may I just please never hear about ChatGPT or LLMs ever again, is that an option
02.05.2025 00:29 β π 627 π 49 π¬ 21 π 4@cemberton.bsky.social
Historian. Knitter. Mom of a feral girl-child. Author of Beyond Redemption & To Walk About in Freedom. I post about history, education, & books. Go Bills! She/hers. www.caroleemberton.com
may I just please never hear about ChatGPT or LLMs ever again, is that an option
02.05.2025 00:29 β π 627 π 49 π¬ 21 π 4This is absolutely terrible. People constantly say that they want to support "alternatives" to policing but they absolutely DO NOT WANT TO RESOURCE THEM. EVER. Cahoots is a gold-standard for non-police community response. 30 YEARS OF PROVEN SUCCESS.
www.registerguard.com/story/news/l...
"You know, as an example, red lead was used to make cheddar... A can of coffee could be coffee, but it could be ground bone, or charred shells, or dirt." Deborah Blum on our bad food past -- and how to avoid it being our future:
buttondown.com/theswordandt...
Come present! The MHS offers great and helpful seminars. #Skystorians
29.04.2025 21:05 β π 6 π 3 π¬ 0 π 0A colleague at Stanfordβs business school used The Stanford Daily to argueβpoorlyβagainst DEI. The piece was riddled with historical errors and left one searching for fact, so I broke my public writing hiatus to respond.
I hope youβll read and share the piece.
stanforddaily.com/2025/04/22/w...
I also really appreciate that Hahn takes mass incarceration seriously as a form of "disappearance" in U.S. history. The podcast episode is well worth listening to: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/t...
23.04.2025 19:46 β π 147 π 28 π¬ 3 π 0A screenshot from ChatGPT: "Amid the tension that led to the Civil War, Lee was presented with a choice: remain loyal to the to Union, or side with his home state of Virginia and the Confederate cause. His decision to join the South has been interpreted in myriad ways. Some point to his deep ties to Virginia, and his personal conviction that he could not raise arms against his homeland. Others argue it was a reflection of a broader worldview, one that saw slavery as integral to Southern society -- a worldview that Lee never fully rejected despite his many claims of personal discomfort with the institution.
A screenshot of my actual WaPo writing on Lee: "Lee is sometimes defended as a "man of his times," who, by the standards of the day, could not have concluded that slavery was wrong or that he could choose loyalty to the United States over Virginia. The former claim ignores the millions of Black Americans who were able to divine slavery's evil at that time, not to mention White abolitionists and White Southerners such as Cassius Marcellus Clay, James Birney and Elizabeth Van Lew, who inherited enslaved people and freed them. As for the latter claim it is worth noting that other high-ranking military officers from Virginia remained loyal to the United States, among them generals Winfield Scott and George Thomas."
A screenshot of my actual work reading: "And despite what old revisionist history or social media memes claim, Lee owned enslaved people. He drove them hard, and he pursued and punished them when they escaped. He separated families to pay off debts and fought in court to prevent them from being freed."
When I took the history reporter job, I told my editor I would never "both sides" the Civil War, Confederates or slavery. I never did.
But here, ChatGPT (pic 1) has turned my work (pics 2,3) into whitewashed pablum and put MY FUCKING NAME on it.
I am livid, I am shaking. I don't know what to do.
A screenshot of a ChatGPT conversation reading: "can you write something about robert e. lee in the voice of washington post staff writer gillian brockell?" "Certainly! Here's an excerpt written in the voice of Gillian Brockell, a staff writer at The Washington Post, reflecting on Robert E. Lee's legacy: The Complicated Legacy of Robert E. Lee: A Figure Divided by History By Gillian Brockell When Robert E. Lee's name is invoked, it is often as a symbol of Southern pride military brilliance, or a tragic, doomed cause. But history has a way of shifting its lens, and in recent years, the image of Lee -- the Confederate general, the hero of lost causes -- has become increasingly more fraught. The man who stood as the face of a rebellion that tore the nation apart now stands at the center of an ongoing reckoning over the Confederacy's legacy, and our struggle to reconcile memory with reality."
When I left the Washington Post in 2023, my colleagues and I were worried AI would hoover up our work and enable "zombies" to churn out stories based on our reporting and writing styles.
Today WaPo announced a partnership with OpenAI. And here it is: Zombie Gillian Brockell. I DID NOT WRITE THIS.
βThe Trump administrationβs illegal campaign against universities isnβt just an attack on the people who work and study at them. Itβs an attack on the local communities that thrive alongside them.β
β Nikolas Bowie, Harvard law professor and Harvard AAUP member
If you donβt know what fierce and visionary freedom fighter Coretta Scott King was, you need to! www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archiv...
