David Herdson

David Herdson

@davidherdson.bsky.social

Part-time writer. Political activist. Fan of Bradford City and rail travel (amongst other things). Bibliophile. Dad. List not necessarily in order of importance.

1,244 Followers 279 Following 6,441 Posts Joined Oct 2024
3 hours ago

HMG should tell Trump to get stuffed. He got the world into this mess, didn't consult anyone is flagrantly and repeatedly breaking international law.

That comes with consequences, which he needs to learn the hard way. If Britain participates, we get drawn into Trump's war without influence.

5 1 0 0
5 hours ago
Post image

An historic humiliation for the United States. Trump is so deranged he will not realise this.

338 79 24 36
5 hours ago

Harsh on Ed Davey.

0 0 0 0
11 hours ago

No, it won't. But every little bit of pressure in that direction makes an incremental difference.

1 0 1 0
11 hours ago

Yes. We can't leave everything to experts as any system has implicit or explicit values which are not technocratic and have to be framed politically. Equally, ignoring experts' opinion in favour of ideology is an extremely dangerous path.

6 0 0 0
12 hours ago
Preview
Ukraine and allies fear easing Russian sanctions will prolong war Ukraine's president says the US decision

Trump won't care about words (well, he will because he has a very thin skin, but it's not the most important thing).

If Trump aligning with Russia really matters - and it does - then Europe needs to reflect that in policy.

Deny the US access to European bases.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/article...

2 0 2 0
12 hours ago

Every reason that applies to health could be applied to anything else.

The problem comes from the attitude and knowledge of those voting, not the subject matter.

If they're capable of producing bad outcomes for health on ideological grounds, they're equally capable of doing so on anything else.

9 0 1 0
12 hours ago
Preview
Trump says Iran war will be over 'pretty quickly' but US hasn't 'won enough' yet Oil prices fall as Trump threatens Iran with 'fire and fury' over Strait of Hormuz

It's a week since Trump said his special military operation will be over "pretty quickly".

He's now making moves to deploy assets that will take half a month to arrive.

Bluster is not the same as control of events.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/cz...

3 2 0 0
21 hours ago

He's waited for the markets to close before posting this.

2 1 0 0
23 hours ago

If Trump does not pay a heavy price, one way or another, he'll do it again.

The ideal outcome would be for him to be impeached immediately. In reality, that won't happen until the GOP are more afraid of the public than they are of Trump. And that in turn won't happen without a lot of pain.

5 0 1 0
1 day ago

Also, the media ecosystem will take apart the Greens in a way they won't take apart Farage.

2 0 0 0
1 day ago
Preview
Oil Prices Could Easily Go Much Higher If the Strait stays closed, look out above

Excellent, concise post from @pkrugman.bsky.social .

Put simply: if supply dramatically falls of a good whose demand doesn't change much when its price does then its price will go through the roof.

That's where oil is if the Straight of Hormuz stays closed.

open.substack.com/pub/paulkrug...

1 1 0 0
1 day ago

In relation to the US mid-terms, it's worth noting that the war-related costs here come on top of soaring healthcare bills - and as inflation rises, so will interest rates and mortgages.

All of which can be laid at Trump's door.

1 1 0 0
1 day ago

You're accusing them of weasel words?

1 0 0 0
1 day ago

On the other things, yes, of course Labour has done some good things (though on the two-child cap, only after being dragged there by pressure).

But overall there's little direction, dynamism, narrative or stated purpose. So even if things do get better, there's no guarantee they'll get the credit.

1 0 0 0
1 day ago

I agree on the Greens. They've a lot of dangerous stuff. I joined the Lib Dems because I believe Britain needs a sensible alternative.

On the NHS, I have multiple first- and close second-hand (my mum) experience that it doesn't work, frequently doesn't care and acts as if it's above criticism.

2 0 2 0
1 day ago

I won't criticise these groups for doing what they're set up to do.

I won't blame courts for adjudicating matters within their competence.

I will blame an excessively restrictive framework that allows endless challenges and is a huge inhibitant and set of barriers to getting stuff done. Change it.

1 0 0 0
1 day ago

Pain also has to be for a purpose. You have to explain what you're doing, why it's necessary, and what the benefit will be afterwards.

If the electorate believes you, and if you can deliver on that claimed benefit afterwards, then you stand a chance.

But Labour's done none of it.

2 0 0 0
1 day ago

Squeezing voters to make tactical decisions requires them to believe that the tactical choice is a tolerable alternative, that it's necessary given the opposite-bloc option, and that it will work.

At the moment, Labour is struggling to make two of those claims to left-of-centre voters.

1 0 1 0
1 day ago

In 2024, polls had voting intention continuing to drift away from Labour, to the Lib Dems and Greens, through the election period.

And while the Tories did recover some share from Reform it was only a fraction of what they'd earlier lost.

1 0 1 0
1 day ago

Apart from staying in NATO, which requires no effort, I'm not sure Labour is delivering on any of those.

I also don't think voters do particularly want more social housing: what they want is more affordable housing *across the board*.

0 0 1 0
1 day ago

Gorton & Denton has always had more left voters than right. I don't think it's at all certain that they will automatically return to Labour once it's clear that Greens, Lib Dems, SNP or Plaid are capable of winning in their respective seats. That alone is one reason the local elections matter.

1 0 0 0
1 day ago

Polls report, they don't predict. Yes, opinion can change but that requires facts to change. At the moment, Labour seems intent on annoying those currently willing to vote for it, while not doing enough to attract those who won't - and I see no indication of them being able to react to that.

4 0 3 0
1 day ago

This is unacceptable from the US, giving Russia yet another benefit from Trump's reckless and un-thought-through violence in Iran.

Ukraine and Europe will pay the price.

European governments should demand Trump reverse his policy and if he doesn't, withdraw American access to their bases.

0 0 0 0
1 day ago

For contrast, here's the net change in seats for the govt at each local election round since 2020:

Con
2021: +9%
2022: -26%
2023: -32%
2024: -48%
Lab
2025: -66%

And going by local by-elections, national by-elections and polling, Labour is on for even worse this year.

Unprecedented.

2 1 1 0
1 day ago

Governments do usually lose seats in local elections mid-term (not 'always') but the issue here is the scale of those losses. In local by-elections since May, Labour has held only 24% of the seats it's defended. That's even worse than the 34% retention in last May's election.

1 0 1 0
1 day ago

Polls report. Those with a reputation to protect use their accuracy to promote their retail services.

And they are accurate: the local and Westminster by-elections give enough evidence. As does canvassing.

Labour is going to take a battering in May.

1 0 2 0
1 day ago

These feel like optimistic predictions, given where oil prices have been this week already, how much oil flows through the Straight, and inelastic oil demand is.

1 0 0 0
2 days ago

Obviously, Sunak was the first non-white British PM. That in itself is notable but not, these days, all that remarkable. Which is a good thing.

0 0 0 0
2 days ago

Prime Ministers don't *have* to be remembered for anything.

To the extent that Bonar Law is remembered (not much) it's specifically for being, in Lloyd George's words, the unknown prime minister.

Sunak was a boring, briefly-serving technocrat. He'll be forgotten.

2 0 2 0