Some have questioned the value of such public statements in terms of deterrence, naming & shaming. While it (rhetorically) demonstrates unity and determination, current tensions within the alliance undermine this stance with regard to the possibility of actual responses described in the statement.
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
โ
Underlining strategic ambiguity - Art. 5 applicability to campaigns & range of response โ[โฆ] determined to employ the full range of capabilities in order to deter, defend against and counter the full spectrum of cyber threats.ย We will respond to these at a time and in a manner of our choosing.โ
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
โ
Similar language as used in Strategic Concept & Summit declarations: โWe remain united in our determination to counter, constrain, and contest Russian malicious cyber activities [โฆ].โ
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
๐บ๐ฆ โRussiaโs actions will not deter Alliesโ support to Ukraine, including cyber assistance through the Tallinn Mechanism and IT capability coalition. We will continue to use the lessons learned from the war against Ukraine in countering Russian malicious cyber activity.โ
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
๐บ๐ฆ Also notice how strong this language is on continued support for Ukraine. ๐บ๐ธ Maybe a hint that working relations with the U.S. Delegation are quite stable despite Trump (as suspected by many & has been the case under Trump 1.0). However, this runs contrary to reports of DoD practice under Hegseth
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
๐ท๐บContinued clarity on the threat: โ[โฆ] illustrate the extent to which cyber and wider hybrid threats have become important tools in Russiaโs ongoing campaign to destabilise NATO Allies and in Russiaโs brutal and unprovoked war of aggression against Ukraine.โ
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
The Statement is likely a sign that attacks against allies are more severe than publicly known, hence the timing & move. The connection to one of the few other statements of this kind (malicious Russian cyber activities against GER/CZ) adds more weight to the statement and emphasizes the prior move.
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
The nod to attacks against other allies, incl. Romania is interesting as it differs from the language used above. Likely allies wanting to avoid confronting language. Itโs widely known & recognized that all allies are subject to such attacks - choosing to highlight it still makes for a stronger case
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
๐ค Standing in solidarity & recognizing attributions by individual allies (here EST, FR, UK, US as NATOs leading cyber nations) has become the compromise, alternative to a joint NATO attribution in a narrow sense. Getting 32 allies to agree to such a move is not easy in the current environment.
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
www.nato.int/cps/en/natoh... ๐จ Significant statement (18.7.25) NATO has only published such a statement (outside summits) exclusively focusing on condemning malicious cyber activities a handful of times. Russia has been named as a malicious actor in cyberspace before but the tone is more decisive โฌ๏ธ
22.07.2025 06:30 โ ๐ 1 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 0
Zelensky arrives at NATO summit in The Hague as Netherlands pledges new aid
Welcoming Zelensky at the Catshuis official residence, Schoof presented a new military aid package for Ukraine, including 100 drone radar systems, front-line vehicles for evacuating the wounded, and 8...
โกZelensky arrives at NATO summit in The Hague as Netherlands pledges new aid.
"Let me be clear: Ukraine is part of the family that we call the Euro-Atlantic family," Dutch Prime Minister Dick Schoof told Zelensky in front of reporters.
24.06.2025 11:20 โ ๐ 372 ๐ 73 ๐ฌ 6 ๐ 4
#NATO #5ProzentZiel ist 1) signaling an USA (burden-sharing) und Russland (abschrecken). 2) 2% wurden 2014 beschlossen, die meisten Staaten haben es erst nach RU Angriff auf UA erfรผllt. 3) Mil. nutzbare Infrastruktur ist Auslegungssache (Bahn, Hรคfen etc 4) NATO hat keine Instrumente zu sanktionieren
23.06.2025 05:21 โ ๐ 0 ๐ 0 ๐ฌ 0 ๐ 0
Mรผtzenich und Stegner, die Ewiggestrigen der deutschen Sicherheits- und Auรenpolitiker. Ihr โManifestโ ist ein realitรคtsverweigerndes Pamphlet voller fataler Fehleinschรคtzungen. Wie sehr kann man eigentlich รผbersehen, was nicht erst seit รผber einem Jahrzehnt bereits in Europa passiert?
11.06.2025 09:11 โ ๐ 348 ๐ 58 ๐ฌ 22 ๐ 1
Also it violates both the NATO Articles of Agreement and the UN Charter, both of which are treaties ratified by the Senate & therefore also part of US law.
bsky.app/profile/mcop...
04.05.2025 15:41 โ ๐ 60 ๐ 13 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
Q: "Would you rule out military force to take Canada?"
Trump: "I think we're not going to ever get to that point. Something could happen with Greenland, I'll be honest."
Q: "You are not ruling out military force to take Greenland?"
Trump: "I don't rule it out."
04.05.2025 15:45 โ ๐ 801 ๐ 314 ๐ฌ 136 ๐ 164
Ende August soll der Entwurf einer neuen Nationalen Sicherheitsstrategie der #USA vorliegen; gestaltet von Elbridge Colby. Der entwickelte schon Trumps NSS von 2018. Colby vertritt wie kein anderer eine radikale Fokussierung der US-Streitkrรคfte auf China/Asien, weg von Europa.
03.05.2025 17:28 โ ๐ 7 ๐ 4 ๐ฌ 3 ๐ 0
What the First 100 Days Taught Us About Resisting Trump
For starters, itโs better to push back than to appease.
FOR ANYONE WHO WANTS to oppose the Trump administration...there is a strategy worth pursuing, one familiar to underdogs the world over: Push the aggressor beyond their limits.
My latest, on Columbia, Harvard, immigration, Abrego Garcia, the Supreme Court, and why appeasing fascists does not work.
