Growing up Different(ly than Last Time We Asked): Social Status and Changing Reports of Childhood Income Rank - Social Indicators Research
How we remember our past can be shaped by the realities of our present. This study examines how changes to present circumstances influence retrospective reports of family income rank at age 16. While retrospective survey data can be used to assess the long-term effects of childhood conditions, present-day circumstances may “anchor” memories, causing shifts in how individuals recall and report past experiences. Using panel data from the 2006–2014 General Social Surveys (8,602 observations from 2,883 individuals in the United States), we analyze how changes in objective and subjective indicators of current social status—income, financial satisfaction, and perceived income relative to others—are associated with changes in reports of childhood income rank, and how this varies by sex and race/ethnicity. Fixed-effects models reveal no significant association between changes in income and in childhood income rank. However, changes in subjective measures of social status show contrasting effects, as increases in current financial satisfaction are associated with decreases in childhood income rank, but increases in current perceived relative income are associated with increases in childhood income rank. We argue these opposing effects follow from theories of anchoring in recall bias. We further find these effects are stronger among males but are consistent across racial/ethnic groups. This demographic heterogeneity suggests that recall bias is not evenly distributed across the population and has important implications for how different groups perceive their own pasts. Our findings further highlight the malleability of retrospective perceptions and their sensitivity to current social conditions, offering methodological insights into survey reliability and recall bias.
The GSS asked the same people about their childhood income rank three different times. 56% changed their answer, even though what was trying to be measured couldn’t change! We dig into this in a new article at @socialindicators.bsky.social.
doi.org/10.1007/s112...
🧵👇 (1/5)
10.10.2025 14:05 — 👍 44 🔁 19 💬 2 📌 1
13.10.2025 10:49 — 👍 999 🔁 265 💬 3 📌 5
Very excited to have this launched.
13.10.2025 05:49 — 👍 72 🔁 23 💬 0 📌 1
NEW: These are all the Education Dept. offices that staffers and managers say have been impacted by layoffs since Friday, according to the union for the agency’s employees.
They include workers that supported HBCUs, tribal colleges, charter schools, civil rights reviews, special ed & more.
12.10.2025 23:30 — 👍 46 🔁 40 💬 0 📌 5
After 35 years at UT Austin, I hardly recognize my university | Opinion
What was once a beacon of access and discovery is now fighting for its soul and mission as political attacks upend norms, rules and rights, Lisa L. Moore writes.
After 35 years at UT Austin, I hardly recognize my university | @austinstatesman.bsky.social
What was once a beacon of access and discovery is now fighting for its soul and mission as political attacks upend norms, rules and rights
www.statesman.com/opinion/colu...
11.10.2025 16:23 — 👍 42 🔁 20 💬 2 📌 0
Black Unemployment Is Surging Again. This Time Is Different.
Attacks on the federal workforce are also attacks on Black workers, who are overrepresented in the public sector.
Black unemployment is 7.5%. I'm reminded of Coates' observation that Black Americans regularly experience conditions that would be considered a crisis if whites faced them.
12.10.2025 12:51 — 👍 1443 🔁 521 💬 17 📌 25
Trump Administration Will Rehire Scores of Experts Fired in Error
New reporting: many apparently fired at CDC in 'error'. This is a failure by design given that the admin does not care about fulfilling agency missions. This is the kind of error that should have political consequences.
Unserious people cause real-world harm.
🎁
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/11/h...
11.10.2025 22:35 — 👍 327 🔁 131 💬 11 📌 24
Abstracts due December 1
11.10.2025 17:35 — 👍 2 🔁 5 💬 0 📌 0
I've been saying this exact thing in talks. They are breaking things that aren't easy to fix. And in some cases, like civil rights, destroying a legacy that took a couple of centuries to build, and don't have a ton of buy-in from dems, even if they get power back.
11.10.2025 13:57 — 👍 87 🔁 21 💬 4 📌 0
They know they won't be in power forever. So, they're breaking as much as they can right now, in the hope that whoever follows them won't be able to put it all back together.
