Naththan

Naththan

@nathanpittman.bsky.social

PhD candidate, writing about the art of government of transport planning: maps as manifestations of power, models as inseparable from plans, questions of what planning is as questions of what it should be, and good planners as bad planners.

828 Followers 113 Following 658 Posts Joined Jul 2023
21 hours ago
Preview
SA Liberals dump candidate who said homosexuality ‘opens up demonic realms’ after initially standing by him Party leader Ashton Hurn confirms Carston Woodhouse will not run for Liberals in SA’s state election, but says ‘people are entitled to have their views’

The first rule of gay demonic realms membership is that you under no circumstances reveal to the heteros the existence of the demonic realms. Friggin’ snitch.

2 0 0 0
1 week ago
A black car, presumably belonging to some arsehole, parked on the footpath

Liveable Melbourne means contending with jerks who are intent on using their cars to block the tiniest strip of the street that our collective carbrain has deemed to be for pedestrian use.

8 0 0 0
1 week ago

If a PT project is underused: “what a waste of money, PT is such a money pit, let’s never invest again”.

If a road project is underused: “amazing, great job, we’ve solved congestion, let’s build more of these”.

9 0 1 0
1 week ago

Petrol prices need to be six, seven times higher. I will not be taking any questions.

6 0 0 0
2 weeks ago

Question: what proportion of Victoria’s flour etc is milled at the Kensington mill?

2 0 1 0
2 weeks ago

My dodgy estimates that you should consider calculating yourself...

🚅 Madrid to Barcelona HSR: AU$25,000,000/km

🚅 Sydney to Newcastle HSR: AU$310,000,000/km

2 0 0 0
2 weeks ago

There's a more specific comparison to Spain under "the density myth"
🚅 NTL-SYD's 624/km (² not specified) compares favourably to BCN-ZAZ's 244/km².
🚅 But BCN-ZAZ is almost all a surface alignment and not a tunnel.
🚅 Spanish HSR construction is way cheaper as a result and in general.

1 0 0 1
2 weeks ago
Screencap of Australian HSR report. Image shows a stylised map of Eastern Australia with a comparison of density figures; this shows that the urbanised east coast corridor of Australia has a lower density than many other countries and that the dense urbanised area around Sydney is denser than other countries.

"N/S/W is actually denser than the UK, Japan, France, and Spain if you only count the urbanised area and then carefully compare that to the whole area of these other countries"

Solid logic. No comments. Give these people 200 billion to build a subway between Sydney and Newcastle.

6 0 0 1
2 weeks ago

Complete with a new station at Shin Wondabyne.

0 0 0 0
2 weeks ago

I demand a surface alignment that lets me soak in the amazing scenery.

3 1 1 0
2 weeks ago

I feel if we’re going to insist on 250+km/h, the first stage should at least be one that is as low risk as possible, like Sydney to Canberra, instead of tunnelling under the Hawkesbury.

3 1 1 0
2 weeks ago

The utterance of "A.I.'s inevitability" is one of the most stark pure performatives I've seen in my time working in higher ed. Every time it is uttered, it is clearly not reporting a fact about the world but instead actively trying to create the reality it narrates. We can and must refuse.

1,074 326 15 30
2 weeks ago
Rear of xtrap ii train at flinder street Side of xtrap ii train at flinder street station Interior view of xtrap ii train More xtrap ii

Surprise xtrapolis ii at flinders street station

10 1 1 0
2 weeks ago

It’s amazing how much wider and more spacious the street feels without cars, even where there are many more people using it.

2 1 0 0
3 weeks ago

Despite having selected the “sustainable” option for my super, the top investment in my account was Transurban. That is until AI mania took over.

2 0 0 0
3 weeks ago

Rest of February at the very least. Congrats!

1 0 1 0
3 weeks ago

Interesting report out of the UK proposing to "reconfigure and upgrade an existing set of services into a coherent, clockface, integrated network" for the countryside between Sheffield and Manchester, drawing on Swiss PT planning principles.

1 0 0 0
1 month ago

Fantastic. Great move. Well done Angus.

2 0 0 0
1 month ago

Perhaps I'll step this back a touch and acknowledge how the Unimelb campus is gated in some ways:

👎 Poor permeability on Swanston St due to tram superstop and turnbacks
👎 Grattan Street resuming its role as a traffic sewer
👎 Royal Parade being a ultrawide traffic sewer

... I'm sensing a theme here

2 0 0 0
1 month ago
Preview
University urged to change course on demolition of modernist building Scholars in Melbourne University’s arts faculty warn heritage will be erased if the university demolishes modernist architect Roy Grounds’ John Medley Building.

