Good summary of the state of play on Kavanaugh Stops (aka ice detentions based solely on race)
06.10.2025 16:54 โ ๐ 36 ๐ 12 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0@jimoleske.bsky.social
Professor, Lewis & Clark Law School. Teach constitutional law and torts, write on religious liberty and equal protection.
Good summary of the state of play on Kavanaugh Stops (aka ice detentions based solely on race)
06.10.2025 16:54 โ ๐ 36 ๐ 12 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0To my mind the still bigger point is that the original claim was based on nothing, Vladeck refuted it with something, and now weโre fighting about that instead of the original claim
06.10.2025 18:07 โ ๐ 14 ๐ 2 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0/2 ...for the anti-SLAPP statute to protect speech in connection with it. My point is she was capable of good and right.
It's always more upsetting when someone like that chooses evil. Because make no mistake, she's chosen evil, and she wallows in it.
BREAKING: Illinois has filed suit to block Trump's deployment of the military to Chicago.
storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.us...
Really important.
06.10.2025 13:20 โ ๐ 202 ๐ 52 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1King James II offers a breath of fresh air by tossing out Magdalen College fellows, promises more open inquiry.
06.10.2025 13:35 โ ๐ 35 ๐ 6 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 0I agree with Dean that @anatosaurus.bsky.social's piece was very good, but fell short in its (brief) discussion of economy. And my concern was about seeming dismissal of import of strong economic messaging.
Pollingism existed in 2012 as well as 2024, and it was not primary reason for 2024 loss.
ICE is doing a hell of a lot of harm in the Chicago area *right now.* I donโt mean to trivialize the national guard stuff, it absolutely is an irresponsible escalation, but the guard-centric convo around this really does understate whatโs going on without any guardsmen.
06.10.2025 12:45 โ ๐ 4807 ๐ 1275 ๐ฌ 86 ๐ 34Judge Karin Immergutโs ruling capped a dramatic weekend that included President Trump sending California National Guard members to Oregon and ordering others from Texas.
06.10.2025 04:07 โ ๐ 159 ๐ 40 ๐ฌ 8 ๐ 8VERY chill out here tonight at ICE processing facility south of downtown Portland. Federal Judge (Immergut, appointed by Trump) just made ruling from the bench no federalized Guard to Portland from anywhere period.
06.10.2025 03:40 โ ๐ 1298 ๐ 267 ๐ฌ 20 ๐ 19And that's it for the hearing. Updated story tk; @alexbaumhardt.bsky.social is on the ground outside the ICE facility and reports about 150 protesters present.
06.10.2025 03:22 โ ๐ 23 ๐ 6 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 0Judge: That's what I'll do. Prohibit federalization or deployment of any NG troops into Oregon. For all reasons in prior opinion. Deployment of federalized military is ultra vires and contrary to law, violating Title 10, section 12406. I also find it's likely that defendants violate 10th Amendment.
06.10.2025 03:18 โ ๐ 3442 ๐ 787 ๐ฌ 11 ๐ 144Oregon (Kennedy): I think it would be appropriate for the court to issue separate 2nd TRO and incorporate by reference reasoning of initial TRO. Now we'd need to broaden: apply to deploying federalized members of NG of *any* state into Oregon.
06.10.2025 03:15 โ ๐ 1142 ๐ 98 ๐ฌ 4 ๐ 15Immergut: What I'll do is not modify my original TRO but issue a new TRO that prohibits the relocation or deployment of any federalized national guard to the state of Oregon....
06.10.2025 03:17 โ ๐ 1757 ๐ 376 ๐ฌ 37 ๐ 52Immergut: I'm handling this on expedited basis, but defendants haven't provided new info.
SHE RULES FROM THE BENCH: I grant the plaintiffs motion for a second TRO based on reasons stated in previous order...
DOJ: CA NG is already federalized
Judge: You are an officer of the court. Do you think this is an appropriate way to deal with my order? Appropriate way of dealing with ruling you disagree with?
