Screenshot of opening paras of my piece:
Chatbots Are Antithetical to Learning
By Emily M. Bender
Across higher education, administrators, faculty, staff, and students are being inundated with claims that large language models (often marketed as โAIโ) represent the future of both education and the workplace. They tell us that prompt engineering and so on are essential skills that students must master to be competitive, and that all of this tech will bring us unparalleled efficiency gains, allowing us to focus on โwhat really matters.โ The reason for this messaging isnโt any actual scientific breakthrough but rather the desperation of tech companies to try to recoup their massive investment in so-called AI. Unfortunately, these calls are also frequently coming from inside the house, with university administrators and some faculty jumping on the bandwagon and singing the companiesโ advertising jingles for them.
But synthetic text-extruding machines are in fact antithetical to the mission of education.
Writing is thinking and learning. Pushing a button to generate an essay-shaped object requires little thinking and accomplishes minimal learning. Sharing synthetic text with an instructor means missing out on genuine feedback and help with honing both arguments and authorial voice. When teachers value the polished but anodyne text extruded from these systems over studentsโ authentic voices, we reinforce harmful linguistic ideologies, including those that associate stigmatized varieties of language with lack of โintelligence.โ
A little belatedly sharing this piece that I published in @chronicle.com 's Opinion Forum (sorry full text is paywalled)
www.chronicle.com/article/how-...
20.11.2025 00:46 โ ๐ 137 ๐ 33 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 3
A photo of Mar, a Customer Services Specialist at the Southeast Branch, with this longer quote: โI have seen so many of my public service coworkers give their everything to give the members of our community the best possible outcomes and support, and we as workers simply deserve the same. Forming a union builds a community-based power, giving us a seat at the table to actively influence how the library operates, ensuring we serve our community the best we can.โ
Mar is organizing a union with his co-workers at @columbuslibrary.bsky.social because โI have seen so many of my public service coworkers give their everything to give the members of our community the best possible outcomes and support, and we as workers simply deserve the same.โ
19.11.2025 21:27 โ ๐ 3 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
A photo of Emily, a Youth Engagement Specialist at CML's South High Branch. With a longer version of her quote: โMy colleagues and I go above and beyond for every person who enters the library on a daily basis. We all chose this profession because we want to help and serve our communities. All the while, most of us are unable to afford to live in the neighborhoods where we work. A union would provide us the chance to have a voice in how our own workplaces are run while holding those at the top accountable when necessary.โ
Emily is organizing a union with her co-workers at @columbuslibrary.bsky.social because "A union would provide us the chance to have a voice in how our own workplaces are run while holding those at the top accountable when necessary.โ
19.11.2025 21:25 โ ๐ 2 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
A photo of Adi, a Customer Services Specialist at CML Main Library, with the same quote that is also in the post.
Adi is organizing a union with her co-workers at @columbuslibrary.bsky.social because โTo continue on during these times without a union would be a surrender to the attack Ohio libraries are facing. A union will empower us to advocate for a better workplace benefiting workers and patrons alike.โ
19.11.2025 21:22 โ ๐ 4 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
i am also a survivor of sexual violence who works in a field where sexual harassment is incredibly normalized, so perhaps iโm sensitive, but!
i simply donโt think we have to accept a world where existing as a person in the world means a non-zero risk of having your image turned into porn!
19.11.2025 17:21 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
whenever a story like this breaks, i think about the way AI slop salespeople and their allies insist that their tech is โinevitable.โ
โitโs here whether you like it or not!โ
the entire project is rotten, but i keep getting caught on on how explicitly anti-consent it is.
