If you are applying to a PhD, don't use an LLM in composing your proposal.
If you are doing a PhD, don't use an LLM to do the writing and reading and thinking for you.
Sorry, I am going to die on this hill.
@michaelmurphy.bsky.social
Professional astrophysicist, amateur human. Science fan, renewables groupie, political malcontent. Professor at Swinburne University of Technology. Opinions my own.
If you are applying to a PhD, don't use an LLM in composing your proposal.
If you are doing a PhD, don't use an LLM to do the writing and reading and thinking for you.
Sorry, I am going to die on this hill.
It is hard to feel safe when you fear people who (you think) aren't exactly like yourself.
29.07.2025 05:06 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0I didn't get the memo. Is the "Harvard Professor" involved somehow?
29.07.2025 00:37 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0Spain bids β¬400 million to host mega telescope at risk in US budget cuts www.nature.com/articles/d41...
24.07.2025 22:28 β π 9 π 3 π¬ 0 π 0We moved from BB to Canvas about 8 years ago. At that time, at least, Canvas was much better. I mean, still needlessly complex and jargon-loaded, but usable. No-one here misses BB.
24.07.2025 13:18 β π 3 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0An RBA paper suggests the rapid growth in foreign students post-pandemic did not play a big role in pushing rents higher.
24.07.2025 07:08 β π 16 π 3 π¬ 2 π 3Especially when thereβs no space between the words and the em dash.
21.07.2025 22:09 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0A view of the interior of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation building in Ultimo. A tall airy atrium with balconies and lots of light.
Visited the ABC building in Sydney and had a wonderful chat with David Marr for Late Night Live. You can listen tonight at around 10:30pm (not, in this case, actually live!) www.abc.net.au/listen/progr...
09.07.2025 07:00 β π 323 π 21 π¬ 9 π 2They seem to be β¦Β how to put this β¦Β struggling to find their editorial niche. Opinions from academics outside their expertise areas wasn't their original proposal, I recall.
09.07.2025 06:48 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0A photo of cat sitting in some Venetian blinds they have just destroyed with the text JOY DIVISION at the top and UNKNOWN PLEASURES at the bottom
This might be my favourite cat meme of 2025 so far
08.07.2025 21:51 β π 5315 π 1518 π¬ 30 π 48By the way, none of this research would be possible without Australia's access to @eso.org facilities via the current strategic partnership. That ends in a couple of years!
We should join ESO as a full member β invest in a stable partner at the government treaty level.
ESO telescope time allocation day. I had a good run this time, together with excellent collaborators. Commiserations to those who didn't.
I'm a professor & don't need plaudits, but it's nice to have a panel of peers say "Yeah, that's a good idea, and well presented".
Gas companies want to charge you for using gas.
They also want to charge you for others not using gas.
(If only those who said that this would happen could charge people for not taking their advice!)
To me, peer review might be OK to determine if something should be published, say, but scoring/ranking proposals relative to each other is a completely different thing. Conflating the latter with βpeer reviewβ has never made completely sense to me.
02.07.2025 12:20 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0Has anyone has ever tested the outcomes of grants (or other type of proposal) against the score or ranking during the βpeer reviewβ process? From your statement, I guess not.
02.07.2025 12:20 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 2 π 0Although we like to imagine that conventional peer review is the βgold standardβ, this prejudice is not borne out by evidence.
The only way to test it is to duplicate review and see how well it reproduces. The available evidence indicates that it is indistinguishable from distributed peer review.
Then I try to carry on after thinking that it probably will.
01.07.2025 01:14 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0Then I stare at the screen for a few more seconds wondering if that'll actually happen.
01.07.2025 01:14 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0Every time NASA/ADS takes a second or two longer than usual to find a paper, my heart skips a beat as I worry it's been defunded and taken down.
01.07.2025 01:14 β π 2 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0Anybody got a picture of Annie Walker? Possibly first British professional astronomer, later moved to Oz. www.theguardian.com/science/2025...
30.06.2025 06:49 β π 17 π 12 π¬ 0 π 3Disappointed the Spectator deleted this blog post heralding a pause in global warming based on 2 years of data.
www.spectator.co.uk/2017/06/trut...
We cross live to Peter Dutton for his takeβ¦
27.06.2025 07:25 β π 3 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0π³
14.06.2025 00:48 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0Similar story for me and the didnβt know that either! Do the baby teeth fall out or something at a young age? I donβt recall any random fangs on the carpet!
13.06.2025 12:50 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0Yes, but in true Australian style, it has no Government funding and is "seeking funders" (i.e. donations) π
13.06.2025 07:25 β π 2 π 1 π¬ 1 π 0Electric vehicle myths: more than half Australians wrongly believe EVs are more likely to catch fire, survey shows
09.06.2025 23:39 β π 28 π 9 π¬ 6 π 1βΊοΈ
06.06.2025 11:30 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0At least if it passes it will be an easy ban to implement.
06.06.2025 06:41 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0A few general nuggets from the Astrostatistics summer school I keep hearing over and over again (and which I firmly agree with)..... π§΅
05.06.2025 19:50 β π 26 π 7 π¬ 2 π 2I have one coffee a day. One. But if I miss that single coffee I get a headache by 3pm. I can stop anytime I wantβ¦
05.06.2025 14:30 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0