11.10.2025 13:54 — 👍 712 🔁 209 💬 25 📌 12
**always follow the money**
PE firm behind for-profit universities using its WH influence to handwrite terms that will eviscerate, hamstring and control its own competitors in higher ed…and NY Times giving space to the CEO to come out and admit this influence in a pro-Compact piece
11.10.2025 11:10 — 👍 33 🔁 13 💬 1 📌 0
Private equity gets its toothhold into firms through economic squeezing, devalues them, then breaks them into parts to sell off. This compact is the squeeze that will simultaneously advantage for-profit ed *and* make it easier to PE-ify non-profit ed. The ideological component is a means to an end.
11.10.2025 11:31 — 👍 69 🔁 27 💬 2 📌 1
aaand we are officially in the hide-your-neighbors stage
10.10.2025 22:31 — 👍 19166 🔁 7693 💬 297 📌 246
Here's a snippet from the MIT president's letter to ED
10.10.2025 14:12 — 👍 304 🔁 92 💬 4 📌 5
The Virginia Senate just told UVA it’s not getting state funding if it accepts the compact since UVA exists to serve Virginia, its residents, & their interests—not be a tool of the federal govt. Scoop from our student newspaper, who’ve been doing vital reporting www.cavalierdaily.com/article/2025...
10.10.2025 21:45 — 👍 3762 🔁 1052 💬 39 📌 92
More of this. Signing this authoritarian devil’s bargain would betray higher education’s independence and the pursuit of knowledge.
10.10.2025 14:09 — 👍 133 🔁 29 💬 1 📌 1
'When authoritarians seize power, it is crucial to recognize courageous defenders of freedom who rise and resist,' the Norwegian Nobel Committee said as it announced Maria Corina Machado as the winner of the 2025 Nobel Peace Prize
10.10.2025 09:30 — 👍 5209 🔁 1866 💬 145 📌 404
Journals and publishers crack down on research from open health data sets
PLOS, Frontiers, and others announce policies trying to stem the tide of suspect research
"Frontiers has announced a similar change, requiring editors to automatically reject papers that use public health data sets without some kind of “external validation.” www.science.org/content/arti...
09.10.2025 22:17 — 👍 10 🔁 5 💬 1 📌 0
Indicting political opponents & critics because they are political opponents & critics is terrifying.
It's completely inconsistent with the rule of law & democracy.
It should scare everyone - and (hopefully) will get people to realize that we all need to stand against this.
09.10.2025 20:53 — 👍 1307 🔁 372 💬 40 📌 13
Trump Fires Black Officials From an Overwhelmingly White Administration
It is simply accurate to call this regime segregationist.
09.10.2025 11:24 — 👍 1543 🔁 445 💬 27 📌 23
Job posting! OU Sociology is looking to hire a TT Assistant Professor or an accelerated TT or tenured Associate Professor, teaching criminology, criminal justice, & race/ethnicity courses. OU is OK's flagship R1, PhD program, 2-2 load with TA help. Please share!
Details: apply.interfolio.com/174925
08.10.2025 16:15 — 👍 21 🔁 19 💬 1 📌 1
A fragmented legal system and threat of deportation are pushing higher education out of reach for many undocumented students
While some students living in the US without legal authorization can apply for private scholarships or state-based financial aid, a growing number of states are changing the rules.
ASA member Vanessa Delgado @vanessadelgado.bsky.social (Washington State University) was interviewed about higher education pathways for students living in the U.S. without legal authorization & the ways the administration is affecting their options. @us.theconversation.com
08.10.2025 13:36 — 👍 3 🔁 5 💬 0 📌 0
Super excited for this discussion on the structural determinants of health, moderated by Paula Braveman. A powerhouse panel - @tyson-brown.bsky.social @povertyscholar.bsky.social and Jonathan Heller
07.10.2025 16:38 — 👍 9 🔁 4 💬 0 📌 0
@sgbuggs.bsky.social's tether.
sociologist into racism, intimacy + culture. co-editor/author of Unsafe Words (2023). disaster bi 🏳️🌈. food/theater/fashion/tv junkie. black feminist killjoy.
shantelgbuggs.com
Chair of sociology at JHU KSAS. Study democracy and try to rescue it at SNF Agora Institute. Previously at UNC Sociology and IAH. #GDTBATH. Swarthmore and UC Berkeley alum. Proud Baltimorean.
