The myth of the ‘marketplace of ideas’— and how it warps free speech
The so-called “marketplace of ideas” doesn’t simply reward truth or the strongest arguments— it rewards power. Without guardrails, the strongest players dominate while minority views are sidelined. Mary Anne Franks, professor at George Washington Law, warns nowhere is this more apparent than under Trump, who owns his own social media platform and uses it as a propaganda megaphone. The marketplace, as an idea, Franks says, “is not designed to get us truth or democracy or autonomy or any of the things that we think the First Amendment is supposed to get us.” Dahlia Lithwick, Senior Editor at Slate, adds, about the First Amendment, “There's both too much law and not enough law and an immense amount of abuse of the space between the two.”
The “market place of ideas” isn’t free or fair—it’s dominated by those with power. Especially when the President owns his own platform, says @maryannefranks.bsky.social. In this way, the Trump admin “has, not just skin in the game, [but] an entire shakedown racket,” says @dahlialithwick.bsky.social
28.09.2025 19:03 — 👍 189 🔁 63 💬 5 📌 2
Trump Isn’t Liberating D.C. He’s Subduing It.
We’ve seen this happen in other countries. We thought it couldn’t happen here. It is.
@billkristolbulwark.bsky.social: We’ve seen this happen in other countries. We thought it couldn’t happen here. It is.
Read Morning Shots only @thebulwark.com: www.thebulwark.com/p/trump-isnt...
12.08.2025 13:29 — 👍 290 🔁 94 💬 16 📌 2
Fascist instigator.
12.08.2025 13:54 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
They truly are trying to kill people.
12.08.2025 13:51 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Do something today to resist. Even small actions add up when millions of people do them.
10.08.2025 17:26 — 👍 605 🔁 173 💬 24 📌 13
10.08.2025 18:55 — 👍 14689 🔁 3677 💬 46 📌 153
White skin
29.07.2025 12:38 — 👍 3 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
The Master of Distraction Fails to Distract
Trump's epic Epstein fumble
This seems to be a good moment to remind folks that it was a singularly bad idea to elect a convicted felon - a man found liable for sexual abuse, who bragged about grabbing women, and consorted with the world’s most notorious pedophile — to the presidency.
charliesykes.substack.com/p/the-master...
13.07.2025 15:30 — 👍 849 🔁 223 💬 38 📌 13
Words & Phrases We Can Do Without
DHS is a human rights monstrosity
No decent American could fail to be horrified and deeply ashamed that our government, under the auspices of the Orwellian name, “Department of Homeland Security,” is complicit in these human rights atrocities.
open.substack.com/pub/contrari...
08.07.2025 12:06 — 👍 1131 🔁 359 💬 45 📌 11
Alligator Alcatraz detainees allege inhumane conditions at immigration detention center
Detainees claim they are enduring inhumane conditions, including lack of access to water, inadequate food and denial of religious rights.
People in Alligator Auschwitz describe the inhumane conditions in the concentration camp—insufficient water, scarce and unsanitary food, lack of medicine, denial of religious rights, etc.
“They're not respecting our human rights. We're human beings—we're not dogs. We're like rats in an experiment."
08.07.2025 11:45 — 👍 5507 🔁 2967 💬 439 📌 369
LA school district demands inquiry after Ice officers filmed urinating on campus
Officials in Pico Rivera say agents gathered before a raid and soiled parking lot after being asked to leave
ICE agents were caught on camera unlawfully trespassing and urinating on the grounds of an LA public school, risking exposure to minors.
They’re not only terrorizing our communities—illegally kidnapping people—but also urinating on playgrounds.
ICE is a morally bankrupt, state terror organization.
07.07.2025 15:19 — 👍 1857 🔁 812 💬 108 📌 61
How the Supreme Court Gerrymandered the Law to Serve the GOP
Read more here.
“This Supreme Court is reshaping the law to reflect Republican priorities — weakening Medicaid protections, approving conservative religious carveouts and creating exceptions that benefit the GOP,” Leah Litman writes.
www.democracydocket.com/opinion/how-...
04.07.2025 22:01 — 👍 526 🔁 194 💬 30 📌 7
As we celebrate this 4th of July, we must remember why we celebrate. It was on this day that our nation declared independence from a mad king who abused his power and the people of this land.
Just as in 1776, these grievances remain just as relevant today. Because in America, there are no kings.
04.07.2025 19:15 — 👍 2385 🔁 718 💬 100 📌 47
Same…
04.07.2025 01:02 — 👍 9097 🔁 2124 💬 164 📌 103
04.07.2025 00:12 — 👍 51538 🔁 13508 💬 1559 📌 592
Kilmar Abrego Garcia was tortured at CECOT.
He was subjected to severe beatings, severe sleep deprivation, inadequate nutrition, and psychological torture; forced to kneel from approximately 9:00 PM to 6:00 AM; and threatened with transfer to the cells with gang members who would "tear" him apart.
03.07.2025 00:24 — 👍 1357 🔁 634 💬 46 📌 38
Democracies use government as an instrument for the common good. Using a tax bill to destroy and deny health care for 17 million of our people is a sign of authoritarianism.
02.07.2025 13:52 — 👍 5532 🔁 1791 💬 367 📌 64
Early estimates indicate that it will cost around $450 million a year to operate the detention camp. ChatGPT estimates it would cost about $440 million a year to permanently house all homeless veterans. I think that speaks volumes about the priorities of the Trump administration.