19.11.2025 17:19 โ ๐ 4 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
thank you for being part of the fight thenโ we are going to win this one! ๐
18.11.2025 18:23 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
happy to be part of this! ๐
18.11.2025 17:15 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
A graphic with a photo of Phoebe and the text: โWe can't rely on our administration or the government to protect our labor rights or the most vulnerable of our customers and coworkers. We need to protect each other, we need to have solidarity with each other, and we need to use the power that we have in our numbers to organize and demand that our rights and dignity as employees are upheld.โ โ Phoebe, Customer Services Specialist, Linden Branch
โWe need to protect each other, we need to have solidarity with each other, and we need to use the power that we have in our numbers to organize and demand that our rights and dignity as employees are upheld.โ โ Phoebe, Customer Services Specialist, Linden Branch
18.11.2025 15:18 โ ๐ 6 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
A graphic with a photo of Ryan and the text: โI believe my coworkers and I have the right to fight for a better workplace.โ โ Ryan, Adult Services Librarian, Main Library
โI believe my coworkers and I have the right to fight for a better workplace.โ โ Ryan, Adult Services Librarian, Main Library
18.11.2025 15:17 โ ๐ 5 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
A graphic with a photo of Maria and the text: โAs attacks on libraries increase locally and nationally, library workers need every tool available to ensure our ability to continue to provide vital resources to our community. A union will strengthen our voice in our workplace, our job security, and ability to sustainably do the work we love.โ โ Maria, Librarian, Local History and Genealogy (Main Library)
โLibrary workers need every tool available to ensure our ability to continue to provide vital resources to our community. A union will strengthen our voice in our workplace, our job security, & ability to sustainably do the work we love.โ โ Maria, Librarian, Local History and Genealogy
18.11.2025 15:13 โ ๐ 5 ๐ 1 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
A graphic with a photo of Caitlin and the text: โI believe we as employees know what our communities need. Our voices should be reflected in decisions at CML to better support our patrons and each other.โ โ Caitlin, Information Service Specialist, Franklinton Branch
Why are @columbuslibrary.bsky.social workers organizing their union?
โI believe we as employees know what our communities need. Our voices should be reflected in decisions at CML to better support our patrons and each other.โ โ Caitlin, Information Service Specialist, Franklinton Branch
18.11.2025 15:13 โ ๐ 7 ๐ 3 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
A Massive Archiving Effort at National Parks (with Jenny McBurney and Lynda Kellam)
Podcast Episode ยท The 404 Media Podcast ยท 2025-11-10 ยท 46m
โThe current administration is trying to scrub websites, datasets, and now signs in National Parks (and on other public lands) of words or ideas that they don't like. We're trying to preserve this content to help preserve our full history, not just a tidy whitewashed version.โ
Listen now:
10.11.2025 14:17 โ ๐ 53 ๐ 18 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
YouTube video by 404 Media
Volunteers Archived 10,000 Signs from National Parks (with Jenny McBurney and Lynda Kellam)
Trump wants to erase any "negative" content from educational sites at National Parks.
This week, @samleecole.bsky.social speaks to a group of data preservationists behind "Save Our Signs" who want to save the real history of parks before the administration erases it.
10.11.2025 14:15 โ ๐ 167 ๐ 56 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 0
Iโve seen several Godzilla flicks in the theater over the past few years and you can feel, viscerally, that we are all praying for Godzilla to rise from the sea and give us what we deserve
09.11.2025 14:52 โ ๐ 759 ๐ 116 ๐ฌ 8 ๐ 0
AI's capabilities may be exaggerated by flawed tests, according to new study
A study from the Oxford Internet Institute analyzed 445 tests used to evaluate AI models.
I appreciate the work of these authors to show that this problem not only is still here but has grown:
www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-ne...
But it is also quite frustrating ๐งต>>
09.11.2025 14:59 โ ๐ 257 ๐ 102 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 6
Paneraโs moderately caffeinated lemonade was loosely associated with 2 deaths before it was taken off market.
This article alone has 4 examples of ChatGPT encouraging young people to commit suicide, and OpenAIโs own public stats estimate over a million users discuss suicide with ChatGPT each week.
07.11.2025 22:56 โ ๐ 9884 ๐ 3861 ๐ฌ 105 ๐ 180
The Return of the Luddites | Los Angeles Review of Books
Erik J. Larson considers โThe AI Con: How to Fight Big Techโs Hype and Create the Future We Wantโ by Emily M. Bender and Alex Hanna.
"By insisting on the term 'automation,' Bender and Hanna reveal that whatโs sold as innovation is often just labor displacement with better branding."
Erik J. Larson discusses "The AI Con" by Emily M. Bender and Alex Hanna: https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-return-of-the-luddites/
01.11.2025 13:34 โ ๐ 39 ๐ 12 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
I think every time someone pitches this article, which we have seen in one form or another for as long as class has existed, they should get a fastball from a pitching machine right to the groin
31.10.2025 17:09 โ ๐ 255 ๐ 39 ๐ฌ 8 ๐ 1
look iโm just sayingโ she and her wigs would absolutely have a great time on this
30.10.2025 14:42 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
nicole kidman as aimee semple mcpherson in a limited series about her lifeโฆโฆ..
