Billy Carpenter's Avatar

Billy Carpenter

@billycarpy.bsky.social

⚽️ writing and analysis, usually in the form of giant Arsenal long-reads. I also write for SCOUTED. Here's my newsletter: https://billycarpenter.substack.com/

10,988 Followers  |  169 Following  |  2,205 Posts  |  Joined: 13.11.2024  |  1.6115

Latest posts by billycarpy.bsky.social on Bluesky

I was feeling a *little* more sanguine before I saw that Sunderland were 16th in xG with the fewest shots on target in the league. They sure look better than that every time I tune in.

08.11.2025 22:48 — 👍 28    🔁 1    💬 2    📌 0

The only sub thing I'm really questioning is that the late-match felt prime for Hincapié: runny, energy-y, fighty, duelly, shithousey, secure.

08.11.2025 22:47 — 👍 57    🔁 3    💬 6    📌 0

Runny attackers = more outlets = more possession = fewer waves of opponent pressure late = a much easier job of defending. Obvious, but somebody like Martinelli or Madueke is a lovely defensive sub, in other words. We had none.

08.11.2025 21:26 — 👍 71    🔁 3    💬 4    📌 0
Preview
Adventures Breaking back-fives, what numbers have changed (and what haven't), how Eze differs from Ødegaard, Saliba in midfield, scattered notes on Rice and Gyökeres, and more

Here's my Arsenal long-read, just for you.

Attacking back-fives, analytics, tactics, a deeper look at what has (and hasn't) changed, and a whole lot more.

08.11.2025 09:29 — 👍 44    🔁 7    💬 4    📌 1

I don't know the threshold, but it's the amount of power put behind the shot. "primary intention being power"

kicky hardy

08.11.2025 09:49 — 👍 5    🔁 0    💬 2    📌 0

Important shifts, as I went through @gradientsports.bsky.social data:

— Arsenal now lead the league in “open play power shots” (26)
— This is 12 more than the second-highest team
— Arsenal have the highest percentage of “power shots” in the league (19%)
— Eze leads this league (7).

08.11.2025 09:40 — 👍 31    🔁 6    💬 3    📌 0
Preview
Adventures Breaking back-fives, what numbers have changed (and what haven't), how Eze differs from Ødegaard, Saliba in midfield, scattered notes on Rice and Gyökeres, and more

Here's my Arsenal long-read, just for you.

Attacking back-fives, analytics, tactics, a deeper look at what has (and hasn't) changed, and a whole lot more.

08.11.2025 09:29 — 👍 44    🔁 7    💬 4    📌 1

Big newsletter coming after this one, by the way.

04.11.2025 16:54 — 👍 12    🔁 0    💬 0    📌 0

Hincapié o'clock.

04.11.2025 16:54 — 👍 17    🔁 0    💬 2    📌 0
Gabriel, Timber, Saka

Gabriel, Timber, Saka

Diabolical subs.

30.10.2025 23:00 — 👍 111    🔁 3    💬 5    📌 0

Real ones know.

30.10.2025 18:37 — 👍 19    🔁 1    💬 2    📌 0

Haha, one of my takeaways as well.

"Everybody is doing long throws."

No, everybody is *trying* to do long throws. Like three people actually are.

30.10.2025 18:31 — 👍 7    🔁 0    💬 1    📌 0

Yeah, I've been working on Post-Towel expected Threat (PTxT ±).

Basically, you take the expected threat of the throw-in after treatment (i.e, towel), and subtract the value of control (i.e, comparable, towelless throw-ins).

My wife hasn't seen me in three weeks. Will report back.

30.10.2025 18:26 — 👍 49    🔁 1    💬 2    📌 0
Preview
Responsibility The mental load of a modern player, and how Arsenal are changing in attack to swarm the box in numbers

There's a solid section in the last one about him (in the middle), and specifically, about how he's causing a lot of the collapses of opponent structure (as we saw yesterday). Some interesting numbers in there too if you missed it

billycarpenter.substack.com/p/responsibi...

30.10.2025 18:15 — 👍 5    🔁 0    💬 1    📌 0

I have approximately 64 bullets that I'm considering writing about for Arsenal. What micro-topic are you interested in me exploring right now?

30.10.2025 17:45 — 👍 23    🔁 1    💬 26    📌 0

Celebrate all you want, but all I see is a nil-nil draw on set pieces. ☹️

29.10.2025 21:49 — 👍 169    🔁 7    💬 5    📌 0

Arsenal needed a quicker trigger.

