Randy Besco

Randy Besco

@randybesco.bsky.social

Political Science at the University of Toronto. Elections and Voting. Immigration, Race and Ethnicity. Political Psychology.

1,859 Followers 1,322 Following 124 Posts Joined Sep 2023
2 days ago

The last few years have really made it clear that people (including academics) basically only have substantive preferences, almost no procedural principles at all.

Majoritarianism? Sovereignty? Plain text of constitutions?

All completely flipped ideologically. Even among experts!

0 0 0 0
4 days ago

Congrats, glad to see this out!

What do you mean by more "consistent" changes? Just less variation in effect size?

0 0 1 0
1 week ago

A few days ago a student was talking to me while standing up, holding his laptop and balancing a glass of water on the keyboard.

I had to stop him and hold the glass myself, it was stressing me out too much.

9 0 0 0
1 week ago

This is very goodπŸ‘. The reason its annoying is that it seems like it was written/said by an author/person, which turns out to be false. If it was actually written by some RA, people would also react badly.

There are objections about abilities, theft or whatever, but the authorship thing is easy.

1 0 0 0
2 weeks ago

The fact that it affects correlations and not just levels was news to me!

Getting people to use more reversed questions is very doable. SEM is a much bigger lift though.

1 0 1 0
1 month ago

This seems like a key point in terms of actually convincing new people: that selection on sig is much higher than it "should" be.

3 0 0 0
1 month ago
Preview
a close up of a man 's face with a shaved line on his head . ALT: a close up of a man 's face with a shaved line on his head .

Can't be over the word count if there isn't a right way to count the words

1 0 0 0
1 month ago

Revising lecture slides, and I updated an example with a new new cross-tab. The next slide has some step-by-step calculations to show how it works.

So, can AI update the slide? Powerpoint has built in Copilot!

No. AI can't update numbers in a slide. But it will consistant lie that it has. WTF.

1 0 0 0
1 month ago

Interestingly, due the 2025 citizen reform, I think decendants would keep citizenship forever. Don't imagine they were thinking about separatism when drafting it.

1 0 0 0
1 month ago

Great idea! We should train an LLM on Aristotle and Kant and let it make IRB decisions. Pretty sure it actually doesn't say anywhere in the regulations that IRB members have to be humans...

3 0 2 0
1 month ago

Oh yes I agree! I just meant we shouldn't look at the their percentage of nulls as correct/natural/unbiased or something, because its influenced by the behavior of other journals.

1 0 1 0
1 month ago

They really do deserve a credit for a great journal.

Although, probably some reverse selection on significance for submissions happening there too.

0 0 1 0
1 month ago

You're too busy and don't have time to do all the reviews?

Easy step one, stop reviewing for Elsevier journals.

Later you can also stop editing and submitting to them. (sorry to Electoral Studies, but this calls for market discipline, time to devalue those assets)

4 0 0 0
1 month ago

So LLMs have guidelines about discussing presidents?

Trying out ChatGTP5.2, and it reasons:

"OK, I’m thinking through how to respect guidelines on discussing influential politicians. Redirecting to general topics like race and elections research instead of focusing on Obama as an individual."

3 0 1 0
1 month ago

Reviewing PhD applications for next year, and I can't believe the number and quality of them.

We always have good applicants, but this year we could easily admit three full cohorts. And I suspect the acceptance rate will be really high too.

2 0 0 0
2 months ago

Thanks for having me!

1 0 0 0
2 months ago

Sure did! Its possible I have eaten more than one already.

1 0 0 0
2 months ago

I was an external examiner for a PhD defense for the first time today, and it was a great experience. I went in person rather than zoom. That has costs, but I think its worth it. Partly because its an important event, but also somehow being in person makes it important.

10/10 would examine again.

15 0 3 0
3 months ago

Thanks! And when the new changes happened, I was so glad we had your work from before! Won't be the last time I'm sure.

1 0 0 0
3 months ago

HA I believe it, so widespread. Alberta is also not particularly conservative!

0 0 0 0
3 months ago

Thanks!

0 0 0 0
3 months ago
Post image

Linking of immigration to the housing crisis seems much more likely, given timing and age changes. Polarization has been going on for a while, but this recent shift was among all parties.

Some media analysis with @jeremiedrouin.bsky.social is in the pipeline, maybe that will shed more light.

5 0 0 0
3 months ago

Thanks!

0 0 0 0
3 months ago

Thanks to @cbreton.bsky.social and @irpp.org for publishing, @parkinac.bsky.social for the invaluable data series, and to @catherineouellet.bsky.social and @skelalex.bsky.social for helping with the early data work!

5 1 2 0
3 months ago
Post image

Overall, we are back to the 80s-90s state, where most Canadians think we have too much immigration.

But the demographic structure - and probably the causes - of that opposition is probably quite different.

3 0 1 0
3 months ago
Post image Post image

Gender has changed a little - women historically more anti-immigrant, now its men - but this started earlier, and differences are still small.

Most other categories haven't changed much. Surprisingly, despite debate around educational shifts, its relation to immigration is basically the same.

0 0 1 0
3 months ago
Post image

Anglophones have becomes much more anti-immigrant than francophones. Quebec is now the least anti-immigrant province.

11 3 1 2
3 months ago
Post image

Young people are now the most anti-immigrant group. As far as we can tell this is the first time its happened.

Specifically, this is saying "admitting too many immigrants", which isn't quite the same thing as prejudice or other measures. But its still a striking shift.

3 2 1 1
3 months ago

New work on on Immigration attitudes, out in @irpp.org with @natashagoel.bsky.social

We show dramatical increase in anti-immigration opinion in Canada over the past couple of years.

Its very different than previous shifts like in 1990s...

26 14 5 3
3 months ago

The elections commissioner. Allegations would be filed, and there would be a little hearing. Of course, it incentivized filing lots of allegations against your opponents..
.

2 0 0 0