Balkinization: The Art of Replacing the Law with the Deal
A group blog on constitutional law, theory, and politics
I thought I'd put the administration's proposed "compact" with universities in context, so I wrote the blog post below.
It's especially for journalists covering this story!
Many details about how the compact itself works and why the administration has retreated to this strategy.
04.10.2025 22:34 β π 539 π 264 π¬ 12 π 57
Some problems have simple solutions. This new βCompact for Academic Excellence in Higher Educationβ is one. The answer is simply saying no.
Simple does not mean easy. But Brown, Dartmouth, MIT, Vanderbilt, Univ of AZ, UPenn, USC, UT Austin & UVA must understand what theyβll lose if they sign on.
02.10.2025 06:14 β π 494 π 190 π¬ 2 π 18
Applying to US Graduate School in Ecology, Evolution, and Related Fields
Webpage on the hidden curriculum of applying to ecology and evolution grad programs in the US (a lot of the info applies to other fields too, but perhaps less well): applyingtoeeb.info
#AcademicSky π§ͺ
02.10.2025 12:28 β π 50 π 36 π¬ 3 π 0
Happy Birthday, Dan!! πππ (that's what you were asking for, right?)
02.10.2025 18:35 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0
The GRFP announcement from NSF cuts out an entire cohort of 2nd year students from consideration, without warning. This is so deeply unfair that it warrants a formal protest from the scientific community. If someone wants to work with me to craft an open letter and solicit signatures, LMK.
26.09.2025 17:10 β π 168 π 86 π¬ 9 π 8
There is so much in the news cycle these days that the complete dismantling of the Forest Service -- so *our* forests can be auctioned off to Big TImber -- is unfortunately getting little air play. But if this happens, US landscapes may be almost unrecognizable in a decade, and never coming back. π
26.09.2025 01:53 β π 267 π 223 π¬ 6 π 2
Flea? Tick? Insect of some sort?
23.09.2025 02:39 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0
Illustration of the profile of a Crested Jayshrike, a warm brown songbird with a white collar, hooked black beak, and tall feathery crest. It is fringed in bright white light, with a blurry background of tropical greenery.
For @cassalalia.bsky.social, a Crested Jayshrike! Thanks so much for the #Waymakers donation!
To donate and request a bird: act.theyoungcenter.org/a/birdsbeyon... . Include your bsky name if you want a ping!
Every dollar helps support unaccompanied immigrant kids in the US!
π¨πͺΆ #SciArt #BirdArt
27.08.2025 00:37 β π 104 π 25 π¬ 1 π 0
What the Bloom After L.A.βs Wildfires Reveals About Our Ecological Future
A bunch of wonderful scientists are working to study how the LA fires in January impacted our local nature. We had a great time working with @brookejarvis.bsky.social and @nytimes.com on this beautiful article.
feat. @kendallcalhoun.bsky.social @ltkelly.bsky.social et al.
26.08.2025 19:52 β π 27 π 9 π¬ 1 π 0
Since at least the 1990s, the identity-based Harvard student group was labeled with that ordering. Since the ordering of letters is, at best, arbitrary, I think no one decided it was worth changing, and became standard on campus for related topics.
25.08.2025 20:59 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0
As one can imagine, I have some thoughts. Hereβs a thread no one asked for:
1. SCIENCE IN THE US IS POLITICAL. No matter how much you want to ignore that fact, it is supported by taxpayer dollars and is therefore, political by nature.
2. BUT it has had bipartisan support for decades, whichβ¦
23.08.2025 16:15 β π 600 π 253 π¬ 17 π 29
The Roadless Rule Explained: How the Last Unbroken Forests Could Be Lost Forever
For 25 years it has protected 59 million acres of wild forest. The latest repeal puts them all at risk.
"The Roadless Rule Explained: How the Last Unbroken Forests Could Be Lost Forever. For 25 years it has protected 59 million acres of wild forest. The latest repeal puts them all at risk." π morethanjustparks.substack.com/p/the-roadle...
