professor | U. of Minnesota | MacArthur Fellow | Director CPEC | Co-founder Sironix Renewables, Carba.com, & Lakril Technologies | Advisor ActivatedLLC | ❤️✌🏽🍃♻️ #mspsky
All things sugars. #glycotime
Run by SYL/JWA
Temple University chemistry professor, some other stuff too.
Digital chemist & chemistry automation nerd | Lives in a historical canalside cottage | "Aggressively sciency" | Views are mine | She/they. Macclesfield, UK
1. A blog to help chemists find jobs. (chemjobber.com) 2. Towards a quantitative understanding of the quality of the chemistry job market
DC-based freelance journalist and editor | science, health, food | ✍️ DCist, Knowable, NPR, Science News | NASW Freelance Committee | Chemistry Ph.D. 🧪 | Inglés y Español | she/her
Chicago-based health & science columnist for Bloomberg Opinion @opinion.bsky.social. Writing about public health, medicine, emerging technologies (Crispr!), biotech & pharma. opinions=mine, She/her. Signal: lisajarvis.77
Editor (she/her) @cenmag.bsky.social into biomolecules, drug discovery, and biotech. Also beer, skiing, and the joys of being an immigrant in Germany. All views expressed here are absolutely mine, especially when they're right. DM for Signal.
Organic chemist, enzymologist, professor, cat dad. PEI ➡️ Queen's U ➡️ UIUC ➡️ USask. 🇨🇦✌️🙂 (he/him)
Book author, toxicology journalist, fascinated by poison and murder (current book project), and, oh yeah, I'm the former director of the Knight Science Journalism program at MIT.
Writer, journalist. Science, health. Pandemics, animals. Birder, photographer. Many words, some awards. AN IMMENSE WORLD, I CONTAIN MULTITUDES. Married to Liz Neeley, parent to Typo. he/him
📷 Canon R6mkii + RF 800mm
Edyong.me
Academic philosopher, lapsed chemist, occasional science writer, perpetual ethics booster. All views my own. (she/her)