Is AI making job recruitment less meritocratic? We're getting some v interesting research studies on this question now, and the news is... not good. @jburnmurdoch.ft.com & I dive in, in the latest edition of our newsletter The AI Shift www.ft.com/content/e5b7...
14.11.2025 10:12 โ ๐ 800 ๐ 330 ๐ฌ 25 ๐ 80
A table showing profit margins of major publishers. A snippet of text related to this table is below.
1. The four-fold drain
1.1 Money
Currently, academic publishing is dominated by profit-oriented, multinational companies for
whom scientific knowledge is a commodity to be sold back to the academic community who
created it. The dominant four are Elsevier, Springer Nature, Wiley and Taylor & Francis,
which collectively generated over US$7.1 billion in revenue from journal publishing in 2024
alone, and over US$12 billion in profits between 2019 and 2024 (Table 1A). Their profit
margins have always been over 30% in the last five years, and for the largest publisher
(Elsevier) always over 37%.
Against many comparators, across many sectors, scientific publishing is one of the most
consistently profitable industries (Table S1). These financial arrangements make a substantial
difference to science budgets. In 2024, 46% of Elsevier revenues and 53% of Taylor &
Francis revenues were generated in North America, meaning that North American
researchers were charged over US$2.27 billion by just two for-profit publishers. The
Canadian research councils and the US National Science Foundation were allocated US$9.3
billion in that year.
A figure detailing the drain on researcher time.
1. The four-fold drain
1.2 Time
The number of papers published each year is growing faster than the scientific workforce,
with the number of papers per researcher almost doubling between 1996 and 2022 (Figure
1A). This reflects the fact that publishersโ commercial desire to publish (sell) more material
has aligned well with the competitive prestige culture in which publications help secure jobs,
grants, promotions, and awards. To the extent that this growth is driven by a pressure for
profit, rather than scholarly imperatives, it distorts the way researchers spend their time.
The publishing system depends on unpaid reviewer labour, estimated to be over 130 million
unpaid hours annually in 2020 alone (9). Researchers have complained about the demands of
peer-review for decades, but the scale of the problem is now worse, with editors reporting
widespread difficulties recruiting reviewers. The growth in publications involves not only the
authorsโ time, but that of academic editors and reviewers who are dealing with so many
review demands.
Even more seriously, the imperative to produce ever more articles reshapes the nature of
scientific inquiry. Evidence across multiple fields shows that more papers result in
โossificationโ, not new ideas (10). It may seem paradoxical that more papers can slow
progress until one considers how it affects researchersโ time. While rewards remain tied to
volume, prestige, and impact of publications, researchers will be nudged away from riskier,
local, interdisciplinary, and long-term work. The result is a treadmill of constant activity with
limited progress whereas core scholarly practices โ such as reading, reflecting and engaging
with othersโ contributions โ is de-prioritized. What looks like productivity often masks
intellectual exhaustion built on a demoralizing, narrowing scientific vision.
A table of profit margins across industries. The section of text related to this table is below:
1. The four-fold drain
1.1 Money
Currently, academic publishing is dominated by profit-oriented, multinational companies for
whom scientific knowledge is a commodity to be sold back to the academic community who
created it. The dominant four are Elsevier, Springer Nature, Wiley and Taylor & Francis,
which collectively generated over US$7.1 billion in revenue from journal publishing in 2024
alone, and over US$12 billion in profits between 2019 and 2024 (Table 1A). Their profit
margins have always been over 30% in the last five years, and for the largest publisher
(Elsevier) always over 37%.
Against many comparators, across many sectors, scientific publishing is one of the most
consistently profitable industries (Table S1). These financial arrangements make a substantial
difference to science budgets. In 2024, 46% of Elsevier revenues and 53% of Taylor &
Francis revenues were generated in North America, meaning that North American
researchers were charged over US$2.27 billion by just two for-profit publishers. The
Canadian research councils and the US National Science Foundation were allocated US$9.3
billion in that year.
The costs of inaction are plain: wasted public funds, lost researcher time, compromised
scientific integrity and eroded public trust. Today, the system rewards commercial publishers
first, and science second. Without bold action from the funders we risk continuing to pour
resources into a system that prioritizes profit over the advancement of scientific knowledge.
We wrote the Strain on scientific publishing to highlight the problems of time & trust. With a fantastic group of co-authors, we present The Drain of Scientific Publishing:
a ๐งต 1/n
Drain: arxiv.org/abs/2511.04820
Strain: direct.mit.edu/qss/article/...
Oligopoly: direct.mit.edu/qss/article/...
11.11.2025 11:52 โ ๐ 595 ๐ 426 ๐ฌ 8 ๐ 60
I've been investigating the huge levels of exploitation faced by workers on the seasonal worker visa for the last few years, and have often asked myself why the trade union movement has ignored these workers.