19.08.2025 18:45 β π 23 π 14 π¬ 1 π 1
Are you planning on attending the @amornith.bsky.social (American Ornithological Society) #AOS25 meeting in St. Louis this year?
I'm making a Starter Pack of attendees so we can easily follow each other. Attending the meeting and want on the list? Comment here or DM me! go.bsky.app/3dybD1a
04.08.2025 22:10 β π 30 π 16 π¬ 11 π 1
NEW: A federal judge has demanded NSF explain in court how the UCLA grant suspensions are not in violation of her June order that restored grants to UC scientists
05.08.2025 16:15 β π 245 π 82 π¬ 6 π 6
π
31.07.2025 19:47 β π 13 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0
Birds are dinosaurs who shrugged off a couple apocalypses. Some eat bone marrow. Some drink nectar. They outswim fish in the sea. They smile politely at gravityβs demands. β¬
βͺI am grateful to see them. I am grateful to feed them. I am grateful to know them.β¬
30.07.2025 16:02 β π 1392 π 367 π¬ 27 π 21
It's incredibly distressing, because - my lab needs funding but look, realistically, I'll be okay - but the entire generation of people who were going to move into this research space are just completely orphaned. There's no way to start a lab on this now. Funders need to pivot back to funding.
29.07.2025 18:34 β π 32 π 5 π¬ 1 π 1
One thing very few people know, even in the climate-health research space, is that - in addition to NIH / NSF / NASA / EPA blocking any new research on climate change and health - all the philanthropies have decided to take NGO-shaped roles rather than fund research, and so they aren't stepping in.
29.07.2025 18:33 β π 52 π 21 π¬ 1 π 1
I normally think about #fire from an ecological perspective, so really enjoyed thinking about the role of fire in the evolutionary past and future with @ltkelly.bsky.social. Take a look, it's a short read!
26.07.2025 01:40 β π 15 π 7 π¬ 0 π 0
It is difficult to describe just how disastrous it would be if just-released NOAA budget proposal (or even large portions) were to be enacted: It would involve a wholesale dismantling (decimation, really) of entities relevant to weather, climate, & ocean research & prediction.
01.07.2025 17:18 β π 344 π 154 π¬ 9 π 8
Oh you've never heard of piculets before? The mini woodpeckers? Well here ya go- have a Rufous Piculet. Your life is now that much cuter. You're welcome.
π· Ayuwat Jearwattanakanok, eBird
06.06.2025 18:38 β π 156 π 12 π¬ 5 π 2
Career planning in an era of scientific disinvestment
Know not just the destination and the route, but all the other features on the map
In a time when support for junior scientists is disappearing, how can you plan for a career in STEM? I think it starts by thinking of science as a big map with many routes and destinations, instead of a pipeline. π§ͺ
scienceforeveryone.science/p/career-pla...
04.06.2025 21:10 β π 93 π 37 π¬ 3 π 5
Itβs destroying our future.
04.06.2025 03:32 β π 116 π 28 π¬ 4 π 2
screenshot from the NSF budget request to congress showing that the number of people involved in NSF activities will drop from 330,100 to 90,000.
The bottom line with the proposed cuts to NSF is to cut the number of working scientists and disappear opportunities to train new scientists.
This is a PROPOSED budget to Congress. Call your reps.
31.05.2025 03:46 β π 281 π 127 π¬ 4 π 6
Goodbye REUs, goodbye GRFPs, goodbye CAREERs (which ironically I just finished writing today). This is the end of the road for all early-career scientists. If you aren't enraged you aren't paying attention.
31.05.2025 06:01 β π 158 π 82 π¬ 6 π 3
Graphs showing 25 years of budgets for the National Institute of Health, NASA, and the NSF. In all cases, the proposed budget for next year is far, far below any year of the previous quarter century.
