As I have been lamenting for years, the clear erroneous standard for District Court findings of fact has been rendered null & void by this Court.
Justice Kagan in dissent:
โWe are a higher court than the District Court, but we are not a better one when it comes to making such a fact-based decision.โ
05.12.2025 00:19 โ ๐ 860 ๐ 217 ๐ฌ 13 ๐ 4
Texas is not on โthe eve of an election,โ as was true in the
case the majority cites. Republican National Committee v.
Democratic National Committee, 589 U. S. 423, 424 (2020)
(per curiam); see ante, at 2. The election there was five days
after the injunction. Similarly, the election in Purcell was
โjust weeksโ away. 549 U. S., at 4. Here, Election Day is
eleven months from now. Even the primary election (which
Texas could change) is in March. The District Court care-
fully listed the various โelection preparationsโ underway to
switch to the 2025 map. App. 144. On the other hand, the
court noted how the 2021 mapโwhich the injunction rein-
statedโwas, in a real sense, the status quo. See id., at 145.
Officials, candidates, and voters are all familiar with it from
the last two election cycles. Until late last summer, every-
one expected that map to govern 2026 too. And indeed, it
will be used in a special runoff election in the Stateโs largest
county on January 31, 2026. So, the District Court properly
concluded, โ[a]n injunction in this case would not cause sig-
nificant disruption.โ Id., at 144. Except to the extent all of
us live in election season all the time, the 2026 congres-
sional election is not well underway.
16 ABBOTT v. LEAGUE OF UNITED LATIN
AMERICAN CITIZENS
KAGAN, J., dissenting
And even supposing it is now the ninth or tenth hour,
whose choice was that? It was of course the Texas legisla-
ture that decided to change its map six months before a
March primary. The plaintiffs could not have moved any
faster: They requested an injunction before the new law was
even signed. And to try to speed the litigation, they de-
clined discovery. (That decision, by the way, probably ac-
counted for their failure to submit an alternative map,
which to be probative must be based on the Stateโs particu-
lar districting criteria. See supra, at 13 n.) The District
Court moved expeditiously too, issuing its 160-page opinion
(on November 18) just a month after post-hearing briefing
concluded. No one dilly-dallied in this case. The District
Court ruled as โlateโ as it did because the legislature en-
acted a new map less than three months before.
If Purcell prevents such a ruling, it gives every State the
opportunity to hold an unlawful election. The District
Court, once again aptly, made the point: Were judicial re-
view so broadly foreclosed, then to implement even a โbla-
tantly unconstitutional map,โ the โLegislature would need
only to passโ it on a schedule like this one. App. 154โ155.
That cannot be the lawโexcept of course that today it is.
According to the majority, Texas had a free pass to redis-
trict in August 2025 for the 2026 House elections. See ante,
at 2. All that the plaintiffs can hope for is better luck in
2028.
Pretty notable, in my view, that Kagan points out the Supreme Court's pro-gerrymandering decision in Texas is a step-by-step instruction manual for states to draw discriminatory maps while ducking judicial review, and the majority has...nothing to say in response www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25p...
05.12.2025 00:41 โ ๐ 1374 ๐ 433 ๐ฌ 22 ๐ 13
Simply amazing that the Supreme Court declared an end to legal race discrimination in the affirmative action case two years ago and now allows overt racism in both immigration arrests and redistricting.
Using race to help minorities? Bad. Using it to discriminate against them? Very, very good.
04.12.2025 23:52 โ ๐ 5541 ๐ 2102 ๐ฌ 161 ๐ 97
It's a campaign of terror.
Her terror (and the terror of entire communities, forced into hiding) is not incidental.
It is a product they are manufacturing, a key part of the spectacle for their intended audience.
Which is the terrorized, but also the terror consumers.
04.12.2025 02:39 โ ๐ 369 ๐ 139 ๐ฌ 7 ๐ 4
Hepatitis B infection in infancy (almost half of all HepB is caught in childhood) is associated with a 90% chance of becoming a chronic infection (ie the body can never clear the virus), and is highly likely to progress to liver failure and liver cancer.
Vaccinating at birth has reduced this by 99%
03.12.2025 15:59 โ ๐ 277 ๐ 117 ๐ฌ 5 ๐ 5
Really letting the hood slip, here.
