UK Government review on sex and gender slammed by professionals for wrongly portraying trans identities
Researchers have warned that the UK Government’s review on sex and gender risks harming studies relating to trans identities.
Wasn't necessarily expecting to get our research covered in Attitude Mag but I'm so glad @attitudemag.bsky.social has:
"We are calling upon researchers across the UK to reject the recommendations of the Sullivan Review," says Dr Jay Todd @jaytoddgla.bsky.social"
www.attitude.co.uk/news/uk-gove...
03.02.2026 14:29 — 👍 29 🔁 9 💬 0 📌 1
In selecting Sullivan, the commissioners chose an advisory group member of Sex Matters, which understands sex as binary, ‘real, immutable and important’ (what it calls ‘objective reality’) and claims, in contrast, ‘gender identity’ as a determination of whether ‘someone is male or female (or both or neither)’ is merely a ‘strongly held and erroneous personal feeling’ (Sex Matters 2024). Prior to selection, Sullivan had made clear she disagreed with research not conceptualising sex as binary and immutable (e.g., Sullivan 2020). While SR1 does not use the phrase ‘gender critical’ to describe its framework, it is allied—through its lead author, terminologies and recommendations—with those self-identifying as ‘gender critical’ feminists. It includes, for example, terms such as ‘adult human female’ (SR1, 11, 43) which some scholars have recognised as an ‘anti-transgender dogwhistle’ (Duffy 2025). ‘Gender critical’ feminism has been analysed by other feminist and queer scholars as part of a broader anti-gender movement (Butler 2025), gender conservatism (S. Ahmed 2021) and a manifestation of ‘postfascist feminism’ (Bassi and LaFleur 2022).2 These scholars have demonstrated that this movement's arguments are, as in Bassi and LaFleur's (2022, 317) words, ‘genealogically coherent with multiple conservative moral panics and resilient fascist tropes’. Meanwhile, the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention (2025a, n.p.) has stated that ‘the beliefs held by the gender critical movement overlap significantly with those held by various authoritarian governments and fascist political parties the world over’.
Many university researchers (& many social scientists) have no idea that the 'Sullivan Review' (named after its lead author, sociologist Sullivan) exists nor of its potential potency.
@jaytoddgla.bsky.social and I wanted to set the Review in context
rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...
03.02.2026 17:38 — 👍 13 🔁 8 💬 0 📌 1
Trans research ‘at risk’ if data collection guidance adopted
Response to Sullivan Review argues recommendations could hit quality of findings and impinge on academic freedom
Published on February 3, 2026
Last updated February 3, 2026
Patrick Jack
Twitter: @paddywjack
The recommendations of a review into how sex and gender data is collected could damage the quality of public research and is part of wider efforts to erase trans people from statistics, a new paper has argued.
I never post a link to the THE but the THE has covered Jay Todd's @jaytoddgla.bsky.social and my paper with the headline, 'Trans research "at risk" if data collection guidance adopted'
rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...
03.02.2026 09:48 — 👍 25 🔁 4 💬 0 📌 0
Feels a bit weird to promote a review of my own book... but the book is not just mine, and contributors deserve to get their work noticed! Link in first comment.
02.02.2026 12:32 — 👍 2 🔁 1 💬 1 📌 0
We recommend another seminar organised by Franek
02.02.2026 10:27 — 👍 1 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0
YouTube video by ONE Media Coverage
DREAMS Trailer (2025) The Oslo Trilogy
youtube.com/watch?v=y7aK... beautifully written and portrayed. A true gem 💫
31.01.2026 09:07 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Depressing from Philip Augar in the FT on the massive shift in burden from state to student. Aside from his ultimately economistic reduction of value, it’s surely the very definition of the learning experience that you can’t know what it should be in advance. It saps education of critical challenge.
30.01.2026 08:06 — 👍 5 🔁 2 💬 0 📌 1
For the Palestinian people, psychic life is just as much a site of struggle for liberation as social life. Palestinians are persistently refused psychological amplitude, characteristics easily granted to those who are never worried they might fall out of what is constituted as the category of the human. Abdaljawad Omar’s writings in English published since October 7, 2023 (as well as writings by other Palestinians, other Arabs, and those of Palestinian descent) offer means of understanding material resistance in relation to the terrain of the psyche. Omar offers distinctive accounts of mourning, loss, and ruins, as well as of how settler colonialism reorganizes experiences of time and relations between past, present, and future. The article reads Omar’s writings against other accounts of mourning and of psychic phenomena that are indebted to psychoanalysis. Omar’s analyses of Palestinians’ resistance to unfreedom and annihilation open up other ways of understanding the psychic vicissitudes of those who suffer, grieve, and struggle to exit a colonial condition characterized by the colonizer’s repeated attempts to break psychic worlds as well as erase bodily life. Understandings of psychic life that do justice to how Palestine is redrawing the world are central to the work of ‘cracking history open’.