There are 2 previous historical cases of countries destroying their science and universities, crippling them for decades: Lysenkoism in the USSR and Nazi Germany. The Trump administration will be the 3rd.
It's not just budgets but research, institutions, expertise, and training the next generation.
31.05.2025 04:43 β π 15319 π 7927 π¬ 456 π 535
In case you couldn't bear to read all the way to the end (understandable), here is the proposed picture for the BIO Directorate.
30.05.2025 23:00 β π 31 π 40 π¬ 2 π 14
Law prof @ UCLA. I study equality and oligarchy.
Most recent book @ https://anti-oligarchy.com
Studying why and how behavior evolves, from mosquitoes to mole-rats | Leon Levy Scholar @Columbia working with Ishmail Abdus-Saboor | PhD @Princeton with Lindy McBride | ιΊ»εΈ/ζ±ε€§ alum π―π΅ | yukihaba.github.io
Ecologist with broad interests studying gulls, pathogens, and microbiomes. Love and teach R. Dangerously close to becoming microbiologist. Gulls Eating Stuff citizen science project. https://alicerisely.weebly.com/
contributing writer for The New York Times Magazine, writer for The New Yorker, Wired, and elsewhere, slowly writing a book
Tennessean on the Puget Sound, a pal and a confidant
https://brookejarvis.net
Mobilizing the fight for science and democracy, because Science is for everyone π§ͺπ
The hub for science activism!
Learn more β¬οΈ
http://linktr.ee/standupforscience
Research scientist | public land owner | facial hair enthusiast. Science interests: #Wildfire #Forests #GlobalChange
Assistant Professor @UMassAmherst. Birds + physiology + ecology + evolution. (she/her)
Conservation scientist & naturalist | Asst. Professor @ UGA
Writer @ Gulo in Nature |π¦#ornithologyπ§#freshwater | He/Him
Ornithology @ KU Biodiversity Institute | PhD Student with Dr. Town Peterson | she/her
PhD candidate @ University of Michigan EEB | macroecology, seasonal migration, ornithology, biogeography | He/him
PhD candidate at @kentstate β’ Evolutionary biology π§¬β’ Ecology β’Evidence based conservation β’high altitude adaptation β’Birds β’Multi-omics β’ poetry
Rose Postdoctoral Fellow @cornellbirds | avian quantitative ecologist | sci-commποΈ| foodie π§ | she/they | personal account; opinions my own β¨
π» Statistical ecologist at the Swiss Ornithological Institute
π¦
π¦ Bayesian population models applied to raptors
Del Pallars.
Biologist, molecular ecologistπ§βπ¬ , eDNA nerd π§¬, birder π¦, coin collector πͺ, insect enjoyer π, Brazilian mineiro, and more.
Currently a Postdoc in the Kelly Lab at UW.
Ornithology, evolution, ecology. Assistant Professor and Curator of Birds at Louisiana State University. I also like rugby, house music, hip-hop, food, baking, and art. he/him/Γ©l
@rainygay1 on Twitter. Gay cat day and just living my Seattle thot life
United Academics Local 6741 is an AAUP & AFT⬠local, composed of all non-collectively bargaining AAUP chapter members and at-large members of AAUP. Visit us at https://local6741.org/ & become a member at https://www.aaup.org/membership/join
Zoologist & ecologist
Obsessed with herps, birds, and PNG
Doing ecological modelling for a living and still shocked by that
π³οΈβππ¨π¦π§ Conservation, curator in charge of birbs, island hopper, climber, connoisseur of fine teas, biscuit fiend, v left, queer af, ErdΕsβBacon = 8, he/him.
π Tring & Milton Keynes, UK
https://linktr.ee/albnd
Paleontologist PhD & Medical Scribe
#BirdGlamour, #NameThatTrack, #ichnology, bird & dino tracks.
Fellow of Royal Canadian Geographical Society.
She/Her.
Views mine.
LOTS of Ash pics!