B. No Order of Removal Exists for Abrego Garcia
No such order of removal exists for Abrego Garcia. When Abrego Garcia was first
wrongly expelled to El Salvador, the Court struggled to understand the legal authority for even
seizing him in the first place. At the first hearing in Abrego I, the Court inquired of Respondents’
counsel:
The Court: I want to ask, though, the very specific question, if there is a final order of removal, what . . . document got this process started? There is no warrant for his arrest by an order of removal. There is no statement of probable cause. There’s no charge. There’s no report that says that anyone saw Mr. Abrego Garcia doing anything illegal or criminal. So what is the actual document that gave these officers the authority to start this process?
Counsel: That is not in the record, and the government has not put
that into the record. And that’s the best I can do.
Abrego I, ECF No. 33 at 21:11–22.
The Court continued to press counsel about the existence of a removal order and was told plainly that none can be found:
The Court: Okay. So if there’s a Title 8 removal order, there would be an order of removal that’s being executed, and we don’t have one for Mr. Abrego Garcia, right? . . . Do you have that order? . . . Is it in the record? Counsel: I do not have that order. It is not in the record. Id. at 23:7–24:4. Since that time, Respondents have never produced an order of removal despite Abrego Garcia hinging much of his jurisdictional and legal arguments on its non-existence. ECF No. 1 ¶¶ 68–69; ECF No. 32 at 10, 15–17, 27; ECF No. 87 at 11–12. Indeed, Respondents twice sponsored the testimony of ICE officials whose job it is to effectuate removal orders, and who candidly admitted to having never seen one for Abrego Garcia. See ECF No. 107 at 30:16–22 (testimony of Cantú) (“Q: Based upon your many years of experience you described to us, you know what a final order of removal looks like, right, sir? Cantú: I do. Q: And have you seen a final order of removal in regard to Mr. Abrego Garcia? Cantú: I have not.”). See also Abrego I, ECF No. 234 at 46:6–12 (testimony of interim Assistant Director for ICE Removal Operations, Thomas Giles (“Giles”)) (“Q: You have not seen the final order of removal, have you, sir? Giles: What do you mean by that? Q: I mean, you have not seen a piece of paper that represents the final order of removal vis-a-vis Mr. Abrego Garcia, correct? Giles: No, I have not.”).15 Based on this, the Court concludes that no order of removal exists.
🚨Judge Xinis finds that, incredibly, Mr. Abrego Garcia was never ordered deported in 2019. She notes that every since this saga began all the way back in March, the government has NEVER been able to produce any evidence that the immigration judge actually issued a removal order.
11.12.2025 16:13 — 👍 1785 🔁 556 💬 30 📌 80
We're like three days from the n-word
11.12.2025 01:00 — 👍 567 🔁 79 💬 33 📌 7
I was there likely much, much earlier than you were!
10.12.2025 03:45 — 👍 3 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Wow -- Russia reportedly plotted last year to plant bombs on US-bound flights (gift link) giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/...
09.12.2025 19:33 — 👍 9947 🔁 5311 💬 711 📌 591
Excellent point
09.12.2025 19:26 — 👍 5 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Absolutely. I am an English PhD who benefited from William &Mary's undergrad requirement that I take three sciences. I choose Chemistry, Cell Biology and Botany. Made me a better thinker and gave me an expanded perspective on the world as I knew it.
09.12.2025 19:25 — 👍 26 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Did you post on Blacksky?
07.12.2025 02:41 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Both?
07.12.2025 00:29 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
If I were one of the wealthiest people in human history, living in a country with ever growing wealth inequality, I might think twice about advocating ritual execution
06.12.2025 22:20 — 👍 442 🔁 108 💬 4 📌 7
Yes.
06.12.2025 21:23 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
The Nobel Prize committee should announce the World Cup winner tomorrow
06.12.2025 04:29 — 👍 38784 🔁 7534 💬 512 📌 306
All of the above?
04.12.2025 20:28 — 👍 6 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
He's got to go
03.12.2025 21:15 — 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
BREAKING: All House Democrats have signed our discharge petition to extend the ACA tax credits.
That makes 214.
We can protect health care and lower costs — if only 4 Republicans will join us.
03.12.2025 15:55 — 👍 2235 🔁 780 💬 52 📌 61
Cover of Inhabitants of the Deep: The Blueness of Blackness by Jonathan Howard. The cover features a dark blue background with a painted image of a Black figure in a sheer white garment on the right-hand side. The figure appears to be deep underwater, based on the patterns of refracted light on the figure's body. On the left-hand side is a distorted reflection of the figure, as though seen from above the water's surface.