JD/PhD. Interdisciplinary sociologist, law & society, transnational gender & sexuality. I research marriage, esp in S Africa. And I organize with colleagues to defend higher ed. Opinions mine not employer's.
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2802-3365
Author: Captive Cosmopolitans:
Black Mariners and the World of South Atlantic Slavery
https://uncpress.org/book/9781469671468/captive-cosmopolitans/
Words at ballsandstrikes.org, and even more words in The Originalism Trap: How Extremists Stole the Constitution and How We the People Can Take It Back
Out now at tinyurl.com/originalismtrap !
Professor & Chief of the Division of Ethics @Columbia University, medical anthropologist, Co-director of ELSIhub/CERA @columbiaethics.bsky.social, @elsihub.bsky.social
https://www.mhe.cuimc.columbia.edu/profile/sandra-s-lee-phd
Sociologist. Origins-LA Latina🇲🇽. Author of #learningtobelatino Research: #highereducation #latinos #activism RT or ❤️ not endorsement
https://www.daisyverduzcoreyes.com/
Love. Intimacy. Geopolitics. Political geographer at UNC-CH. Author of Intimate Geopolitics & Political Geography: a Critical Introduction. Insta @geogsara and @landbackabolition. Free 🇵🇸
https://linktr.ee/geogsara
Postdoc in the EqualStrength project @ the University of Lausanne. Previously, Trento, Mannheim, & Indiana University.
Born in 🇩🇪, grew up in 🇺🇸, now 🇨🇭
Studying ethnic, racial, and gender inequality via (quasi)experiments.
Sociologist. Mamá. Hablo español.
Professor of Sociology and administrative data infrastructure enthusiast at UC Irvine. My book (Schooled & Sorted) examines the role of categorization in education and how we can create more egalitarian categories.
CathyDavidson.com. Advocate for active learning, student success. Author “The New Education” etc. Cofounder HASTAC.org ("world's first academic social network"--NSF). Science fiction fan. Lover of oceans. Opinions and typos my own. #SeaScrolling #Breathe
Digital Behavioral & Social Science Data Archive with 800+ member institutions worldwide. ICPSR is a unit within the Institute for Social Research at the University of Michigan.
Web: icpsr.umich.edu
Help: icpsr-help@umich.edu
Yale SOM professor & Bulls fan. I study consumer finance, and econometrics is a big part of my research identity. He/him/his
Professor of Pol. Sci. UMich-Flint. Political Theory and Labor Studies. Author "The Political Theory of Salvage" https://sunypress.edu/Books/T/The-Political-Theory-of-Salvage. Opinions solely my own and do not reflect my institution.
Personal account. Personal views. Frank G. Millard Professor of Law, University of Michigan Law School & Arlene Susan Kohn Professor of Social Policy, University of Michigan Ford School of Public Policy. Former General Counsel, HHS and OMB.
Professor of Law & Criminal Justice interested in INjustice. Research #forensics #AI science/tech in criminal justice. Also crazy about anti-fascism, atheism, Prince, professional cycling, politics, the news, live comedy and music. #academicsky (1st-gen)
Reporter, Los Angeles Times. I cover the University of California and more in higher and K-12 education. Former national and foreign correspondent. Big fan of reporting on religion. Based in Los Angeles.
Senior Researcher at Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods, Bonn. Understanding educational and labor market inequality through evidence-based research. Passionate about data, innovative methods, and impactful science communication.