02.07.2025 20:51 — 👍 490 🔁 191 💬 10 📌 7
While “Fiscal Conservatives” are issuing strongly worded letters to House Leadership (for real, that actually happened) — Republicans have stalled out on the Floor without enough votes to move to the #BigUglyBill. Here’s your mid-afternoon update. ⬇️
02.07.2025 20:11 — 👍 421 🔁 109 💬 25 📌 6
I’ve been thinking a lot about Murkowski’s vote. It contains, in one action, so much that defines our pathetic political moment:
Selfishness: I’m taking care of me and mine, the rest of you can pound sand;
Lack of accountability: I know the bill is bad, hopefully someone else will fix it;
02.07.2025 19:41 — 👍 5920 🔁 1594 💬 227 📌 84
Yes, it's 2025. Time to be current in our scientific knowledge and our compassion for fellow humans. Healthcare is between the person and their doctor.
02.07.2025 22:42 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
RNC Sues Arizona To Block Voting Access for Overseas U.S. Citizens
Read more here.
ICYMI: Republicans are suing to block an Arizona law that lets some overseas citizens vote in the state. This new challenge fits into a broader Republican legal strategy to undermine overseas voting access.
www.democracydocket.com/news-alerts/...
02.07.2025 13:02 — 👍 197 🔁 71 💬 12 📌 8
Let's remember this..
These women don't even support women much less anyone else. They are disgraceful.
29.06.2025 04:58 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
While Senate Republicans and the White House are trying to cut dirty deals and jam their big abomination of a bill through the Senate Floor—I want to take a moment to thank the three heroines of the Supreme Court holding it down for our democracy and the rule of law every day! So grateful! ❤️
29.06.2025 02:46 — 👍 1287 🔁 297 💬 38 📌 11
YouTube video by Rep. Melanie Stansbury
Rep. Stansbury: The big abomination of a bill is in the Senate, here’s an update
ONCE AGAIN in the dark of night—Republicans are trying to jam their Big Abomination of a Bill through Congress. This is what’s going on tonight after they jammed a motion to proceed through the Senate in a 51-49 vote. Obviously, I’ll be a very hell NO on this bill. ⬇️
29.06.2025 04:13 — 👍 689 🔁 177 💬 29 📌 7
Grrrrr
28.06.2025 20:48 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
www.cbpp.org/press/statem...
28.06.2025 16:54 — 👍 41 🔁 23 💬 1 📌 0
Fake wrestling
28.06.2025 20:41 — 👍 3 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
This is on Trump’s head. Should be headline in every paper
26.06.2025 23:03 — 👍 2011 🔁 839 💬 88 📌 38
Econ professor at Michigan ● Senior fellow, Brookings ● Intro econ textbook author ● Think Like An Economist podcast ● An economist willing to admit that the glass really is half full.
Chair & President, Media Matters. An all around good guy fueled by caffeine, candy and comeuppance. Posts are mine alone.
Temerty Professor of Modern European History, Munk School, University of Toronto; Permanent Fellow, IWM Vienna; Emeritus Levin Professor, Yale. Author of "On Freedom," "On Tyranny," "Our Malady," "Road to Unfreedom," "Black Earth," and "Bloodlands"
Founder and Executive Director @protectdemocracy.org. Former Associate White House Counsel. Tweets my own.
Congresswoman representing New Mexico’s 1st Congressional District. Fighting for our future. Working to build a better world. Trail runner & chile connoisseur. ❤️🌶️
My children are Jesse & Jaime. Jaime was murdered in the Parkland school shooting. My life is dedicated to saving lives fighting for gun safety in America and have written two books Find The Helpers and American Carnage.
Surgeon, Writer ("Being Mortal," "Checklist Manifesto"), and formerly led Global Health @USAID.
Dad. Husband. Coach. Independent. New Yorker. Veteran. Host: @indyamericans.bsky.social. Founder: @indyvetsofamerica.bsky.social, Righteous, @amvets4ukraine.bsky.social, IAVA, Operation Liberty. Fighting for Democracy: https://linktr.ee/paulrieckhoff
Official Bluesky account for the #50501Movement
#NoKings 10/18 Made History!!
#BoycottSpotify #BoycottHomeDepot
Join the Movement > https://FiftyFifty.one
The official Milwaukee chapter of the national 50501 Movement | 50 States • 50 Protests • 1 Movement | For the People, Forward Milwaukee
https://linktr.ee/50501.milwaukee
Publisher of The Bulwark. Host of the Focus Group Podcast. Co-host, The Next Level. Become a subscriber: http://TheBulwark.com/join
Bronx boy. Cubs fan. Dad, husband, writer, podcaster and cable news host.
The Sirens’ Call: How Attention Became the World’s Most Endangered Resource out now.
https://sirenscallbook.com/
We use the law to advance a bold, vibrant democracy for all people by defending progress, disrupting extremism, and building for the future. Join us at democracyforward.org
I stand for🗽& ⚖️ for All 🇺🇸 Voted for #HarrisWalz2024 for our civil liberties. We have more in common than what separates us, time to unite against Trump. We must prepare for 2026 Midterms.
50 States, 50 Protests, 1 Day
Bubbly artist commissionable and proficient in many traditional mediums
I love hand engraving metal works and drawing with Copic markers