I wrote on psychic life and Palestinian resistance
– to ensure more people read Abdaljawad Omar @hamayel.bsky.social.
www.cambridge.org/core/journal...
28.01.2026 07:31 — 👍 37 🔁 17 💬 1 📌 1
Lo ascoltero se il tardo capitalismo non mi asfalta prima.
27.01.2026 10:48 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
😍 mi hai sbloccato un lacrimevole ricordo. Well done
27.01.2026 10:15 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Opinion | The Age of Interdisciplinary Slop
The corporate jargon of change masks the decimation of intellectual life.
Jonathan Kramnick continues his long critique of interdisciplinarity, now arguing that while its jargon remains, it is with changed “affect & ambition”: “Today the jargon lingers on in a kind of zombie state: animated, repetitive, & oddly untethered from belief” www.chronicle.com/article/the-...
27.01.2026 08:37 — 👍 2 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0
Dennett’s powerful ideas
Published in Philosophical Psychology (Ahead of Print, 2026)
With this brief editorial, I present our special issue on Dennett's Powerful Ideas, due out very soon in @journalphp.bsky.social. I'm very pleased with the quality and variety of contributions we received! doi.org/10.1080/0951... #philsky #philpsy
26.01.2026 10:32 — 👍 37 🔁 13 💬 0 📌 1
Programme
Programme
Des Fitzgerald @desfitzgerald.bsky.social & I are convening open panels at EASST (Sept) on 'STS & biology revisited: biosociality, interdisciplinarity & the biosociences, in an age of increasingly biological fascism'. Please consider submitting, &/or circulate to colleagues easst.net/conference/e...
26.01.2026 12:36 — 👍 9 🔁 10 💬 0 📌 0
Programme of the day
History of the museum
Se siete a Milano il 5 feb potete partecipare a un evento storico: gli Stati Generali del Museo della Filosofia museodellafilosofia.unimi.it/gli-stati-ge... Progetti su diritti per gli animali, guerra e pace, intelligenza artificiale, fake news e molto altro… #philsky #filosofiapertutti
25.01.2026 20:37 — 👍 3 🔁 2 💬 0 📌 0
Iran in Revolt | Kayhan Valadbaygi
Deep political-economic transformations are causing recurrent waves of unrest, with no long-term solution in sight.
📣 My new article on Iran’s latest unrest for @phenomenalworld.bsky.social
www.phenomenalworld.org/analysis/ira...
Iran has witnessed another wave of unrest beginning on 28 December—the fourth major uprising since 2017. (1/5)
22.01.2026 13:38 — 👍 23 🔁 16 💬 1 📌 2
YouTube video by The Philosopher
The Philosopher & The News: Has Trump Proved Realists Right? Alexis Papazoglou with Linda Kinstler
ICYMI: "Has Trump Proved Realists Right?"
Linda Kinstler talks with Alexis Papazoglou about the origins of realism, the Monroe Doctrine, applied realism and international law, legal legitimacy, and if Trump's strategy is realist or Machtpolitik.
#Philosophy #Politics
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAIP...
25.01.2026 17:33 — 👍 4 🔁 3 💬 0 📌 0
Editors' Picks: Reads of 2025
Special edition newsletter today!
The team at The Philosopher picked our favourite books that we read in 2025! We'd love to hear your favourites of the year as well!
See the full write-up at our substack or scroll down for an in-brief version. 1/12 🧵
#Philosophy #Booksky
thephilosopher1923.substack.com/p/editors-pi...
22.01.2026 16:26 — 👍 7 🔁 3 💬 2 📌 1
Highly recommend — and it takes up many of the analytical frameworks and conjunctural analyses elaborated by @eskandarsadeghi.bsky.social in @thedigradio.bsky.social’s 5 part history of modern Iran from 2022 thedigradio.com/History%20of...
23.01.2026 07:31 — 👍 19 🔁 6 💬 0 📌 0
A screenshot of the first page of the article from the journal Teaching in Higher Education: Critical Perspectives titled: From debate to dialogue: teaching contested canons through dialogic literary argumentation by Farid Mohammadi. The screenshot includes the abstract of the article (available via the link).
A screenshot of the cover of the journal Teaching in Higher Education: Critical Perspectives. The cover is red with a black band on the edge.
New publication alert! 🚨
From debate to dialogue: teaching contested canons through dialogic literary argumentation
Points of Departure paper by Farid Mohammadi
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10....
#HigherEducation #DialogicEducation
21.01.2026 08:14 — 👍 3 🔁 3 💬 0 📌 0
❗ PESGB Annual Conference 2026. ❗
The conference will take place from Friday 27 March to Sunday 29 March 2026 at New College, University of Oxford, bringing together scholars, researchers, and practitioners in the field of philosophy of education.