So I spoke to unions, big and small, to try and answer that question.
12.11.2025 08:31 โ ๐ 20 ๐ 14 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
Minimum Wages: Directive put beyond all doubt by todayโs ruling of the Court of Justice.
@estherlynch.bsky.social ๐ข "this judgment confirms that the Minimum Wage Directive stands firm โ the EU can and must act for fair wages."
11.11.2025 08:59 โ ๐ 22 ๐ 20 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 5
co-organised by The Faculty of Legal and Political Sciences โ Hassan First University of Settat (Morocco), the Department of Law, Political, Economic and Social Sciences โ University of Eastern Piedmont (Italy), and my research unit @umr7354dres.bsky.social in Strasbourg (France)
10.11.2025 09:22 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
๐ข Call for papers
ยซ #Migration in times of crisis: Legal Insights and Humanitarian Challenges ยป (1-3 April 2026, Settat)
Call here : dres.unistra.fr/websites/mis...
Deadline for submission : 30 November 2025
10.11.2025 09:22 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
Informal Workers, Vulnerability and Human Rights: An Inter-American Story
ABSTRACT . Informality is a defining feature of labour markets in Latin America and the Caribbean, where nearly half of the workforce remains excluded from
Important new article on informality under the IASHR by @mauropucheta.bsky.social and @renanbkalil.bsky.social, open access in the ILJ. Exploring the potential for a rights-based model and calling for a more systematic recognition of informal workers by the Court. academic.oup.com/ilj/advance-...
07.11.2025 12:42 โ ๐ 6 ๐ 3 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
๐ก A NEW PUBLICATION IS OUT!
Policy Brief - Relations between immigration and labour policies.โจThe Role of the State Labour Inspectorate in Preventing Irregular Employment of Migrant Workers in Poland.
๐ www.dignityfirm.eu/policy-brief...
06.11.2025 08:44 โ ๐ 3 ๐ 2 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
The E-BoP seminar at the ILO takes place tomorrow!
27.10.2025 10:16 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
A year or two ago, I started keeping a list of cases where attorneys had been disciplined for submitting court documents with fake AI-generated filings. Figured it would be a short-lived phenomenon as attys became aware
I had to stop, because the number is growing faster than I could keep up
24.10.2025 21:50 โ ๐ 268 ๐ 102 ๐ฌ 18 ๐ 2
Temporary Labour Migration in Europe
This webinar will present findings from the ERC-funded project 'European Birds of Passage', which examines how EU and national laws shape the rights and perceptions of temporary migrant workers. The d...
๐ข The European Birds of Passage team will present our preliminary findings at the International Labour Organization (Geneva) in the seminar โTemporary Labour Migration in Europeโ (28 October, 1PM - 3PM CEST)
#labourmigration #ILO #EUlaw
www.ilo.org/meetings-and...
16.10.2025 09:51 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 1
๐ก NEW PUBLICATION IS OUT
๐ The DignityFIRM project aims at understanding of and improving policies related to irregular migrant work (IMW) in the Farm to Fork (F2F) sector.
๐ www.dignityfirm.eu/the-governan...
06.10.2025 07:47 โ ๐ 3 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
Isnโt it Ironic?
Aren't silencing attempts against a symposium highlighting academic silencing ironic? Khaled El Mahmoud, Anna Sophia Tiedeke & Sissy Katsoni think so! In their contribution to the symp., the eds. of #ร share the silencing attempts they faced while organising it. voelkerrechtsblog.org/isnt-it-ironic
15.09.2025 17:07 โ ๐ 2 ๐ 2 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
With @gemmagasseau.bsky.social we have a new short piece in Capital & Class, where we analyse continuties and changes in European economic governance. We argue that, despite the changes since the pandemic, EU integration remains centered on neoliberalism (1)
08.09.2025 15:49 โ ๐ 6 ๐ 3 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
E-GRUiEN consortium is composed of representatives from from 11 academic and research centers, led by Prof. Nathan Lillie, Professor of Social and Public Policy, and the Head of the Social and Public Policy unit in the Department of Social Sciences and Philosophy (Jyvaskylan Yliopisto, Finland).
22.04.2025 07:25 โ ๐ 2 ๐ 2 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Interested in coming to work with us at the ETUI?
Background in economics?
We are seeking a full-time researcher to bring quantitative skills to questions of European economic and employment policies
See here for more info ๐ etui.org/ZR5
๐ Deadline: 31 August
31.07.2025 10:04 โ ๐ 8 ๐ 7 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 6
Everything is ready for our conference (it's on Monday!) ๐ฅ. You can still register for online attendance here ep-events.secure.europarl.europa.eu/lincstrasbou...
27.06.2025 09:33 โ ๐ 2 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Deadline for registration for in-person attendance is next Monday (23 June) โ
Conference spotlight nยฐ 5 ๐ฆ: I will present the results of two systematic analyses of EU law (focusing on "labour market" and "temporariness") to explore the legal chronotope of temporary labour migration in/to the EU.