03.12.2025 16:03 โ ๐ 2097 ๐ 382 ๐ฌ 110 ๐ 17
I cannot believe this guy is a physician or that he is my Senator. smh
03.12.2025 14:04 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
The official policy of the Trump Administration is ignorant bigotry. Weโre asked, under principles including charity, to assume that people support the administration despite that policy, not specifically because of it. I am increasingly unwilling to extend that charity.
02.12.2025 19:24 โ ๐ 2570 ๐ 638 ๐ฌ 108 ๐ 30
Any death is tragic; however, the Food and Drug Administrationโs vague declaration about the COVID-19 vaccine and pediatric deaths undermines confidence in the safety of the vaccine and raises questions about FDAโs own approval process.
Our statement: bit.ly/44B8IvH
02.12.2025 15:01 โ ๐ 73 ๐ 30 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 0
Pretty impressive that through this entire scandal and press blitz, RFK Jr. hasn't lost focus on his life's work of shortening the life expectancy of the average American and endangering the lives of children.
01.12.2025 22:10 โ ๐ 2644 ๐ 621 ๐ฌ 40 ๐ 17
What I always find fascinating about comments like this is that they have been made about literally every immigrant group throughout American history: Germans, Irish, Miller's Jewish ancestors, etc.
28.11.2025 13:23 โ ๐ 139 ๐ 25 ๐ฌ 7 ๐ 3
We are now further away from the theatrical release of Raiders of the Lost Ark (June 12, 1981) than it was from the year it takes place in (1936). We have reached the Indiana Jones event horizon.
27.11.2025 00:49 โ ๐ 2806 ๐ 848 ๐ฌ 59 ๐ 130
The absolute fucking irony.
27.11.2025 17:55 โ ๐ 307 ๐ 96 ๐ฌ 7 ๐ 2
This is monstrous.
26.11.2025 16:15 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
impossible to describe how it felt in the mid-90s when "Possum Kingdom" was on the radio in good rotation, at work trying to mop up the glass/acid spill of a cartload of pickle boxes crashed on the floor while someone screams "Do you wanna die?" from a speaker cut into the drop ceiling.
25.11.2025 12:59 โ ๐ 216 ๐ 34 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 13
Disappointed to see that ASHP isnโt one of the organizations supporting this statement
23.11.2025 19:02 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Opinion | โThe System Is Meant to Break Youโ: What ICE Is Doing to People Here Legally
Unconscionable. Full stop. No excuses to be associated with or endorse or remain silent: www.nytimes.com/2025/11/21/o...
23.11.2025 17:49 โ ๐ 255 ๐ 128 ๐ฌ 11 ๐ 12
The screen door slams, Mary's dress sways
Like a vision she dances across the porch as the radio plays
Roy Orbison's singing for the lonely
Hey, that's me and I want you only
Don't turn me home again
I just can't face myself alone again
23.11.2025 01:42 โ ๐ 376 ๐ 69 ๐ฌ 16 ๐ 128
As I spent more and more of my life under the care of doctors, nurses, and researchers striving to improve the lives of others, I watched as Bobby cut nearly a half billion dollars for research into mRNA vaccines, technology that could be used against certain cancers; slashed billions in funding from the National Institutes of Health, the world's largest sponsor of medical research; and threatened to oust the panel of medical experts charged with recommending preventive cancer screenings. Hundreds of N.I.H. grants and clinical trials were cancelled, affecting thousands of patients. I worried about funding for leukemia and bone-marrow research at Memorial Sloan Kettering. I worried about the trials that were my only shot at remission. Early in my illness, when I
Just an absolutely gutting essay by Tatiana Schlossberg, a writer, mother of two young children, and cousin of RFK Jr who is dying of leukemia.
www.newyorker.com/culture/the-...
22.11.2025 16:09 โ ๐ 15125 ๐ 5421 ๐ฌ 376 ๐ 229
This is some scary shit you guys. Two pillars of the communityโmiddle aged white guys no lessโarrested because some off duty cop bastard sitting several booths away in a restaurant claims to have heard them โplotting against law enforcement.โ Weโre in the โears everywhere, trust no oneโ stage of it.
22.11.2025 12:39 โ ๐ 841 ๐ 239 ๐ฌ 13 ๐ 9
A Cocaine Bear movie poster featuring Fozzie Bear.
movie posters featuring the muppets: thread
22.11.2025 13:49 โ ๐ 1365 ๐ 338 ๐ฌ 38 ๐ 59
SEDITIOUS BEHAVIOR, punishable by DEATH!