26.10.2025 14:56 — 👍 60    🔁 1    💬 1    📌 0

Same karate kick that created the first Gyökeres goal against Atleti.

Shooters shoot.

26.10.2025 14:46 — 👍 90    🔁 5    💬 1    📌 1

Here's the big one.

25.10.2025 13:41 — 👍 8    🔁 0    💬 0    📌 0
All-out, repeat intensity: Sustains high-intensity work through 90+ (recovery runs, counter-press jumps, potential for overlaps).
Frame + movement: 6'0–6'1, plays “tall” vs wingers; long, dextrous legs; side-on, knees bent, short active steps. Leap lets him contest up a level; pre-aerial duel muscling improving. More feisty than domineering.
Pace: Wide speed (CL top-end 34.8 km/h). Fastest when carrying up the left touchline; short recoveries solid, medium-or-longer excellent.
Technique: Clean first touch, economical actions, but not a hips-loose winger-quality dribbler. Right foot functional but not overly interesting.
Temperament: Formerly way over-amped (13Y/3R in 22/23); calibrating more: yellows/90 dropped (0.48→0.12), reds mostly gone last two seasons, still hints of over-aggression. Smart, tactically aware, adjusted to Alonso quickly. Ferocious in duels, composed in possession.

All-out, repeat intensity: Sustains high-intensity work through 90+ (recovery runs, counter-press jumps, potential for overlaps). Frame + movement: 6'0–6'1, plays “tall” vs wingers; long, dextrous legs; side-on, knees bent, short active steps. Leap lets him contest up a level; pre-aerial duel muscling improving. More feisty than domineering. Pace: Wide speed (CL top-end 34.8 km/h). Fastest when carrying up the left touchline; short recoveries solid, medium-or-longer excellent. Technique: Clean first touch, economical actions, but not a hips-loose winger-quality dribbler. Right foot functional but not overly interesting. Temperament: Formerly way over-amped (13Y/3R in 22/23); calibrating more: yellows/90 dropped (0.48→0.12), reds mostly gone last two seasons, still hints of over-aggression. Smart, tactically aware, adjusted to Alonso quickly. Ferocious in duels, composed in possession.

I've been experimenting with one-pagers to condense my longer scouting reports into key insights for coaches. Basically: how to set a player up for success.

Here’s a draft for Piero Hincapié, whose time is near.

25.10.2025 13:38 — 👍 104    🔁 7    💬 11    📌 0

Great call.

24.10.2025 14:57 — 👍 0    🔁 0    💬 0    📌 0

Still have some stubborn faith in Jesus (football player). If he loses a step, it'll impact his ability to win wide, but he has it in him to be a ghosting, combining, more typical box striker, as we saw before the injury. He is one smart motherfucker.

24.10.2025 14:49 — 👍 84    🔁 1    💬 5    📌 0
Video thumbnail

"The demands of the game stay the same. There's only three things that happen in a game. You've got it. They've got it. And no one's got it."
- Dyche 07/01/25

12.10.2025 20:49 — 👍 30    🔁 7    💬 0    📌 3

Man Tells Internet Arsenal Fans They Are Too Calm About Something

24.10.2025 14:33 — 👍 33    🔁 0    💬 2    📌 0

My mild take is that Arsenal's fans are a touch too calma about depth. Great players are great players and they're hard to replace for a reason. Being able to cover them 90% is excellent, but still not 100%.

24.10.2025 13:49 — 👍 53    🔁 0    💬 9    📌 0

Yep, your point holds weight for sure.

22.10.2025 16:05 — 👍 0    🔁 0    💬 0    📌 0

“Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome.”

22.10.2025 16:04 — 👍 0    🔁 0    💬 0    📌 0

Upon deep personal reflection, I think I'd do Eze for his second-phase cleanup shots

22.10.2025 15:58 — 👍 3    🔁 0    💬 0    📌 0
Shot quality and results in football - Soccerment We investigate the link between shot quality, as measured by the team average xG per shot, and both results (in terms of wins) and performance (measured with our Expected Points model), for the top 5 ...

Why that's so important:
soccerment.com/shot-quality...

22.10.2025 15:57 — 👍 2    🔁 1    💬 0    📌 0

Brentford reliably focus on marginal gains like this (shot quality) to outperform their transfer budget: they're 17th in net spend since they were promoted (21/22), and have finished top-half in the last four seasons

22.10.2025 15:54 — 👍 8    🔁 1    💬 2    📌 0

@billycarpy is following 20 prominent accounts