01.05.2025 14:52 โ ๐ 351 ๐ 123 ๐ฌ 7 ๐ 20
CBS reports NSA Mike Waltz & NSC's Alex Wong are leaving. This is bad news for European alliesโmany have been concerned that Waltz's firing would expand influence of MAGA types. The loss of Wong, who was subject to racist conspiracy theories by Laura Loomer, will also concern China hawks.
01.05.2025 14:55 โ ๐ 185 ๐ 51 ๐ฌ 11 ๐ 6
Here is a brief breakdown of the differences between the US and Ukrainian/European (UA/E.) proposals for ending Russia's war against Ukraine.
The UA/European proposal is a response to the US one-pager that emerged from Wittkoff's trip to Moscow last week.
26.04.2025 09:02 โ ๐ 119 ๐ 44 ๐ฌ 4 ๐ 6
but does he have the cards
23.04.2025 16:43 โ ๐ 36 ๐ 6 ๐ฌ 5 ๐ 0
Russia seizing thousands of homes in occupied Mariupol - BBC News
To save their homes, Ukrainians face a dangerous return through Russia, and pressure to take a Russian passport.
Russia seizing thousands of homes in occupied Mariupol:
"The confiscations appear to be part of a larger scheme to โRussifyโ the occupied coastal city, which includes the construction of new military facilities and renaming streets to Moscow-approved titles."
- BBC Verify
19.04.2025 09:14 โ ๐ 24 ๐ 11 ๐ฌ 1 ๐ 1
Remember Fiona Hill? Sheโs now sounding the alarm again: โWeโre definitely on a path toward full-on state repression. Thereโs no question about it. Iโve thought about this for an extraordinarily long time.โ When Fiona speaks, we should all listen.
13.04.2025 17:10 โ ๐ 10702 ๐ 4092 ๐ฌ 204 ๐ 169
Reuters: Chinese military officers have been touring close to Russia's frontlines with Beijing's approval to draw lessons and tactics from the war. t.me/c/1817343196...
12.04.2025 09:57 โ ๐ 326 ๐ 74 ๐ฌ 18 ๐ 10
To join or not to join? Norway is edging closer to the EU
Trumpโs trade war has brought Norway even closer to the EU and increased the urgency for it to make a decision about membership.
With Trumpโs trade war threatening to leave Norway in the crossfire of US-EU sanctions, Norway is facing a similar moment of truth about EU membership as Finland and Sweden did with regard to NATO 3 years earlier.
I argue that itโs time to make it official - for a strong Norden in the EU
11.04.2025 15:46 โ ๐ 523 ๐ 119 ๐ฌ 26 ๐ 24
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius and British Secretary of State for Defence John Healey standing next to each other.
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius and British Secretary of State for Defence John Healey will co-host a meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group #UDCG at the NATO HQ in Brussels today.
โน๏ธ Find the programme here: nato.int/cps/en/natoh...
11.04.2025 04:59 โ ๐ 50 ๐ 6 ๐ฌ 2 ๐ 1
Head of Activation at Euronews. Follower of global events, history buff, drummer.
Brussels-based but often on the move ๐๐ปโโ๏ธ
Husband of C, Dad of J & L, CEO/Editor-The DSR Network, Host-Deep State Radio, Siliconsciousness, other pods, Columnist-The Daily Beast, author of many books, also see my "Need to Know" Substack (djrothkopf.substack.com)
security & investigations editor at @WIRED.com, send tips and/or dog pics
Signal: couts.01
Senior adviser (Europe), IISS,
Special adviser, Fondation pour la Recherche Stratรฉgique
Exploring the American idea through ambitious, essential reporting and storytelling. Of no party or clique since 1857. http://theatlantic.com
Shooting the messenger will not solve the problem
Redakteur Investigativ und Daten | Investigative Reporter @DIEZEIT
PGP: 5356 E18D 028D 2A17 D95C 00A9 3816 1797 D451 8B42
Threema: PHT4ZBYM
@kaibiermann@mastodon.online
UN Director at Crisis Group.
Nobody knows politics and policy like we do.
Former CIA clandestine service. Spycraft Entertainment, Atlantic Council, NAFO. Host of Mission implausible podcast. Friend of dogs everywhere.
With more than 300 employees at two locations - Mannheim and Cologne - GESIS provides essential and internationally relevant research-based services for the social sciences.
https://www.gesis.org
U.S. Senator from Connecticut.
A journal on German & European foreign affairs, formerly BerlinPolicy, published by the German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP), @dgap.org | English edition of @internationalepolitik.de | Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ipquarterly/
CeMAS bรผndelt interdisziplinรคre Expertise zu Verschwรถrungsideologien, Desinformation, Antisemitismus & Rechtsextremismus.
Impressum: https://cemas.io/impressum/
Chief economist @ Centre for European Reform. Eurozone macroeconomic policies | Role of ๐ฉ๐ช ๐ณ๐ฑ in EU. Formerly @ECB, @IMF, @Worldbank.
Recovering Lawyer. President, @chkbal.bsky.social. Host of the "George Conway Explains It All to Sarah Longwell" podcast on @thebulwark.com.
Dad, husband, President, citizen. barackobama.com
Co-Founder Momentum Training Institute, IfNotNow, More Perfect Union. Formerly Warren, Justice Democrats, etc.
Writer for WIRED. Author of SANDWORM. New book, TRACERS IN THE DARK: The Global Hunt for the Crime Lords of Cryptocurrency, out now. agreenberg@wired.com. Andy.01 on Signal.
International Relations prof at U. Illinois. Editor of Arc Digital. Author โDrones and Terrorism.โ Politics, national security, and occasional nerdery.