Save 30% on #NewBook "Inhabitants of the Deep" by Jonathan Howard, which undertakes a black ecocritical study of the deep (oceans, rivers, lakes) in African American literature. #BlackStudies
buff.ly/ejHedv7
01.12.2025 19:20 — 👍 39 🔁 15 💬 1 📌 6
he's fighting for his life in this meeting
02.12.2025 17:56 — 👍 3349 🔁 473 💬 321 📌 35
02.12.2025 02:39 — 👍 6 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
For 19th C Black conservatism, Booker T. Washington, Up from Slavery or The Atlanta Exposition Address
02.12.2025 00:01 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Of course!
01.12.2025 23:58 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
This is just my opinion, but I don't think departments need to change their strategy for reading or grading student work.
Departments need a strategy for responding to harassment and attacks.
01.12.2025 20:23 — 👍 684 🔁 190 💬 5 📌 11
the primary thing that TPUSA provides to young conservatives is a blueprint for weaponizing the abject cowardice of university administrators against individual teachers and instructors, and university admins should take a long look in the mirror and think about what that says about them
30.11.2025 20:51 — 👍 4747 🔁 1206 💬 70 📌 46
With DC shooter now identified as an Afghan national not the antifa secret agent White House hoped for a good time to remember the Trump admin has gutted domestic anti-terrorism capacity and reassigned many to finding grandmothers to arrest at immigration hearings.
27.11.2025 04:06 — 👍 5553 🔁 1628 💬 44 📌 52
bsky.app/profile/melb...
27.11.2025 01:07 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
The dead Guard members could have been home in West Virginia, prepping for the holidays. Instead, they died in the cause of performative ass-hattery on behalf of a malign narcissist and his cronies.
27.11.2025 00:23 — 👍 9 🔁 4 💬 0 📌 0
It's his fault that they are dead
26.11.2025 20:54 — 👍 4 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
I wish I had such luck
26.11.2025 19:22 — 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
NEW data I've received: Just 5% of people detained by ICE since October 1 have had violent criminal convictions, 3/4 had no criminal convictions at all. Most "criminals" had immigration, traffic, and vice offenses. Not the "worst of the worst"...
24.11.2025 23:33 — 👍 1331 🔁 517 💬 27 📌 36
Wheatley was nicely used in Episode 1
24.11.2025 02:23 — 👍 2 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Editing, Writing, Teaching, Muttering, not in that order. LA and CT currently but Iowa originally. USC; Avidly; #hairstudies; with intense eagerness.
Author of There Is No Place for Us: Working and Homeless in America • essays and reporting in The New York Times, Harper's, The New Republic & elsewhere briangoldstone.net
Freelance artist: Illustration, Print Media & oil painting. Sweatshop worker. Union supporter.
SciFi/Horror nerd. Political junkie & history buff.
http://lukerussell.myportfolio.com
On a mission to save street dogs around the world. You can support here... https://www.happydoggo.com/donate
Court reporter & artist/maker. Voting Blue💙🦋🌈💙🐴 🐕🐈🐐
Immigrants make the USA a better place. Mosaics @shannonrossmosaics (insta)
Now I am become sarcasm, destroyer of worlds. Cogito ergo sumbitch ipso facto vis a vis hold deez.
Psst...I'm also Mask Wearing Amy ;-)
Person, Human Being, Individual, Homo Sapiens Sapiens
Chicagoland
Theater critic for The New Yorker, social media addict
Teapot Queen | patriciamatthew.com
Race and Regency Lab | raceandregency.org
average against the machine
Husband, dad, veteran, writer, and proud Midwesterner. 19th US Secretary of Transportation and former Mayor of South Bend.
He/Him/His #GetSomebodyElseToDoIt #Educator #LifeLongLearner #PettySavedEducated #DoctorateOnHold #KHive #🐝hive #foodie #cartoonlover #GoldenGirlsFan
Writer, husband, etc. Books: Pictures at a Revolution (2008), Five Came Back (2014), Mike Nichols: A Life (2021), Untitled gay cultural history (2026). Freelance: T, New York, etc. A long time ago: EW, Grantland, younger.
Retired Military Vet that believes in Family, Human Rights, Accountability and Love…without it, What the Hell Are We Doing Here Folks! Also Love Music, Sports & Travel. Traveled to 41 Countries & all 50 States. Oh Yeah, Fu<k the Convict & his Cult!✊🏽
Asst. Professor @ UM, Writing a book on literary culture and Black feminist sociality in the 70s and 80s. This account represents just me, not my employer.
UCLA Political Psychologist. Director of Race, Ethnicity, Politics, & Society (REPS) Lab. Newby accordionist 🪗. Arriba El Grullo, Jalisco 🇲🇽.
Distinguished Professor, CUNY Graduate Center; Director of Research, Center for Place, Culture and Politics. New book: The Story of Capital (24 February 2026). Posts from David Harvey personally are signed -DH
Small Business Owner | ΔΣΘ | Black Like That | Always Brooklyn | Music is Life!
Racial trauma researcher with deep interest in decolonizing somatic approaches to resistance, healing and resilience.