When the restaurant TVs have motion smoothing on
20.11.2025 16:14 โ ๐ 144 ๐ 21 ๐ฌ 3 ๐ 3
The DoE has reclassified numerous health professional and other degrees, limiting access to federal student loan programs eligible for the higher OBBBA loan caps from thousands to a few hundred.
As ALWAYS, this is about $$.
We're about to become REALLY "great"...
shorturl.fm/xs7gY
21.11.2025 00:51 โ ๐ 495 ๐ 331 ๐ฌ 68 ๐ 94
I canโt get past this. what can you possibly still have on your hate symbol list once you take off the swastika?
20.11.2025 23:28 โ ๐ 712 ๐ 68 ๐ฌ 50 ๐ 4
Letโs talk about sedition and treason, because the most powerful yet inadequate man in the world is having a tantrum about it, and his soulless, spineless sycophants are boosting his message.
/1
20.11.2025 16:31 โ ๐ 8006 ๐ 2231 ๐ฌ 144 ๐ 156
The left has a problem with political violence. Anyway, hereโs the President of the United States saying his political opponents should be executed.
20.11.2025 14:46 โ ๐ 2549 ๐ 609 ๐ฌ 38 ๐ 19
A reminder that Republican bans have not reduced the abortion rate. All they've done is kill and harm women.
19.11.2025 15:11 โ ๐ 148 ๐ 28 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 1
ICE employee among 16 men arrested in Bloomington sex trafficking sting, police say
According to Bloomington Police Chief Booker Hodges, officers started the three-day sting on Nov. 5. They used several methods to find people who were attempting to solicit a 17-year-old girl for sex.
ICE employee among 16 men arrested in Bloomington sex trafficking sting, police say.
"When he was arrested, he said, 'I'm ICE, boys,'" Hodges said during a press conference Tuesday. "Well, unfortunately for him, we locked him up."
18.11.2025 23:59 โ ๐ 14576 ๐ 5230 ๐ฌ 575 ๐ 630
Senior staff writer, The Ringer
Be better tomorrow
Educator & advocate for little ones!
โHope and resilience are the enemy of fear.โ - Sophie and Colin Hortman
https://linktr.ee/katiejonesmn
I make Dad jokes on NPR and also write books and other things.
Constitutional law prof and historical political scientist studying:
The United States Supreme Court
American Political Development
Anglo-American Constitutionalism
๐Atlanta
Author, Rot and Revival:
https://www.ucpress.edu/books/rot-and-revival/paper
https://bookshop.org/p/books/a-heart-that-works-rob-delaney/3f4398e419f2db84
U.S. Senator for Maryland
vanhollen.senate.gov
Tag me and I will respond telling you how much a profanity you (or the user you're replying to) has used in the last year (it may take me a few minutes to respond).
7,227,479 total profanities counted, you pottymouths!
PharmD, BCCCP
Clinical Pharmacy Specialist, ICU/PK
Base Valdivia Hospital, Valdivia, Chile
Obstetrician-gynecologist with an interest in vaccines but also other topics - history, basketball and theater/music/movies.
https://www.linkedin.com/in/kevin-ault-15a93a46/ and https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&user=uwO23QkAAAAJ
Professor of Political Science & Director of the Saltzman Institute of War & Peace Studies, Columbia. New Book: The Insiders' Game: How Elites Make War and Peace https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691215808/the-insiders-game
โThe thing that was given to me by the universe was the chance to question it, and that is my divine duty.โ Leonardo da Vinci
https://linktr.ee/TheFutureIsFREE
Writer. Mope. I don't know what the hell you're talking about, Lucy, and I want you to shut up.
โLesbian consultant.โ โThe Chappell Roan of twitterโ (and maybe bluesky?) โA good argument, just miles outside the scope.โ Cis, she/her. Powered by iced tea and Carly Rae. I would love to do your podcast.
Southmayd Prof @YaleLawSch + Philosophy @Yale. Ed, @LegalTheory + Stanford Encyclopedia of Phil. โLegalityโ, โThe Internationalistsโ (with @oonahathaway), โFancy Bear Goes Phishing.โ Overuses โneurosymbolicโ
Editor-in-chief of The Contrarian, MSNBC contributor, dog and art lover, democracy defender, and pro-Oxford comma. Book recommendations welcomed.
mom close the door im doing journalism