Based on the number of graduating students and general tourists who have their photos taken with Medley as a backdrop, there must be something special going here.

(As an aside, the reason that Melburnians reckon Unimelb is "gated" is because they can't drive their cars through).

3 0 0 1
1 month ago
Single frame. Chris Minns stands beside a massive tonne weight marked NSW POLICE being lowered by a crane. Visible sticking out from under the weight are hands, legs, a woman’s face, a keffiyeh and placards saying “NO TO GENOCIDE”, “FREE PALESTINE”, “HERZOG OUT”, “NO TO VIOLENCE” Minns says, “Thst should socially cohere them nicely.”

Cohesion.
My @smh cartoon.

738 282 24 6
1 month ago
Preview
How an ugly debate about level crossing blights Cheltenham’s landscape 10 years on The legacy of a fierce and organised community campaign against building a “sky rail” continues to frustrate locals, who say requests to add greenery to the space have been denied.

FYI

2 0 0 0
1 month ago
Mostly, the community got its wish. Of the 21 crossings removed on the Frankston line so far, 13 have been replaced with a trench, six with a rail bridge, and two involved a road closure.

Central Cheltenham’s lifeless public spaces are a legacy of that victory.

From our partners
Long-term resident Kylie Fennessy recalls the fight against the sky rail proposal, and says while most people got what they wanted, she now views with envy the linear strip of land that has been opened up beneath the new rail bridge in Parkdale – one of the few places on the Frankston line where the railway was elevated.

“It’s great. It’s got all the parks underneath, there’s car parking, gardens, an outdoor gym. When you go past any time of the day, people are using the space,” Fennessy said.

🚟 Melburnians demand trenched rail instead of elevated,

🚟 Govt builds railway trench with potentially developable, but in the meantime nasty, concrete platform,

🚟 Melburnians seethe enviously five years later at how nice rail-over-road is elsewhere in the city.

💯 Perfect, no notes.

11 3 2 0
1 month ago
Front page of the news corp agitprop “the Australian”, which reads dignity vs disgrace, with photos of genocidaire Isaac herzog conforming someone and some furious looking protests. 

Above the headline it reads “herzog visit: activists forget Bondi lessons”

Not shown: police initiated violence

Dignity is making statements that amount to incitement to genocide.

Disgrace is protesting that.

Gotcha.

6 1 0 0
1 month ago

‘Take them away, crush them’: Australia faces an oversized yank tank surge that some say poses a health emergency

Fixed it for you.

2 1 0 0
1 month ago

I love that he wrote an article like this and is still convinced that men, including himself, get to where they are based purely and unambiguously on merit.

3 0 0 0
1 month ago
Preview
All bicycles included in draft plan for mandatory helmets and high-vis, Department confirms — Plan was expected to be put to the Cabinet today before it was withdrawn from the meeting of Government Ministers. A reported plan by Ireland’s Government to make the wearing of helme…

All bicycles included in draft plan for mandatory helmets and high-vis, Department confirms irishcycle.com/2026/02/04/a...

54 17 29 66
1 month ago

This ought to fix the problem of students protesting against institutional ties to a state credibly accused of genocide and apartheid!

2 0 0 0
1 month ago
Image shows a table with the headers Line, Station, Interpeak Headway, and Last Bus.
The contents read:
408	St Albans, Ginifer	20	20:19
418	Keilor Plains, St Albans	40	20:59
419	St Albans	40	21:05
421	Keilor Plains, St Albans	40	20:38
423	St Albans	40	21:00
424	St Albans	40	20:38
425	St Albans	40	21:07
426	Albion	40	00:31
456	Albion	40	21:05

The stations between Sunshine and Watergardens on the Sunbury line have recently received a huge increase in service, with 10-min headways until 9pm.

The connecting bus situation is still pretty dire, though. Improving this is critical if we want to get the most of the munnel.

8 1 1 0
1 month ago

According to both PTV and Google journey planners, a journey from Footscray to ACMI at Fed Square takes longer via the Munnel.

It's 19 mins on a Werribee train and 25 mins on a Sunshine-Dandenong train.

Why? Very long egress times from the Town Hall platforms.

3 0 2 0