29.10.2025 20:21 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
I once had to go to a food pantry in November, and because it was close to Thanksgiving, the line to get in wrapped around the block. This was back in the early 2000s. Also when people had access to SNAP. Imagine what it will be this year without it.
22.10.2025 09:33 โ ๐ 95 ๐ 23 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 2
unfortunately it has a character whose trauma turned them into kind of a dick so i am unable to not like it
17.10.2025 00:47 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
also some clunky dialogue and a plot that is justโฆ all over the place
but mostly the ice skating thing
17.10.2025 00:46 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
black phone 2 runs aground on the fact that itโs just not possible to ice skate in a menacing way
17.10.2025 00:45 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
wifi down at the library . may god have mercy on our souls
16.10.2025 17:53 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
They pay brisk money for this crap?
essays and recipes @ https://stone-soup.ghost.io/
public librarian in columbus, oh.
talk unions to me.
fighting for better transit for all.
grassroots, volunteer run. meetings at the main library on the 2nd tuesday of every month. open to everybody. :)
https://transitcolumbus.org/events
Covering Ohio State womenโs basketball on Land-Grant Holy Land, Big Ten WBB and CLE WNBA on The IX Sports. Plus some independent WNBA coverage on Lakefront Courtside. Big Ten WBB voter.
At a concert. Music writing at Columbus Calling.
Abolish golf.
Retired Manic Pixie Dreamgirl.
Smarter than I act online.
Overeducated and understimulated.
Co-owner and editor for With an X Books
https://bsky.app/profile/withanxbooks.bsky.social
https://www.withanxbooks.com/
OFT represents Ohio educators & support staff (k-12, charter & higher ed), social workers, library workers & other public employees. Affiliate of AFT.
Connecting Ohioans to our state government and its impact on our lives. Free to republish, we are the Ohio Capital Journal, reporting for the people.
Sign up: ohiocapitaljournal.com/subscribe
https://olivia.science
assistant professor of computational cognitive science ยท she/they ยท cypriot/kฤฑbrฤฑslฤฑ/ฮบฯ
ฯฯฮฑฮฏฮฑ ยท ฯแฝบฮฝ แผฮธฮทฮฝแพท ฮบฮฑแฝถ ฯฮตแฟฯฮฑ ฮบฮฏฮฝฮตฮน
Author, game dev, ghost writer. Lets Read! NoSleep Podcast editor/contributor. Former Raze. Worked on The Charnel House Trilogy and Richard & Alice and stuff. Owl Cave CEO and Joli Good Productions Co-Founder. Call me Sheet Ghost.
Inquiries: LL@LoreleiLee.work
V*nmo: @Lorelei-Lee
C*shapp: $LoreleiLee
they/them, sw, disabled, writer, organizer, cyborg, porn performer, etc.
ojibwe. mama bear. land defender. founder @giniwcollective. co-founder @notyourmascots. words @nytimes @vogue @cnn. zhaabo@gmail.com
I research youth studies and environmental sociology: young people, climate action & climate justice, and I am a dinosaur from the internet.
๐จโ๐ญSenior Lecturer @ Manchester Met Uni
๐Quaker | #COYS | (he/him)
๐ www.bennosaurus.com
Occam's Trowel, Sifting archaeological fringe to get to archaeological fact. Pseudoarchaeology, Paranormal Archaeology, Archaeogaming, and other random thoughts.
#Metis archaeologist in amiskwacรฎwรขskahikan. Advocating for Indigenous heritage rights. Helping communities find their children.
big famous microblogger
pet account reactionary
flamboyant wrecker
goddess of uselessness
[she/her] texan in ma. Adonis' mom
IWTV | NSFW | Millennial | adults only, please | I will talk about politics | Canyon
Me and my smut against the world (tumblr's garbage flagging system).
she/they | 30s | Romania
ko-fi: https://ko-fi.com/ttfffffffff
prints: https://www.inprnt.com/gallery/ttf/
I don't do commissions.
DO NOT REPOST MY ART OUTSIDE OF BSKY!
Bram Stoker Award-winning author ๐ณ๏ธโโง๏ธ
Jewelry designer & metalsmith sofiazakia.com
COUP DE GRรCE
BURY YOUR GAYS: AN ANTHOLOGY OF TRAGIC QUEER HORROR
https://linktr.ee/sofiaajram
NYT bestselling author of EMPIRE OF AI: empireofai.com. ai reporter. national magazine award & american humanist media award winner. words in The Atlantic. formerly WSJ, MIT Tech Review, KSJ@MIT. email: http://karendhao.com/contact.