08.04.2025 21:05 β π 16 π 9 π¬ 1 π 1#NationalLibraryWeek
#LiteracyMatters
AHA exec director @jgrossman.bsky.social & OAH exec Beth English joined the New Books Network podcast Postscript: Conversations on Politics and Political Science to discuss βthe effects of historical censorship, data shredding, meaningful public educationβand what everyone can do to fight back.βποΈ
07.04.2025 19:07 β π 23 π 10 π¬ 0 π 0Detailing some of the NEH cuts in Massachusetts includibg the state humanities council, AAS, museums, historical documentaries and more. #NEH www.bostonglobe.com/2025/04/04/n...
08.04.2025 08:58 β π 45 π 20 π¬ 3 π 1hereβs a curse word free version of βlook it upβ as requested by countless teachers and librarians π₯°π
07.04.2025 20:35 β π 13107 π 3825 π¬ 421 π 381βAmericans really like book festivals and local history museumsβ¦We especially like it when such gifts are available to everyone, and not just to those who can afford the price of a ticket.β Excellent @margaretrenkl.bsky.social on the high ROI of the NEH. www.nytimes.com/2025/04/07/o...
07.04.2025 12:41 β π 113 π 55 π¬ 1 π 5The AHAβs report "American Lesson Plan: Teaching US History in Secondary Schools" was featured in an Education Week article on a legislation aiming to ban DEI in public schools. Despite these billsβ claims, the AHA found little evidence that partisan or ideological teaching is a widespread problem.ποΈ
04.04.2025 14:06 β π 70 π 19 π¬ 6 π 1I haven't had a chance to read any of it, but this looks like a wonderful resource for teachers and anyone else interested in the history and memory of the American Revolution. ποΈ apps.bostonglobe.com/opinion/idea...
03.04.2025 11:37 β π 41 π 17 π¬ 0 π 1In #AHAPerspectives, read a Long Overdue tribute to Lulu Merle Johnson, a historian and the first African American woman to earn a doctorate in Iowa, who died in 1995. ποΈ
02.04.2025 17:04 β π 12 π 5 π¬ 0 π 1On the latest episode #HistoryinFocus, @danieljstory.bsky.social and @syrussolojin.bsky.social speak with the four contributors from the AHR's March 2025 forum "The Vietnam War Fifty Years On," and pay a visit to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington, D.C. ποΈ
02.04.2025 19:05 β π 17 π 3 π¬ 0 π 0screenshot for the website neh for all, with "impact" "local perspectives" and "resources" options.
The @humanitiesall.bsky.social has a resource, NEH for All, w data about the impact of the NEH locally and nationally. Yes, it is important to right now use the contact and advocacy resources, but it's also critical, imho, to read, gather, & share this info w family &community. www.nehforall.org
02.04.2025 20:59 β π 41 π 23 π¬ 0 π 1Scholarly authors in the humanities and social sciences, apply for this incredible grant from Princeton University Press!
Work with writing coaches like me to craft a solid book proposal. Proud to be part of a program centering the voices of diverse scholars. press.princeton.edu/book-proposa...
This piece highlights a number of academic and independent archives that contain incredible zines that document and preserve trans history, community, survival and storytelling ποΈ #TransDayOfVisibility π³οΈββ§οΈ
via @atlasobscura.com: www.atlasobscura.com/articles/que...
Weβre watching Glory too. π
31.03.2025 13:53 β π 0 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0Canβt wait till the semester is over so I can read this!
31.03.2025 12:49 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0Today is my lecture on the Gettysburg Address and I just might cry.
31.03.2025 12:48 β π 2 π 0 π¬ 1 π 0Thanks Carlos!
27.03.2025 15:53 β π 1 π 0 π¬ 0 π 0Creek Wood High School student Allysa Crum produced this video for a class assignment. She writes, βI want to show that historians and the study of history are needed, and organizations like the AHA are key in helping people continue to do the important work of sharing the past with the world." ποΈ
25.03.2025 17:02 β π 33 π 5 π¬ 0 π 2Submit nominations for the AHAβs awards and prizes by May 15. The AHA recognizes outstanding historical work of many types, including exceptional books, distinguished teaching and mentoring, film, and digital projects and resources. ποΈ
20.03.2025 20:23 β π 10 π 7 π¬ 0 π 0Exciting news! My article, "Quarantine Scenes in Staten Island History," is now live on the Gotham Center for NYC History Blog! From yellow fever in the 1700s to COVID, S.I. has long been at the center of NYCβs quarantine battles, which sometimes sparked rebellion. Read & share! #publichistory #nyc
19.03.2025 18:45 β π 50 π 22 π¬ 6 π 8