DOJ: Well, I'm not a policy maker
Judge: You're a lawyer
Federal attorney insists sending already-federalized troops to Portland is different because they didn't federalize new troops. Immergut isn't buying it.
Federal attorney also trying to say Oregon, Portland and California don't have standing. And that if a new TRO is issued they'll seek a stay.
Governor Kotek Statement on the Mobilization of Texas National Guard to Oregon Salem, OR โ Today, Governor Tina Kotek released the following statement after the Oregon National Guard was informed that the Texas National Guard is preparing a deployment to Oregon: โI have been notified that the Department of War has ordered the Texas Adjutant General to deploy 400 Texas National Guard members to โIllinois, Oregon, and other locations throughout the United States.โ โI have received no direct explanation from President Trump or Secretary Hegseth about the specific need for this action. It is unclear how many will go to what location and what mission they will carry out. โThis is a continuation and escalation of the Presidentโs dangerous, un-American misuse of statesโ National Guard members and hard-earned taxpayer dollars. โI join Illinois Governor JB Pritzker in his call on Texas Governor Greg Abbott to immediately withdraw any support for this decision and refuse to coordinate. โI will continue to keep the public apprised. As Governor, I will continue to fight to uphold the rule of law and the right to govern ourselves.โ
Gov. Tina Kotek on news of Texas National Guard: "This is a continuation and escalation of the Presidentโs dangerous, un-American misuse of statesโ National Guard members and hard-earned taxpayer dollars."
06.10.2025 02:27 โ ๐ 146 ๐ 49 ๐ฌ 6 ๐ 4"Courts lack the power to grant injunctive relief to States because sometimes they hear private-party cases brought after the alleged violations of law have taken place" is ... not terribly persuasive.
06.10.2025 02:30 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0It was a beautiful Sunday in Portland. Farmerโs markets, the Portland Marathon, peaceful protests, and some views of Mt. Hood. This city is vibrant, peaceful, and resilient. We do not need a federal occupation, and we sure as hell donโt want one.
06.10.2025 01:44 โ ๐ 2408 ๐ 733 ๐ฌ 62 ๐ 61This represents a major escalation.
President Trump effort to mobilize TEXAS National Guard for deployment in Portland and Chicago.
Court filing just entered in Oregon v. Trumpโฌ๏ธ
Filed tonight by the state of Oregon - copy of Hegseth memo to Texas National Guard about mobilizing 400 members for federal service, "including in the cities of Portland and Chicago."
storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.us...
Now we have a question about whether the conditions have been met for such a deployment and, depending on what theyโre exactly tasked to do, potential violations of Posse Comitatus.
06.10.2025 01:50 โ ๐ 153 ๐ 36 ๐ฌ 4 ๐ 0Oregon has filed a declaration from the Commander of the Oregon National Guard stating that California National Guard members could be deployed "as early as today" in Oregon for the same "purposes" that Oregon National Guard members would have been deployed for absent yesterday's TRO.
06.10.2025 01:48 โ ๐ 10 ๐ 7 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0Judge Immergut has scheduled a telephonic hearing for 7:00pm tonight.
06.10.2025 01:36 โ ๐ 2 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0I assume the judge will not be happy with this
"After this Court issued a temporary restraining order...Army Northern Command communicated to the California Military Department Executive Leadership that they intended to send 200 of the federalized California National Guard personnel...to Portland.โ
Oregon and California's Joint Motion for a Second Temporary Restraining Order:
s3.documentcloud.org/documents/26...
Lawsuits are underway to stop the California National Guard's deployment in Oregon.
06.10.2025 00:19 โ ๐ 37 ๐ 12 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1Oregon and California's Joint Motion for a Second Temporary Restraining Order:
s3.documentcloud.org/documents/26...
Oregon is working to add California to its complaint against the feds and seek a 2nd temporary restraining order to block the CA National Guard from responding in federal service to Portland's ICE building.
Oregon lawyers hope to get back in front of the federal judge soon, Oregon AG Rayfied says