20.06.2025 07:26 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
just as the Summer heat, our conference is fast approaching (๐
30 June ๐ European Parliament in Strasbourg)
Conference spotlight nยฐ 4 ๐ก: Audrey Deverson will present her research, based on field interviews in France and Spain, on the challenges faced by temporary migrant women in agriculture
12.06.2025 14:45 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Join us in Strasbourg or online on 30 June ๐
Conference Spotlight nยฐ 3 ๐ก: Justyna Hejman will present a study using multiple sources of administrative data to explore the relationship between outgoing postings and incoming temporary labour migrants in the Polish road transport sector
06.06.2025 14:08 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Our latest on the seasonal worker visa.
What jumped out at me when reading this government-commissioned report is that farm-owners will quite openly say that they prefer migrant workers to accrue huge levels of debt, because this pushes them to work harder so that they can pay it off.
03.06.2025 08:03 โ ๐ 193 ๐ 97 ๐ฌ 10 ๐ 5
We still have 15-ish places for in person attendance ! โ
Conference Spotlight nยฐ 2 ๐ก: Daniel Elanga Mendogo will examine the impact of the changes in the EU legal framework for posting of workers on intra-EU trade in services and on the employment outcomes of posted and local workers
02.06.2025 14:17 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Our conference is in one month-ish!
Spotlight 1: Catharina Lopes Scodro will present her research on ๐บ๐ถ๐ด๐ฟ๐ฎ๐ป๐ ๐ฎ๐ ๐ฝ๐ฎ๐ถ๐ฟ๐, comparing the regulatory framework in France and Ireland through a socio-legal perspective based on interviews in both countries. Her discussant will be Vera Pavlou
#EU #Migration
28.05.2025 08:28 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
"I used to be just like you before I started going to therapy"
IMISCOE is the largest interdisciplinary scholarly network in the field of migration with 71 member institutes & 1500+ scholars.
It provides a platform for scholars throughout the world to get together in studying different migration topics.
๐ imiscoe.org
Academic Blog on International Law & International Legal Thought. Posts on new blog articles, events and our Vรถlkerrechtspodcast.
๐: https://voelkerrechtsblog.org
E-GRUiEN (Encouraging Digital and Green Transformation through Revitalisation and Inclusive Union-Employer Negotiations) is a multifield research project focused on fair green and digital transition in automotive, energy, on-demand transport and care.
Associate Professor of Sociology in Work and Organization at the University of Verona, Italy
https://www.dsu.univr.it/?ent=persona&id=40349&lang=en
Coordinator of RE-WOrk
https://sites.dsu.univr.it/rework/
Assoc. Prof., Law Gonville & Caius, Cambridge | Labour Law | EU law | MovingLabourCollective | Disgruntled romantic; once Stakhanov & Mancunian; Toumbiot beyond Toumba
Currently based in Brussels. alum: @nlrbgov + @epi-org.bsky.social | She/her | Opinions mine
Associate Professor of Labour Law at the University of Amsterdam
Dignity for migrant workers in Farm to Fork labour market
#DignityFIRM #Horizon2020
Our website ๐ https://www.dignityfirm.eu/
Asst. Prof of HRM @Maynoothuniversity.ie | PhD @UCC.ie. All views are personal. I am researching platform work.
Professor of Labour and Social Security Law @uurechten.bsky.social, member ECSR @coe.int
FT columnist, writing about work, technology & economics.
One of the best #migrationresearch centres in Europe. We celebrated our 30th birthday in 2023
Associate Coordinator & Senior Network Officer of IMISCOE (International Migration Research Network) at CEDEM @universitedeliege.bsky.social.
Chair Standing Group Migration & Ethnicity of @ecpr.bsky.social. Migration, citizenship, comparative politics, EU
European Research Council, set up by the EU, funds top researchers of any nationality, helping them pursue great ideas at the frontiers of knowledge. #HorizonEU
Freedom and unfreedom in work, leisure and citizenship. People who move & resistance to precarity. Policy & practice responses to 'modern slavery', refugee settlement and migrant youth inclusion. Sociology Senior Lecturer, Uni of Sheffield. ๐ช๐ญ Sahara Libre
Methodological Approaches and Tools in Migration Research - IMISCOE Standing Committee, discussing methods in the migration research community and beyond.
Website: https://tinyurl.com/y9v8n92e
Professor of Social and Public Policy in Jyvรคskylรค, Finland. I research labour relations, migration, European Union, fair energy transition. I used to be an American but not so much these days. I'm more of a Finn these days. Identity is a complex thing
European Papers is conceived of as a cultural project: a tool for reflecting on European integration as a means to create a new political community.
europeanpapers.eu