👉 Register here:
lnkd.in/eQvvZ8gJ
20.01.2026 12:27 — 👍 2 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0
another dawn, another morning waking up to check if America has annexed a European territory, another day trying to remember that politics is not everything in life but also that everyone that condones and normalizes this will belong to a black list for a very, very long time.
20.01.2026 07:38 — 👍 43 🔁 7 💬 0 📌 0
Oh. This.
19.01.2026 18:46 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
New article - long in the making, but so worth waiting! Link in first comment.
16.01.2026 14:19 — 👍 1 🔁 1 💬 1 📌 0
Four Scholars Agree, Disagree, and Agree to Disagree on Viewpoint Diversity
Is the movement to increase intellectual pluralism a genuine reform effort or a partisan power grab?
Ok, one participant is Michael Clune and I couldn’t help myself clicking. I found it a deeply depressing exchange but was fascinated by how the Johns Hopkins English department (3 participants have been/are in that dept) gets circulated/invoked across conversation www.chronicle.com/article/four...
17.01.2026 09:48 — 👍 4 🔁 2 💬 3 📌 1
Please circulate. Our deadline for our ECR Prize at @histhum.bsky.social is approaching (30 January 2026)
13.01.2026 17:15 — 👍 10 🔁 18 💬 1 📌 0
Ex Machina: Film screening and panel discussion - University of Birmingham
Event details
In Birmingham? Interested in human-robot relations? Join us for a film screening and philosophical discussion this March! www.birmingham.ac.uk/events/ex-ma... #philsky #philosophymatters #philosophyforeveryone
12.01.2026 02:16 — 👍 11 🔁 4 💬 1 📌 1
Research Fellow at the International Institute of Social History (IISH).
Fighting every day to deliver a city that working New Yorkers can actually afford. Mayor of New York City.
Poet—latest book: "Slow Now with Clear Skies." Writer. Herbalist—Green Witch. Therapist. Systemic or Family Constellation. Health Artist. #WOMPO https://www.julenetrippweaver.com
(he/him) Belfast/Coleraine poet. Black Eyed Peace, is available as free eBook from Wordpress, inc. the Pushcart nominated Hunting for the Aurora. MA student at MMU - davidatkinsonpoet.wordpress.com
Lecturer in the Heritage of the Middle East at the University of Leicester. Researching ancient Mesopotamia. Playwright, poet, and Babylonian liver diviner.
https://www.selenawisnom.com
https://leicester.academia.edu/SelenaWisnom
Late Roman & Early Medieval History & Archaeology @dependencybonn.de,
Exploring what happens when empires die.
Book available at http://t.ly/LfaV
https://jmharland.hcommons.org/publications
I teach philosophy part time, and I work full time as a creative producer in NYC.
PhD Student at University of Hamburg (@uni-hamburg.de)
| DHPRL(@dhprlab.bsky.social)
Informationen zu allen Bildungsthemen für Eltern, Studierende, Schüler*innen, Lehrer*innen, Erzieher*innen , Dozent*innen, (Bildungs-)Wissenschaftler*innen, Journalist*innen, Pädagogen und Pädagoginnen, Sozialarbeiter*innen, Bildungspolitiker*innen
Associate Professor of Philosophy at Florida Gulf Coast University | Research on Hegel, Skepticism, and Critical Theory
https://mileshentrup.wixsite.com/miles-hentrup
https://philpeople.org/profiles/miles-hentrup
Unironic believer in the Absolute. Marx in my heart; Hegel in my head.
True Materialism: Hegelian Marxism and the Modernist Struggle for Freedom (Stanford UP).
Junior Fellow | Harvard Society of Fellows.
Dog Dad
Video Producer
Tomb Raider Podcaster
London-based Welshman
https://youtube.com/raidercast
🏴👾🐾🏳️🌈
🚫Anti Gen-AI
Astrophysicist, science writer for @iflscience.com, geek, immigrant, and also The Astroholic. Chair of @prideinstem.bsky.social | He/him | opinions are my own
International Criminal Law Professor @LaStatale
of Milan + SeniorLegal Counsel on International Crimes Accountability @ECCHRBerlin
The Scholarly Communication Research Group is a team interested in crossing disciplinary boundaries. #ScienceOfScience #HigherEd #STS
https://sc.amu.edu.pl/
Teaching in Higher Education is an international, peer-reviewed journal (Taylor & Francis) focusing on critical higher education studies.
An interdisciplinary network at the University of Birmingham for researchers working on phenomenology and mental health
https://birminghamphenomenalnetwork.blogspot.com/
Professor of Sociology. Psychoanalyst. Researcher in Critical Theory.
Book: "Immaterial Labor and Cultural Production"(2023):
https://www.cambridgescholars.com/product/978-1-5275-9397-8
https://silviocamargo.academia.edu/
A four-year project that aims to widen and diversify the pool of confident, trained supervisors able to support an inclusive culture and the next generation of researchers.